Which small automatic hatchback for ultimate reliability?
Which small automatic hatchback for ultimate reliability?
Author
Discussion

BritishRacinGrin

Original Poster:

26,708 posts

191 months

Sunday 8th March 2015
quotequote all
Boring as hell I know but I ran out of ideas when Honda Jazz was rejected because it's an old person's car. Somebody please help me.

Only other considerations apart from those already mentionned is that it can't be noticably bigger than a mk2 Clio but must have simular boot space due to dog.

PapaJohns

1,064 posts

184 months

Sunday 8th March 2015
quotequote all
I had a 1series that was an auto , didn't have any problems with it

folos

900 posts

173 months

Sunday 8th March 2015
quotequote all
Nissan Micra.

BritishRacinGrin

Original Poster:

26,708 posts

191 months

Sunday 8th March 2015
quotequote all
A 1-series would be wasted on her, besides probably being 'too big' and having a 'small boot' (due to superior RWD layout).

Micra? If the Jazz was an 'old person's car'...

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Sunday 8th March 2015
quotequote all
Lexus CT200h

Toyota prius

Maybe too "big" ridiculous to discount them purely on that basis though.

BritishRacinGrin

Original Poster:

26,708 posts

191 months

Sunday 8th March 2015
quotequote all
dave_s13 said:

Maybe too "big" ridiculous to discount them purely on that basis though.
Female logic.

J4CKO

47,095 posts

231 months

Sunday 8th March 2015
quotequote all
So the requirement is the definition of the "old persons car" (small auto), that doesn't look like an "old persons car" ?

What is the budget ?

Polo/Golf/Audi A1 with a DSG Box ?

C1/Aygo/107 can be had with an auto, might be a touch slow/tinny though

Skoda Fabia
Clio







Sheepshanks

41,372 posts

150 months

Sunday 8th March 2015
quotequote all
BritishRacinGrin said:
Boring as hell I know but I ran out of ideas when Honda Jazz was rejected because it's an old person's car. Somebody please help me.
Pity Honda doesn't sell the RS Sport and Mugen models here: http://www.honda.co.nz/cars/jazz/view/colours/

RHD too! That's the "new" Jazz, by the way - out everywhere except Europe.

My missus wasn't keen on Jazz as first, but when it came time to change it she didn't even want to look at anything else. Our daughter has one too, and so does the fit young mum down the road. smile


BritishRacinGrin said:
Only other considerations apart from those already mentionned is that it can't be noticably bigger than a mk2 Clio but must have similar boot space due to dog.
What about Captur?

ETA: Sorry - I was forgetting the "ultimate reliability" requirement.

Edited by Sheepshanks on Sunday 8th March 12:29

rallycross

13,763 posts

268 months

Sunday 8th March 2015
quotequote all
whats your budget?
A suzuki swift 1.5 auto is probably the most reliable thing you will find (even more so than a Jazz) and they drive nicely - a but like mini, good handling, enough go to be fun, plus its an old fashioned 4 speed auto which is nice and smooth and works just fine - far better than a horrible CVT box as per the Jazz and not jerky in traffic like the dsg as per the VW's.

Sheepshanks

41,372 posts

150 months

Sunday 8th March 2015
quotequote all
rallycross said:
...far better than a horrible CVT box as per the Jazz.
I've driven CVT Jazz a few times and thought it was absolutely fine.

They did an I-Shift automated manual box for a couple of years - 2009 to 2011 ish - and that's generally regarded as horrible.

Superhoop

4,919 posts

224 months

Sunday 8th March 2015
quotequote all
Mazda2 auto?

The petrol engines are as reliable as they come as are the auto gearboxes, doesn't look like an old persons car and the Mazda2 my mum had was actually a really nice thing to drive.

culpz

4,966 posts

143 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
If you're gonna get an auto you might as well get something VAG with a well renowned double-clutch box. That's what i'd personally go for. Fabia DSG would be perfect i reckon. Decent choice of engines to choose from to work with the gearbox too. Could even go for a VRS if you want something more along the lines of a hot hatch.

LordHaveMurci

12,338 posts

200 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
Aston Martin Cygnet has to be the answer surely?!

Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

198 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
I've no driven an auto Jazz of either flavour, but bloody love my manual one.

Hasbeen

2,073 posts

252 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
The Mazda 2 is about as good as shopping trolleys get.

My lady treats a car as a bit of rubbish. Her auto gave low 7L/100Km economy for 188,000 kilometres, with nothing but servicing.

DUMBO100

1,878 posts

215 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
We bought my Granny a VW High Up 5dr ASG and she loves it. I'm not so sure about the gearbox as it is a bit clunky but she's very happy with it

DUMBO100

1,878 posts

215 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
Ps the VW Polo gets a proper DSG and would be my choice

Sheepshanks

41,372 posts

150 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
Those suggesting VAG cars are missing the bit where the OP asks for "ultimate reliability". We had a SEAT Ibiza and thank Goodness it came with 5yrs breakdown cover.

belleair302

7,015 posts

238 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
Ford Fiesta Ecoboost automatic or a Kia Piccanta. Both are well built, reliable, easy to drive, fun all things considered and look fresh.

Mafffew

2,149 posts

142 months

Monday 9th March 2015
quotequote all
belleair302 said:
Ford Fiesta Ecoboost automatic or a Kia Piccanta. Both are well built, reliable, easy to drive, fun all things considered and look fresh.
Sadly the Fiesta's auto box is censored. If you're getting a Fiesta, it needs to be manual.