Young drivers; telematics boxes & insurance - your experience?
Young drivers; telematics boxes & insurance - your experience?
Author
Discussion

shoestring7

Original Poster:

6,196 posts

277 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
A young member of my family is looking to buy his first car and inevitably it'll be a small engined hatchback. Insurance will just as inevitably be very expensive, but its clear from trying out scenarios on Compare the Market etc. that agreeing to have a telematics box fitted potentially brings a decent reduction in premium.

Thing is, he's already a bit of a petrolhead and is worried that he'll have to drive like nun - no fast cornering or braking etc. and is really against the idea.

His parents are ambivalent; the idea that he'll have to constantly have to think about his 'score' is no bad thing, and they'll help him out by taking him to parties etc. so he doesn't break the curfew.

I know these have been around for a while now; do any young drivers want to share their experiences for and against?

cheers,

SS7

Sycamore

2,218 posts

149 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
I'm 20 and had one on all 3 of my past cars, an Astra, a C4 and my current Smart Roadster. I didn't pay the slightest bit of attention to the score, and as it works on averages, it didn't cause an issue. In fact Co-op gave me a 30% discount on my policy after 3 months for good driving.

Most my commute is through inner city traffic so it was difficult to drive "aggressively" anyway, so it's not all too bad.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all


Youngster apologising for baulking other traffic because Box Says No.

Great idea...rolleyes

thelawnet

1,539 posts

186 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Depends how much he can save. Also look at adding the parents as named driver, if that reduces premium.

I wouldn't, unless there was a substantial saving

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Sunday 1st March 2015
quotequote all
Research recent bad press about insurance companies abusing the scheme and ripping drivers off.

sebhaque

6,536 posts

212 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
Very coincidental this thread should pop up tonight, of all nights. I was driving back home from seeing a few friends, taking it easy on a pleasant Sunday evening. I was approaching a roundabout and saw a car coming up from the left very quick. Anticipated a problem so I covered the brake pedal - sure enough, the bint driving shot straight out into the roundabout causing me to hit the brakes (I was in a Mk1 MX-5), locking up, and nearly ending up in the oncoming lane. I composed myself and carried on driving, eventually pulling up next to the other car at the next set of lights. I knocked on her window and, given my nearly-binned-it state, gave her a few sharp words about how not to drive and how to avoid killing people. Her baby on board sticker was useful ammunition.

Her response? She started crying and said she was sorry. She didn't want to stop because she had a black box fitted and it would penalise her if she braked too hard, so she decided to to brake and "just carry on driving as it'd be safer".

It's a sad state of affairs when young drivers think it's safer to pull out in front of a fking car than actually use their brakes. An MX-5 isn't going to do much damage, but I hope my strong verbal makes her think twice before she decides to dive out in front of a 44-tonner and get her baby laminated across the tarmac.

ETA: Before anybody decides to take a potshot about me locking up, I was more concerened about the potential infant on board; since I was travelling at around 25mph by the time I'd made sure I was clear of her car and gauged the rest of my surroundings (tunnel vision manifests itself rapidly), I was near enough stopped.

Edited by sebhaque on Monday 2nd March 00:04

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
Strewth.

As I said...great idea.

Leicester Loyal

5,062 posts

153 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
Had one fitted to my MK4 Golf since I was 18, I'm 21 now and can't wait to get rid of the thing come renewal. I can't complain though, it has saved me a fortune compared to insurance without the box. The company I went with was co-o.

Countdown

49,589 posts

227 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
It reduced my daughter's premium by £700 in year 1 and a further £900 in Year 2. Worth doing IMO

TheAngryDog

13,316 posts

240 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
Im so glad I aren't a new driver these days! Back when I was 18 (some 16 years ago nearly) £1200 got me insured on a 2.0 DOHC Sierra Sapphire as my first car!

Dannbodge

2,393 posts

152 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
sebhaque said:
Very coincidental this thread should pop up tonight, of all nights. I was driving back home from seeing a few friends, taking it easy on a pleasant Sunday evening. I was approaching a roundabout and saw a car coming up from the left very quick. Anticipated a problem so I covered the brake pedal - sure enough, the bint driving shot straight out into the roundabout causing me to hit the brakes (I was in a Mk1 MX-5), locking up, and nearly ending up in the oncoming lane. I composed myself and carried on driving, eventually pulling up next to the other car at the next set of lights. I knocked on her window and, given my nearly-binned-it state, gave her a few sharp words about how not to drive and how to avoid killing people. Her baby on board sticker was useful ammunition.

Her response? She started crying and said she was sorry. She didn't want to stop because she had a black box fitted and it would penalise her if she braked too hard, so she decided to to brake and "just carry on driving as it'd be safer".

It's a sad state of affairs when young drivers think it's safer to pull out in front of a fking car than actually use their brakes. An MX-5 isn't going to do much damage, but I hope my strong verbal makes her think twice before she decides to dive out in front of a 44-tonner and get her baby laminated across the tarmac.

ETA: Before anybody decides to take a potshot about me locking up, I was more concerened about the potential infant on board; since I was travelling at around 25mph by the time I'd made sure I was clear of her car and gauged the rest of my surroundings (tunnel vision manifests itself rapidly), I was near enough stopped.

Edited by sebhaque on Monday 2nd March 00:04
Sorry but that's bullst.

She should have been anticipating the roundabout and slowing down anyway. That's a combination of poor driving (lack of experience?) and the black box. She was obviously not paying enough attention to the road/conditions ahead

Alucidnation

16,810 posts

201 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
Brilliant idea imo.

We saved a lot of money when our first started learning to drive, and are just about to save more now that our second is about to start.

After doing several comparisons with and without boxes, it was a no brainer.

budfox

1,510 posts

160 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
My objections are on the basis of personal liberty. The young driver thing is the thin end of the wedge. Eventually all cars will have these things built in at manufacture and all of the car's use will be monitored and recorded all of the time. Data will exist from every journey driving and part of that data will be used by insurance companies to charge you accordingly.

Mad? Well who'd have believed that Samsung (and other) TV's would be recording your private conversations and sending them to a 3rd party, or that Microsoft's X-Box camera would be watching you all day?

It's happening people, 1984 and worse by stealth.

V8forweekends

2,506 posts

155 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
budfox said:
My objections are on the basis of personal liberty. The young driver thing is the thin end of the wedge. Eventually all cars will have these things built in at manufacture and all of the car's use will be monitored and recorded all of the time. Data will exist from every journey driving and part of that data will be used by insurance companies to charge you accordingly.

Mad? Well who'd have believed that Samsung (and other) TV's would be recording your private conversations and sending them to a 3rd party, or that Microsoft's X-Box camera would be watching you all day?

It's happening people, 1984 and worse by stealth.

It'll be worse than that actually - it'll be automated NIPs and letters from HMRC saying there's a 50 mile discrepancy between your mileage claims and actual mileage for the year and since they can't be arsed to get any money of big corporations, here's a fine.

And plenty of ahole people in this country will be saying (like they did for ID cards) "if you've done nothing wrong, you've nothing to fear".

And sales of tinfoil will be regulated.

I am only half joking smile

Edited by V8forweekends on Monday 2nd March 08:32

TwigtheWonderkid

49,294 posts

181 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
sebhaque said:
Very coincidental this thread should pop up tonight, of all nights. I was driving back home from seeing a few friends, taking it easy on a pleasant Sunday evening. I was approaching a roundabout and saw a car coming up from the left very quick. Anticipated a problem so I covered the brake pedal - sure enough, the bint driving shot straight out into the roundabout causing me to hit the brakes (I was in a Mk1 MX-5), locking up, and nearly ending up in the oncoming lane. I composed myself and carried on driving, eventually pulling up next to the other car at the next set of lights. I knocked on her window and, given my nearly-binned-it state, gave her a few sharp words about how not to drive and how to avoid killing people. Her baby on board sticker was useful ammunition.

Her response? She started crying and said she was sorry. She didn't want to stop because she had a black box fitted and it would penalise her if she braked too hard, so she decided to to brake and "just carry on driving as it'd be safer".

It's a sad state of affairs when young drivers think it's safer to pull out in front of a fking car than actually use their brakes. An MX-5 isn't going to do much damage, but I hope my strong verbal makes her think twice before she decides to dive out in front of a 44-tonner and get her baby laminated across the tarmac.

ETA: Before anybody decides to take a potshot about me locking up, I was more concerened about the potential infant on board; since I was travelling at around 25mph by the time I'd made sure I was clear of her car and gauged the rest of my surroundings (tunnel vision manifests itself rapidly), I was near enough stopped.

Edited by sebhaque on Monday 2nd March 00:04
All that proves is that the black box does not cure complete idiocy. One instance of sharp breaking wouldn't matter a jot on a black box data recorder, but a fault accident will have a much bigger effect. This woman is too stupid to have a licence, black box or no black box.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,294 posts

181 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
budfox said:
My objections are on the basis of personal liberty. The young driver thing is the thin end of the wedge. Eventually all cars will have these things built in at manufacture and all of the car's use will be monitored and recorded all of the time. Data will exist from every journey driving and part of that data will be used by insurance companies to charge you accordingly.
Well everyone moans about insurance companies lumping them in will all the other idiots and not treating them as an individual. So what's your problem?

Black boxes have been around for around 10 yrs now. When they were first launched the tin foil hat brigade were saying within a few years we'd all have them. A decade later and it's still a niche product taken up by mainly young drivers only.

shoestring7

Original Poster:

6,196 posts

277 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
Sycamore said:
I'm 20 and had one on all 3 of my past cars, an Astra, a C4 and my current Smart Roadster. I didn't pay the slightest bit of attention to the score, and as it works on averages, it didn't cause an issue. In fact Co-op gave me a 30% discount on my policy after 3 months for good driving.

Most my commute is through inner city traffic so it was difficult to drive "aggressively" anyway, so it's not all too bad.
Thanks that's the sort of thing I was after, rather than scare stories about young drivers blaming the 'box' for their mistakes or 'thin edge of the wedge' arguments.

How did the Co-op give you feedback of your driving? Did you feel constrained at all? How did your experience compare with friends who didn't have one?

FWIW from what I understand, for a 1.2l hatchback, a policy with telematics is around £1300 vs £2000 for one without. That's a big difference when you're 17 and trying to pay for it by working in a shop at the weekends (and actually afford the social life your car is supposed to be needed for).

SS7

berlintaxi

8,535 posts

204 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
My son has one fitted in his KA, new driver, passed in Dec 2013, saved him a fortune on insurance. He is able to access a dashboard on line that gives him his scores never been marked down even though like all new drivers he has made the odd cock up, he has received some rebates based on the scores, he has no issue with it being fitted.

For info he is with Bell.

As for Seb's tale above,rolleyes

TwigtheWonderkid

49,294 posts

181 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Research recent bad press about insurance companies abusing the scheme and ripping drivers off.
See stories on this thread about insurers handing back rebates.

Zingari

947 posts

204 months

Monday 2nd March 2015
quotequote all
I'm not so sure about them disregarding the stats if you go into 'amber' or 'red' in any of the areas - braking/accelleration/cornering/speeding

My daughter has one and Ingenie send an email every month with her feedback scores. You literally have to drive like a nun (especially very slow cornering) to get a 'green' across the board but so far at each quarter we have got c£50 rebate. (£1,600 annual for Mini One). However it's not all plain sailing.

If you read the T+C get so many 'reds' each month and you can either have extra payments levied or have your policy cancelled - declaring the latter to a new insurer is about as popular as ebola! Also every time somebody else drives the car and like me having changed the brakes and go out to test them in 'safe' conditons she gets a 'red' warning for dangereous braking! When I contacted them to explain I had to fax off the receipts for the brake parts and give a time/date/location where I tested the brakes to have the record erased. Complete PITA

If it saves a few hundred pounds go for it but be advised these boxes are very very accurate. ACPO guidelines for speeding may be 10%+2mph but not these things.