Help me choose: Jaguar XE r-sport or BMW 3\420 m-sport gran

[craste]

This is my dilemma.
What would you choose?

[LasseV]

Jag.

[kambites]

I haven't driven either, but the Jag seems to have had the better reviews as a drivers' car.

[marmitemania]

I would buy the Jaguar (I may be biased having owned two in the past) but do the right thing, believe the better reviews, buy something a bit different from the default German. British made to which is nice. Lets just look at the two cars for the nano second it takes to see which looks the best.

[cerb4.5lee]

The Jag if you are about to retire the BMW if you aren't...seriously though the Jag is all new and something a little different, the BMW`s have been around for years so it would be nice to have something new to the market I reckon.

[V88Dicky]

Jaag.

[anonymous-user]

marmitemania said:

I would buy the Jaguar (I may be biased having owned two in the past) but do the right thing, believe the better reviews, buy something a bit different from the default German. British made to which is nice. Lets just look at the two cars for the nano second it takes to see which looks the best.

Except the Jag in question doesn't quite look like that does it!

[marmitemania]

cerb4.5lee said:

The Jag if you are about to retire the BMW if you aren't...seriously though the Jag is all new and something a little different, the BMW`s have been around for years so it would be nice to have something new to the market I reckon.

Yeah because the Jag looks like an old duffers car and the BMW looks like something you would see parked up at the local golf course. FML see pics above.

[poing]

The Jag is cooler by a massive margin, buy the BMW if you have ran out of imagination. Besides, if you turn up to take your gran to the post office she'll approve of the Jag but will give you that look if you have the BMW.

[cerb4.5lee]

marmitemania said:

cerb4.5lee said:

The Jag if you are about to retire the BMW if you aren't...seriously though the Jag is all new and something a little different, the BMW`s have been around for years so it would be nice to have something new to the market I reckon.

Yeah because the Jag looks like an old duffers car and the BMW looks like something you would see parked up at the local golf course. FML see pics above.

I only said it tongue in cheek! I also said go with the Jag as well! blimey you must love Jags to defend them that much.

I like BMW`s but get sick and tired of constantly seeing them on the road so the Jag will make a nice change.

[marmitemania]

andrewparker said:

marmitemania said:

I would buy the Jaguar (I may be biased having owned two in the past) but do the right thing, believe the better reviews, buy something a bit different from the default German. British made to which is nice. Lets just look at the two cars for the nano second it takes to see which looks the best.

Except the Jag in question doesn't quite look like that does it!

I knew someone would come to the German cars defense. Yes I jumped the gun it doesn't look like that but it does look like this.



You can option the black pack to delete the chrome.

Edited by marmitemania on Friday 13th March 20:19

[Rammy76]

andrewparker said:

marmitemania said:

I would buy the Jaguar (I may be biased having owned two in the past) but do the right thing, believe the better reviews, buy something a bit different from the default German. British made to which is nice. Lets just look at the two cars for the nano second it takes to see which looks the best.

Except the Jag in question doesn't quite look like that does it!

Probably a fairer comparison regarding the pictures.

I'd still take the Jag.

[Patrick Bateman]

Jag for me.

[marmitemania]

cerb4.5lee said:

marmitemania said:

cerb4.5lee said:

The Jag if you are about to retire the BMW if you aren't...seriously though the Jag is all new and something a little different, the BMW`s have been around for years so it would be nice to have something new to the market I reckon.

Yeah because the Jag looks like an old duffers car and the BMW looks like something you would see parked up at the local golf course. FML see pics above.

I only said it tongue in cheek! I also said go with the Jag as well! blimey you must love Jags to defend them that much.

I like BMW`s but get sick and tired of constantly seeing them on the road so the Jag will make a nice change.

I do love Jaguars I think they are great cars that have a lot of presence and style. I don't have one at the minute as I have a huge golden lab, two children, run a scout troop which involves carting a lot of stuff about, and I also shoot a lot. Therefore the RR suits my needs better at the moment, having said that if I won the lottery tomorrow the local Jaguar garage would be my very first port of call. I think we should think about the products we buy and support British industry (I know it's not British owned) especially when they are as good if not better than the default German fayre.

[LanceRS]

Jag, no question, look at the above pictures.

[ziggy328]

when is the xe-s available from ?

[PHlL]

I'd go for a the F36 but then I'm completely biased.

[ChrisR99]

Jaguar, no comparison.

[craste]

Thanks for the responses guys, looks like the Jag is the one to have.
I just want to say I drive a Jaaaag!

[Muzzer79]

I'd go for the 4 series GC, personally, if well specced