HPI Check and mileage discrepancy
Discussion
I was looking at a car that left England in 2008 and was registered in Ireland.
Upon doing a HPI check on the original English registration it threw up this mileage discrepancy which seems strange in 2005 and 2004 specifically.
I also dont understand how there could be a mileage reading in 2012 when the car has been in Ireland since 2008?
Anyone able to shed some light?
Date recorded Recorded by Mileage
09/Nov/1998 NMR 2,000 2,000
24/Nov/2000 NMR 29,000 29,000
24/Nov/2000 NMR 29,034 29,034
04/Dec/2004 DVLA 88,000 88,000
24/Sep/2005 NMR 83,634 83,634
24/Sep/2005 NMR 85,000 85,000
24/Sep/2005 NMR 85,114 85,114
24/Sep/2005 NMR 86,000 86,000
24/Sep/2005 NMR 87,000 87,000
24/Sep/2005 NMR 87,500 87,500
24/Sep/2005 NMR 87,900 87,900
24/Sep/2005 NMR 88,000 88,000
24/Sep/2005 NMR 89,000 89,000
12/Feb/2012 NMR 102,000 102,000
Upon doing a HPI check on the original English registration it threw up this mileage discrepancy which seems strange in 2005 and 2004 specifically.
I also dont understand how there could be a mileage reading in 2012 when the car has been in Ireland since 2008?
Anyone able to shed some light?
Date recorded Recorded by Mileage
09/Nov/1998 NMR 2,000 2,000
24/Nov/2000 NMR 29,000 29,000
24/Nov/2000 NMR 29,034 29,034
04/Dec/2004 DVLA 88,000 88,000
24/Sep/2005 NMR 83,634 83,634
24/Sep/2005 NMR 85,000 85,000
24/Sep/2005 NMR 85,114 85,114
24/Sep/2005 NMR 86,000 86,000
24/Sep/2005 NMR 87,000 87,000
24/Sep/2005 NMR 87,500 87,500
24/Sep/2005 NMR 87,900 87,900
24/Sep/2005 NMR 88,000 88,000
24/Sep/2005 NMR 89,000 89,000
12/Feb/2012 NMR 102,000 102,000
Troubleatmill said:
Well.... no one is going to clock a car from 88000 miles to 84000 miles.
Human error when filling in forms, MOT time etc.
NMR = Ireland
DVLA = UK
It seems they share data with HPIcheck etc.
NMR = National Mileage Register (aka HPI). Those mileages are user supplied ones where someone has done a check. Could just be someone accessing HPI from Ireland.Human error when filling in forms, MOT time etc.
NMR = Ireland
DVLA = UK
It seems they share data with HPIcheck etc.
Troubleatmill said:
Well.... no one is going to clock a car from 88000 miles to 84000 miles.
Human error when filling in forms, MOT time etc.
NMR = Ireland
DVLA = UK
It seems they share data with HPIcheck etc.
I was wondering if it was someone HPI checking the car and just guessing mileage to fill in the relevant reports?Human error when filling in forms, MOT time etc.
NMR = Ireland
DVLA = UK
It seems they share data with HPIcheck etc.
Edited to add the car left the UK in 2008 so these 2005 checks were done while the car was UK based.
The DVLA figure is a round figure - probably what the previous owner guessed it was when filling in the V5.
If it was actually 83,000 (or was written as 83,000 and mistyped) then they might have guessed higher and left it at that.
This small discrepancy wouldn't worry me, and at the age of the car, neither would I be more worried if it had done 190k.
It's an older car that allegedly hasn't had much use in a decade - whether that is 20k or 25k miles makes no difference. If you want something to be worried about, consider the apparent 13k in 7 years and nothing since 2012... that could be hiding quite a bit.
Edit: if the car wasn't on a UK registration then the 102k is probably a typo in the registration, so ignore the point about usage. However it does show that typos happen easily in this kind of database.
If it was actually 83,000 (or was written as 83,000 and mistyped) then they might have guessed higher and left it at that.
This small discrepancy wouldn't worry me, and at the age of the car, neither would I be more worried if it had done 190k.
It's an older car that allegedly hasn't had much use in a decade - whether that is 20k or 25k miles makes no difference. If you want something to be worried about, consider the apparent 13k in 7 years and nothing since 2012... that could be hiding quite a bit.
Edit: if the car wasn't on a UK registration then the 102k is probably a typo in the registration, so ignore the point about usage. However it does show that typos happen easily in this kind of database.
Edited by CYMR0 on Friday 20th March 18:21
I had a nightmare with this when selling my panda. I bought it at 10k miles and a year old and was selling at around 22k which was around 18 months later I think.
Someone was interested and did a HPI check which said the mileage was 110k at the time I bought It.
The interested bloke soon become uninterested and whilst he agreed with me that someone doing 110k miles in 12 months in a panda was unlikely, people take comfort in 'official' things like HPI checks.
Someone was interested and did a HPI check which said the mileage was 110k at the time I bought It.
The interested bloke soon become uninterested and whilst he agreed with me that someone doing 110k miles in 12 months in a panda was unlikely, people take comfort in 'official' things like HPI checks.
Ok so just done an HPI check.
Car has FSH, V5 present & correct. No other things flagged.
01/Mar/2010 DVLA 129,000 129,000
23/Jul/2012 NMR 140,000 140,000
11/Oct/2012 DVLA 141,000 141,000
07/Feb/2014 NMR 140,201 140,201
07/Feb/2014 NMR 141,501 141,501
13/Feb/2014 NMR 141,501 141,501
09/Mar/2014 NMR 140,973 140,973
Should I be worried?
Car has FSH, V5 present & correct. No other things flagged.
01/Mar/2010 DVLA 129,000 129,000
23/Jul/2012 NMR 140,000 140,000
11/Oct/2012 DVLA 141,000 141,000
07/Feb/2014 NMR 140,201 140,201
07/Feb/2014 NMR 141,501 141,501
13/Feb/2014 NMR 141,501 141,501
09/Mar/2014 NMR 140,973 140,973
Should I be worried?
Problem is anyone can put a check in and add a mileage which then appears on the NMR.
eg
Bought a Z4M at 2yrs old on 12k miles, everything tallied up (inc mileages from warranty jobs after speaking to the supplying dealer and where the work was done) apart from a NMR entry at 20k miles exactly. This was done by a garage 150 miles from where the car was and 4 weeks after the last entry (ie it looked like the car had done 8k in 4 weeks!). Seems they entered an average mileage for a 2yr old car when they did a check.
Managed to get it removed after contacting NMR and providing copies of mileages of 2 services and the mileage when a couple of warranty jobs were carried out.
I'd personally ignore the NMR mileages or at best use it as a guide as to whether you think something might be amiss.
eg
Bought a Z4M at 2yrs old on 12k miles, everything tallied up (inc mileages from warranty jobs after speaking to the supplying dealer and where the work was done) apart from a NMR entry at 20k miles exactly. This was done by a garage 150 miles from where the car was and 4 weeks after the last entry (ie it looked like the car had done 8k in 4 weeks!). Seems they entered an average mileage for a 2yr old car when they did a check.
Managed to get it removed after contacting NMR and providing copies of mileages of 2 services and the mileage when a couple of warranty jobs were carried out.
I'd personally ignore the NMR mileages or at best use it as a guide as to whether you think something might be amiss.
zygalski said:
Ok so just done an HPI check.
Car has FSH, V5 present & correct. No other things flagged.
01/Mar/2010 DVLA 129,000 129,000
23/Jul/2012 NMR 140,000 140,000
11/Oct/2012 DVLA 141,000 141,000
07/Feb/2014 NMR 140,201 140,201
07/Feb/2014 NMR 141,501 141,501
13/Feb/2014 NMR 141,501 141,501
09/Mar/2014 NMR 140,973 140,973
Should I be worried?
Can you not check all the old mileages from MOT's?Car has FSH, V5 present & correct. No other things flagged.
01/Mar/2010 DVLA 129,000 129,000
23/Jul/2012 NMR 140,000 140,000
11/Oct/2012 DVLA 141,000 141,000
07/Feb/2014 NMR 140,201 140,201
07/Feb/2014 NMR 141,501 141,501
13/Feb/2014 NMR 141,501 141,501
09/Mar/2014 NMR 140,973 140,973
Should I be worried?
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



