Pie & Piston Is there a Saloon Bar and Public Bar?
Pie & Piston Is there a Saloon Bar and Public Bar?
Author
Discussion

Dr Strangelove

Original Poster:

419 posts

249 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all
I had an idea if there isn't.

Maybe we could designate one of each as say, The Salloon Bar' for Serious topic. Whereby the author doesn't want to read the witty asides and diversions, but would rather the thread be conducted in a sober manner. Threads seeking straightforward advice for example.

The other bar however could be designated as the 'Public Bar' where people are no bothered how their threads may spin out.

It's probably impractical and diversive to have seperate forums. But maybe we could have a different message Icon for each one.

what do you lot think (I know you're going to be tempted, but resist just this once, this is a 'Saloon Bar' question...

What does Ted think?

MilnerR

8,273 posts

274 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all
Dr Strangelove said:


What does Ted think?



Pies, TVR reliability?

The pie and piston has worked well, but i'm not sure about splitting it any more. We're going to end up with a forum for each member! I quite like the way the pie and piston has such a variety of topics.

>> Edited by MilnerR on Friday 7th January 20:11

Balmoral Green

42,394 posts

264 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

271 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all
Great idea....could also have....

the bog for rude stuff......

the restaurant for all the cooking stuff that's been popping up.......

the cellar for rodent lovers......

and the car park.......

for.....errr........

car related stuff.........

simpo two

89,225 posts

281 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all
Ummm - how about 'Idle Chatter With Of No Great Meaning' and 'Interesting Stuff About Things'?

Unfortunately 'IQ <100' and IQ >100' wouldn't be much use as I'm sure every PHer clears the 100 hurdle with ease!

Dr Strangelove

Original Poster:

419 posts

249 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all
OK, maybe just a 'Saloon Bar' icon for a topic that the author would rather not consist of 50% half-liners' is all i'm suggesting, it may avoid a sensible debate turning into a nonsense debate, which of course there would be room for sans icon... I'm not advocating it's mandatory.

What does the Landlord think of it?

sirtophamhat

1,072 posts

254 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:


and the car park.......

for.....errr........

car related stuff.........


We could have the car park to settle disputes when things get out of hand in other threads.

Flat in Fifth

46,898 posts

267 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all
sirtophamhat said:

We could have the car park to settle disputes when things get out of hand in other threads.

With a virtual van full of plod parked round the corner in SP&L, in fact just like Broad Street most nights.

towman

14,938 posts

255 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all
Be nice to me - I deliver the food and drink!

Dr Strangelove

Original Poster:

419 posts

249 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all
MilnerR said:

Dr Strangelove said:


What does Ted think?




Pies, TVR reliability?

The pie and piston has worked well, but i'm not sure about splitting it any more. We're going to end up with a forum for each member! I quite like the way the pie and piston has such a variety of topics.

>> Edited by MilnerR on Friday 7th January 20:11


I don't see how it would alter the variety of topics, just bring some rigour to some of the threads that are interesting and stimulating to begin, but can often reduce to an outake from a channel 5 pilotless crapcom script...

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

271 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all
Ooooooh......handbags at dawn, ducky.....

alfaman

6,416 posts

250 months

Friday 7th January 2005
quotequote all
sirtophamhat said:

mybrainhurts said:


and the car park.......

for.....errr........

car related stuff.........



We could have the car park to settle disputes when things get out of hand in other threads.


Wot I was thinking - bit of fisticuffs, handbags or slapping