Another what car thread.

[Driver101]

Currently got a 335i which I'm looking to change for something new.

After some thought, I've come down to an Audi S3 saloon, BMW M235i or the A45 AMG.

I've never been the biggest of Audi fans, but I really like the look of the S3 saloon. I've driven the hatch and liked it, so I'd imagine the saloon is very much the same?

The M235i isn't quite as good looking as I'd want. However it offers a lot and there is sizeable discounts on offer just looking at dealer websites.

Then there is the little A45. It's got a lot of flaws and a silly price, but I'm strangely drawn to it and it's also what she likes the most.

Would it be mad to go for the A45? Any owners on here to advise on long term ownership?

Is there any discounts on the A45? My local dealer didn't want to play ball and the already expensive car stayed that way. I read another thread about the depreciation concerns, but the cars in the classifieds seem pricey too.

I'd be interested to hear proper owner accounts.

Thanks.

[MattHall91]

My dad got one of the first M235s and it is brilliant.

I would say better than the other 2 all round, and definitely better in terms of being a drivers car.

Plus you get 6 cylinders and it sounds epic. Fake noise or not.