Should you confront someone you believe is lying about rape?
Should you confront someone you believe is lying about rape?
Author
Discussion

photosnob

Original Poster:

1,339 posts

149 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all
Not talking about allegations to the police - but generally saying things which could get back to the blokes family etc...

Anyway - I've been "helping out" a girl who has previously had problems (anorexia, mental health problems etc...) with some training. She is related to someone close to me... I have no relationship to her other than that.

Now when I was originally told this stuff - I was angry and pretty upset. I was questioning some of the stuff I've said and thought before. I wanted to physically hurt the bloke badly. Without going into too many details - just think much older and boss. My natural reaction was to literally want to go and rip his head off.

But all the dates and times just don't add up... It would be physically impossible for what she says happened to have happened then. And generally the whole story is just wrong... I'd expect to see certain emotions. I'm a pretty cold person, but even I react in a certain way when talking about the most traumatic things have happened to me.

So would you speak to her? Or the poor bloke who is being branded a rapist? Given I have my suspicions that there was probably some sort of sex and he was married with kids... I'm not sure how I could play this one... I also can't just ignore her and refuse to speak to her without upsetting someone else in my life without explanation.

Hoofy

80,189 posts

313 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all
Advise her to go to the police. I'd probably mention something like they jail people for wasting their time but genuine cases need to be dealt with.

photosnob

Original Poster:

1,339 posts

149 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
Advise her to go to the police. I'd probably mention something like they jail people for wasting their time but genuine cases need to be dealt with.
She won't be going to the Police. Annoyingly she is just telling certain people... Problem is - if you tell enough people eventually it will get back to his family and community. He runs a pub so it would be pretty atrocious if his customers found out...


KungFuPanda

4,655 posts

201 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all
So she's going round making false rape allegations?

photosnob

Original Poster:

1,339 posts

149 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all
KungFuPanda said:
So she's going round making false rape allegations?
Yes. But not to the police. Just telling people. Which is almost worst in my book.

ReaderScars

6,087 posts

207 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all
Is there a risk she might do something similar to you?

KungFuPanda

4,655 posts

201 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all

photosnob

Original Poster:

1,339 posts

149 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all
[quote=ReaderScars]Is there a risk she might do something similar to you?[/quote

No - for multiple reasons. For a start I only see her in public places. And secondly as I've said she is related to someone who is close to me. Her style seems to be more about sleeping with people and then claiming she was attacked...

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all
I don't think it matters whether the allegations are made to the police or not, I believe it's still an offence.

A worrying side-effect of the (entirely legitimate and very worthwhile) raising of awareness about sexual abuse seems to be a very small percentage of despicable people using the threat of reporting a rape which never happened. Whether for blackmail, revenge or Christ knows what it's incredible to think anybody would do such a thing - try to destroy someone's life by lying about something like that.

If your suspicions are right, this woman is doing an only slightly less direct version of the above. I can't quite find words for what kind of person that makes her in my book, but I'm afraid I can't think how you would go about stopping it either. If she figured out you knew and were prepared to discredit what she was saying, the reaction would be pretty nuclear and you already know what she's capable of doing to someone who displeases her..

sc0tt

18,315 posts

232 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all
Got her number?

photosnob

Original Poster:

1,339 posts

149 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all
I think it's more about her using it as an excuse for some of her past behaviour. It only came out when I explained about some of my past mistakes and how I had learnt about myself and grown as a person because of them. I'm pretty open and honest (not on here because people want to jump down your throat) about my mistakes... I consider them like my scars, I'm not overly proud of some of them - but I am proud of who I am now and like to think they helped me become the man I am now.

However I did catch her out with another story about an older man taking advantage on his boat Etc... That was just because her story kept changing. It's not gone from one person raping her there - to her having consensual sex with three different blokes, and the other one trying it on and her saying no so he gave in. It's all a bit sickening actually.

My worry isn't that I could get accused of something - but that this poor sod might have had an affair with her and will have his life ripped to bits by these silly allegations.

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Wednesday 18th March 2015
quotequote all
If you're on good terms with the people you suspect she's been telling about this "rape" and have heard similar tales in the past, it might be worth shoe-horning her into conversation with them somehow. Casual discussion of some unrelated but clearly untrue story that she's told you. Perhaps they've endured a lot of bullst from her in other areas too.

Could be quite easy to get from that to saying that you're worried occasional embellishments/lies/changing stories about past relationships could get out of hand.

Perhaps you'll find nobody would expect to take her seriously anyway, or you could at least be nudging them towards taking anything they hear with a big pinch of salt.

photosnob

Original Poster:

1,339 posts

149 months

Thursday 19th March 2015
quotequote all
McSam said:
If you're on good terms with the people you suspect she's been telling about this "rape" and have heard similar tales in the past, it might be worth shoe-horning her into conversation with them somehow. Casual discussion of some unrelated but clearly untrue story that she's told you. Perhaps they've endured a lot of bullst from her in other areas too.

Could be quite easy to get from that to saying that you're worried occasional lies/embellishments/changing stories could get out of hand.

Perhaps you'll find nobody would expect to take her seriously anyway, or you could at least be nudging them towards taking anything they hear with a big pinch of salt.
I've never met the person in question. And we have no mutual friends in common. But I do know for a fact that she has told people in his community. I have no doubt that she has talked rubbish about other stuff - I think it stems from mental health problems, but she is very conniving and selfish.

Quite frankly - I'd rather not speak to her again. But it's impractical due to the situation. And I'd also quite like to do the right thing by this man and his family.

MrBarry123

6,109 posts

152 months

Thursday 19th March 2015
quotequote all
Two options here I suppose...

Option 1 - she's lying. If it was physically impossible - as in Mr ABC wasn't within raping distance of Miss XYZ - then it probably didn't happen.

Option 2 - because of how traumatised she is as a result of the event, she can't recall dates, times etc. coherently which is why her story doesn't ring true.

If she truly believes she's been raped, she should go to the Police and allow the people who are qualified to investigate it, investigate it.

You should not get involved, it's not your place to do so.

mjb1

2,585 posts

190 months

Thursday 19th March 2015
quotequote all
Just keep right out of it. She's a self destructive nutter and she doesn't care who she drags down with her. None of this is your fault or your problem. Don't go out of your way to avoid her though, otherwise she'll jump to the conclusion that your taking sides (and not hers). Next thing you'll be in her allegations - "photosnob knows all about it", etc. Just tell her if she's serious, she should report it to the police.

Sooner or later it's going to blow up, and you don't want to be anywhere near the epicentre.

photosnob said:
My worry isn't that I could get accused of something - but that this poor sod might have had an affair with her and will have his life ripped to bits by these silly allegations.
If he had an affair, then he's no poor sod if the truth comes out. It's his own daft fault really.

vx220

2,725 posts

265 months

Thursday 19th March 2015
quotequote all
photosnob]eaderScars said:
Is there a risk she might do something similar to you?[/quote

No - for multiple reasons. For a start I only see her in public places. And secondly as I've said she is related to someone who is close to me. Her style seems to be more about sleeping with people and then claiming she was attacked...
But you said her current story doesn't add up geographically, so what's to stop her doing the same to you?

You at least need to tell someone you trust, so if she does start on you someone else can be aware. If you don't tell anybody, it give credence to any allegation

Centurion07

10,395 posts

278 months

Thursday 19th March 2015
quotequote all
mjb1 said:
If he had an affair, then he's no poor sod if the truth comes out. It's his own daft fault really.
Yes, quite. He certainly deserves to have his and his families lives completely ruined by a false rape allegation. rolleyes

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Thursday 19th March 2015
quotequote all
KungFuPanda said:
Yes. Tragic story. Didn't end well for anyone even the poor bloke who just wanted to clear his name. He'll have survivor's guilt the rest of his life.

Leptons

5,493 posts

207 months

Thursday 19th March 2015
quotequote all
Just stay out of it. There isn't a fking barge pole long enough for this one.

Eleven

28,176 posts

253 months

Thursday 19th March 2015
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Then when you judge them you'll be a mile away. And you'll have their shoes.