Red Cross Donations
Author
Discussion

budfox

Original Poster:

1,510 posts

160 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
Just had a very polite young lady at the door asking for donations to the Red Cross. Clearly an official collector and I couldn't fault her dedication on a cold and dark night.

But... their chief executive earns well over £180k, a figure which the young volunteer clearly wasn't aware of, and it was for that reason I wasn't prepared to donate anything.

I've no doubt that Mr Big is very good at his job, and that the Red Cross do some valuable work, but with the rich getting richer by the day and the rest of us getting poorer, I'm just not prepared to give money away.

As another perspective, Sky TV have just agreed to pay £1bn/year to cover premiership football. A figure that would fee every child in Africa for at least five years.

I'd be interested in the PH collective opinion on this.

R1gtr

3,443 posts

185 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
Obviously they do some great work but to be honest I am sick to death of the Red Cross, having donated before, they are constantly sending me ste thru the post asking for more money, addressed and also regular unaddressed post.
It is not so much the letters that annoy me it is the fact they all include a pen, a badge or sometimes even coasters or such tat.

How much do they spend on sending out all this st? If I donate I want every penny to go to the needy, I don't want them spending my money on sending me coasters as a fking thank you

Justayellowbadge

37,057 posts

273 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
budfox said:
Just had a very polite young lady at the door asking for donations to the Red Cross. Clearly an official collector and I couldn't fault her dedication on a cold and dark night.

But... their chief executive earns well over £180k, a figure which the young volunteer clearly wasn't aware of, and it was for that reason I wasn't prepared to donate anything.

I've no doubt that Mr Big is very good at his job, and that the Red Cross do some valuable work, but with the rich getting richer by the day and the rest of us getting poorer, I'm just not prepared to give money away.

As another perspective, Sky TV have just agreed to pay £1bn/year to cover premiership football. A figure that would fee every child in Africa for at least five years.

I'd be interested in the PH collective opinion on this.
I would wish an organization I cared about to be in good hands.

180k does not seem a great deal for a chief executive. If they are delivering it's a bargain.

If the person in charge of a charity earns 5 mil, but brings in 50 mil, then they are worth it.


Troubleatmill

10,210 posts

190 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
She could be working for a chugger organisation.
You give £5 a month... A large percentage of that goes to the chugger organisation.

budfox

Original Poster:

1,510 posts

160 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
Troubleatmill said:
She could be working for a chugger organisation.
You give £5 a month... A large percentage of that goes to the chugger organisation.
Yes, that occurred to me too. At least I didn't get shot down in flames here.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
budfox said:
...A figure that would fee every child in Africa for at least five years...

I'd be interested in the PH collective opinion on this.
I thought we as the western world fixed Africa in 85 with Live Aid. Or was it in '05 when we saved it again when old Gordo mcWinky Broon "wiped the debt"

Or maybe it was last Christmas when they re-released that track.Exactly. It's still the same as it ever was!

Honestly. And this is going to come across as crass to some of the hand ringers. I could give a st about Africa anymore. Nothing the western world does makes any difference, I'm sure it's all very complicated but 2 things come to my mind.

1) We have inadvertently created a region completely dependent on our hand outs.

and

2) Having watched a programme about NGOs (non governmental organisations) where they go to a village and paint the walls and offer the people another stand pump in the middle then put up plaques saying how great they are, then claim they are helping. All they are doing is prolonging their poverty with fluff, rather than making sweeping fundamental changes.

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
Troubleatmill said:
She could be working for a chugger organisation.
You give £5 a month... A large percentage of that goes to the chugger organisation.
20 -33 % over the first three years of giving , 0-5 % after that

but never let the truth get i nthe way of selfish rant

GreenDog

2,261 posts

223 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
mph1977 said:
Troubleatmill said:
She could be working for a chugger organisation.
You give £5 a month... A large percentage of that goes to the chugger organisation.
20 -33 % over the first three years of giving , 0-5 % after that

but never let the truth get i nthe way of selfish rant
Isn' 20 - 30% a large percentage then ? I'd say it is.

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
GreenDog said:
mph1977 said:
Troubleatmill said:
She could be working for a chugger organisation.
You give £5 a month... A large percentage of that goes to the chugger organisation.
20 -33 % over the first three years of giving , 0-5 % after that

but never let the truth get i nthe way of selfish rant
Isn' 20 - 30% a large percentage then ? I'd say it is.
the implication of many of those who question the use of paid staff for fundraising is that the chairty sees a minorty of the money raised , rather than them getting a majority of it from day 1

also would you rather see volunteers fundraising and paid staff doing all the service provision ?

tim0409

5,987 posts

190 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
I vowed never to donate to the Red Cross after reading this some time ago -

A Glasgow theatre has had to change a pantomime costume after being told it was breaking the Geneva Convention.

The dress worn by Nurse Poltis in the Pavilion Theatre production of Robin Hood originally had red crosses on the hat and tunic.

These were changed to green crosses after the British Red Cross informed the theatre it was breaking the law and could face prosecution.

Unauthorised use of the emblem violates the Geneva Conventions Act 1957.

The British Red Cross said it had contacted the Pavilion Theatre over the use of a red cross on a nurse's costume in the pantomime, The Magical Adventures of Robin Hood.

"Misuse of that emblem - even when done in an innocent and light-hearted manner - has to be addressed. Repeated and widespread misuse of the Red Cross emblem could dilute its neutrality and its ability to protect.

"When we contacted the theatre management, they quickly changed the cross on the nurse's costume to green and we applaud them for that."

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
tim0409 said:
I vowed never to donate to the Red Cross after reading this some time ago -

A Glasgow theatre has had to change a pantomime costume after being told it was breaking the Geneva Convention.

The dress worn by Nurse Poltis in the Pavilion Theatre production of Robin Hood originally had red crosses on the hat and tunic.

These were changed to green crosses after the British Red Cross informed the theatre it was breaking the law and could face prosecution.

Unauthorised use of the emblem violates the Geneva Conventions Act 1957.

The British Red Cross said it had contacted the Pavilion Theatre over the use of a red cross on a nurse's costume in the pantomime, The Magical Adventures of Robin Hood.

"Misuse of that emblem - even when done in an innocent and light-hearted manner - has to be addressed. Repeated and widespread misuse of the Red Cross emblem could dilute its neutrality and its ability to protect.

"When we contacted the theatre management, they quickly changed the cross on the nurse's costume to green and we applaud them for that."
it's actually the MoD that is the enforcement organisation for the use of the Protective Device, mis use of the Protective Device is a serious matter ...

I'm guessing you have no professional involvement in healthcare and either haven;t servied in the forces or tossed it off during Laws of Armed COmbat sessions as part of MATTs

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Monday 23rd February 2015
quotequote all
BRC annual report 2013

http://www.scribd.com/doc/224119611/2013-Trustees-...


pg 33

"We spent £231.7m in 2013 and all of this expenditure ultimately goes towards helping those in crisis, be it expenditure directly on our charitable activities or expenditure to secure our future income.
>
Expenditure on our charitable activities was up 13 per cent to £155.1m. Our achievements with this expenditure are set out throughout this report.
>
Governance costs increased slightly to £3.1m. These include our annual subscription of £2m to the International Federation of the Red Cross."

67% of expenditure on charitable outcomes

21 % on generating voluntary income

11 % on generating retail income ( i.e. the cost of running the charity shops and generating their stock)

1 % on governance

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 24th February 2015
quotequote all
tim0409 said:
I vowed never to donate to the Red Cross after reading this some time ago -

A Glasgow theatre has had to change a pantomime costume after being told it was breaking the Geneva Convention.

The dress worn by Nurse Poltis in the Pavilion Theatre production of Robin Hood originally had red crosses on the hat and tunic.

These were changed to green crosses after the British Red Cross informed the theatre it was breaking the law and could face prosecution.

Unauthorised use of the emblem violates the Geneva Conventions Act 1957.

The British Red Cross said it had contacted the Pavilion Theatre over the use of a red cross on a nurse's costume in the pantomime, The Magical Adventures of Robin Hood.

"Misuse of that emblem - even when done in an innocent and light-hearted manner - has to be addressed. Repeated and widespread misuse of the Red Cross emblem could dilute its neutrality and its ability to protect.

"When we contacted the theatre management, they quickly changed the cross on the nurse's costume to green and we applaud them for that."
Similar thing happened to EON Productions after a helicopter appeared in The Living Daylights bearing a red cross. On that occasion it was portraying an air ambulance and was a simple case of cinematic license but even that wasn't good enough for the Red Cross, and the film now carries a disclaimer before the opening credits stating that the appearance of the emblem is in no way meant to represent the organisation. Good to see they've got their eye on the really important stuff.....

condor

8,837 posts

279 months

Tuesday 24th February 2015
quotequote all
budfox said:
Troubleatmill said:
She could be working for a chugger organisation.
You give £5 a month... A large percentage of that goes to the chugger organisation.
Yes, that occurred to me too. At least I didn't get shot down in flames here.
A friend of mine had a red cross tabarded chugger turn up at his door. He pointed out to her that she was in a 'no cold calling zone' and she shouldn't be wearing the red cross emblem as it was protected. In small writing on bottom of the tabard was working for chugging organisation.

Silver Smudger

3,395 posts

198 months

Tuesday 24th February 2015
quotequote all
I assume that all those objecting to the way charities are run are just taking their cash directly to the needy all over the world and saving the Red Cross the bother.

RobinOakapple

2,802 posts

143 months

Tuesday 24th February 2015
quotequote all
If there was a charity that was dedicated to spreading effective birth control far and wide, I would contribute gladly.

Lost soul

8,712 posts

213 months

Tuesday 24th February 2015
quotequote all
budfox said:
Just had a very polite young lady at the door asking for donations to the Red Cross. Clearly an official collector and I couldn't fault her dedication on a cold and dark night.

But... their chief executive earns well over £180k, a figure which the young volunteer clearly wasn't aware of, and it was for that reason I wasn't prepared to donate anything.

I've no doubt that Mr Big is very good at his job, and that the Red Cross do some valuable work, but with the rich getting richer by the day and the rest of us getting poorer, I'm just not prepared to give money away.

As another perspective, Sky TV have just agreed to pay £1bn/year to cover premiership football. A figure that would fee every child in Africa for at least five years.

I'd be interested in the PH collective opinion on this.
I feel exactly the same way as you

Lost soul

8,712 posts

213 months

Tuesday 24th February 2015
quotequote all
tim0409 said:
IThe British Red Cross said it had contacted the Pavilion Theatre over the use of a red cross on a nurse's costume in the pantomime, The Magical Adventures of Robin Hood.

"Misuse of that emblem - even when done in an innocent and light-hearted manner - has to be addressed. Repeated and widespread misuse of the Red Cross emblem could dilute its neutrality and its ability to protect.

"When we contacted the theatre management, they quickly changed the cross on the nurse's costume to green and we applaud them for that."
I guess that's to stop fraudulent collecting , but yes it is a bit stupid

mph1977

12,467 posts

199 months

Tuesday 24th February 2015
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
ad agencies and paying for the collectors will be part of the 21 % as will costs directly attributable to the
fundraising activities

expenditure on wages / overheads / rent etc for delivery of charitable purposes will be accounted for within thhat

governance costs will be accounted for in the governance costs noted ...

oddly enopugh the large charities are usually scrupulously accurate in their accounjting especially once you reach the area level and above ( and increasingly the locla service provision units / teams are in such a position that the old days of bungs and bribes to locla worthies and greasy palsm cannot continue to be operated )


iphonedyou

10,425 posts

188 months

Tuesday 24th February 2015
quotequote all
What has Sky's payment for rights to Premiership football coverage got to do with Africa?