Westminster Council...£20 Fines For Stationary Traffic
Westminster Council...£20 Fines For Stationary Traffic
Author
Discussion

Lordbenny

Original Poster:

8,754 posts

250 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
What! So, many questions here.....possibly the most rediculous, un policeable law I've ever heard.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-319899...

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
Yet another waste of council money - x "wardens" on y thousand pounds a year - how many tickets will they have to issue to recover the cost?

bigandclever

14,418 posts

269 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
elsewhere someone said:
Leaving an engine idling is an offence

"Stationary idling is an offence under section 42 of the Road Traffic Act 1988," says Jeanette Miller, a motoring lawyer with Geoffrey Miller Solicitors.

The Act enforces rule 123 of the Highway Code which states: "You must not leave a vehicle engine running unnecessarily while that vehicle is stationary on a public road."

And doing this can incur a £20 fixed-penalty fine under the Road Traffic (Vehicle Emissions) Regulations 2002.

Lordbenny

Original Poster:

8,754 posts

250 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
I can just imagine a Skyline owner trying to tell a warden that the turbo is cooling down.

Martin_Hx

4,029 posts

229 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
It is silly but i must admit it is annoying when people sit in their cars running for 15+ mins. I've known times when Ive been shopping and parked near a car with the driver sat with the engine going, returning 30-45 mins later and them still sat there!

If i know im going to be stationary for a few mins + i will always turn the engine off, why not?

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
Good. About time, too.

trickywoo

14,282 posts

261 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
bigandclever said:
elsewhere someone said:
Leaving an engine idling is an offence

"Stationary idling is an offence under section 42 of the Road Traffic Act 1988," says Jeanette Miller, a motoring lawyer with Geoffrey Miller Solicitors.

The Act enforces rule 123 of the Highway Code which states: "You must not leave a vehicle engine running unnecessarily while that vehicle is stationary on a public road."

And doing this can incur a £20 fixed-penalty fine under the Road Traffic (Vehicle Emissions) Regulations 2002.
The key is 'unnecessarily'.

Hopefully this will target people parked with the engine running rather than in traffic which is moving, albeit slowly.

The sound of an idling diesel while the driver reads the paper needs fining IMO.

55palfers

6,396 posts

195 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
Let's hope they target buses and taxis, etc. as well then.

They can always find some resource to target motorists can't they.

I read Plod will no longer investigate crime if the value is below £50 now...

Hoofy

80,177 posts

313 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
Lordbenny said:
I can just imagine a Skyline owner trying to tell a warden that the turbo is cooling down.
If he doesn't drive like he's trying to beat a personal best through an estate, he can just switch off the engine when he parks up.

KrazyIvan

4,341 posts

206 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
This could be fun, especially when a traffic warden tickets a police car that the officer has left idling.

Pan Pan Pan

10,725 posts

142 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
Sometimes in hot weather people sit stationary with the engine on, so that they can have the air conditioning on.
But councils are just looking for any way of extracting cash from the motoring public, as they see them as a cash cow, the same way that governments do.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
Pan Pan Pan said:
Sometimes in hot weather people sit stationary with the engine on, so that they can have the air conditioning on.
But councils are just looking for any way of extracting cash from the motoring public, as they see them as a cash cow, the same way that governments do.
Or, more realistically, they're under pressure to meet gov't targets regarding pollution in the city and the easiest and most reliable way of ensuring compliance is using the threat of a fine.

Randy Winkman

22,803 posts

220 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
OpulentBob said:
Or, more realistically, they're under pressure to meet gov't targets regarding pollution in the city and the easiest and most reliable way of ensuring compliance is using the threat of a fine.
I'm glad they are under pressure.

Pan Pan Pan

10,725 posts

142 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
OpulentBob said:
Pan Pan Pan said:
Sometimes in hot weather people sit stationary with the engine on, so that they can have the air conditioning on.
But councils are just looking for any way of extracting cash from the motoring public, as they see them as a cash cow, the same way that governments do.
Or, more realistically, they're under pressure to meet gov't targets regarding pollution in the city and the easiest and most reliable way of ensuring compliance is using the threat of a fine.
What possible good is `one' borough introducing this fine going to do? Pollution does not recognise boundaries, either municipal, county, national or international ( as the muck which has been blown into the UK from the Oh so clean EU recently? How can they put pressure on the UK to clean up the air here, when theirs is clearly no better, or even worse? )
It is just one borough using motorists as a cash cow, or to appease some ecomentalist lobby which may exist in their own offices, or area of influence. No Practical value at all.

NickGibbs

1,682 posts

262 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
Pan Pan Pan said:
What possible good is `one' borough introducing this fine going to do? Pollution does not recognise boundaries, either municipal, county, national or international .
You're thinking of CO2 - this is about NoX, particulates etc and will have a good deal of impact locally if idling is a problem.
For once I'm in agreement with Westminster

Love this from the taxi union guy (from here http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-319899...

"Steve McNamara, general secretary of the LTDA said the fines were "absolute tosh" and a PR, money-raising exercise from the council.
He said: "It is not going to do anything constructive to tackle the pollution crisis in London. When was the last time you saw someone idling in the city? It doesn't happen."

If it doesn't happen then your members will be fine, you numpty!

oyster

13,796 posts

279 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
Pan Pan Pan said:
What possible good is `one' borough introducing this fine going to do? Pollution does not recognise boundaries, either municipal, county, national or international ( as the muck which has been blown into the UK from the Oh so clean EU recently? How can they put pressure on the UK to clean up the air here, when theirs is clearly no better, or even worse? )
Whilst you may be technically correct that pollution does spread, it is always going to be worse in the area around the source of the pollution. Unless you think the air in central London is as clean as that in the Lake District.

Or to put it another way, if I pissed in the swimming pool, would you rather be next to me or at the other end of the pool?

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
NickGibbs said:
You're thinking of CO2 - this is about NoX, particulates etc and will have a good deal of impact locally if idling is a problem.
For once I'm in agreement with Westminster

Love this from the taxi union guy (from here http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-319899...

"Steve McNamara, general secretary of the LTDA said the fines were "absolute tosh" and a PR, money-raising exercise from the council.
He said: "It is not going to do anything constructive to tackle the pollution crisis in London. When was the last time you saw someone idling in the city? It doesn't happen."

If it doesn't happen then your members will be fine, you numpty!
Haha, fair point - if they don't idle then he has nothing to worry about and if they do get fined maybe he can explain why he thinks it's acceptable for his members to sit around belching stinking fumes onto the street when they are stationary. I'm always amazed by people who are happy to sit idling in a 4 pot diesel, if I'm stopped for any length of time the last thing I want is the hateful noise of the thing clattering away and the vibration through the car.

Can we apply this to busses as well? hehe

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
Pan Pan Pan said:
Sometimes in hot weather people sit stationary with the engine on, so that they can have the air conditioning on.
Poor lambs. I'm sure not too many people will die as a result of being forced to sit in a car with an open window instead.

Oh, what's that, Skippy? But what about the air quality... Hmmm...

NickGibbs

1,682 posts

262 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
dme123 said:
I'm always amazed by people who are happy to sit idling in a 4 pot diesel, if I'm stopped for any length of time the last thing I want is the hateful noise of the thing clattering away and the vibration through the car.
I quite agree. Worst is when a taxi driver drops off someone late at night down our street, then sits there, doing a bit of admin, checking Facebook, while the engine throbs away at a volume that seems 8x magnified at 1am

Pan Pan Pan

10,725 posts

142 months

Monday 23rd March 2015
quotequote all
oyster said:
Pan Pan Pan said:
What possible good is `one' borough introducing this fine going to do? Pollution does not recognise boundaries, either municipal, county, national or international ( as the muck which has been blown into the UK from the Oh so clean EU recently? How can they put pressure on the UK to clean up the air here, when theirs is clearly no better, or even worse? )
Whilst you may be technically correct that pollution does spread, it is always going to be worse in the area around the source of the pollution. Unless you think the air in central London is as clean as that in the Lake District.

Or to put it another way, if I pissed in the swimming pool, would you rather be next to me or at the other end of the pool?
lets face facts, if we insist on cramming 6 plus million people into a tiny space it is going to become polluted, whether we get around by petrol /diesel/ horse drawn carriage.
The pollution when London used horse drawn vehicles was far greater than it is now.
As for the swimming pool analogy, I would not get into the pool regardless of which end you pissed in it. Consequently I try to avoid going into London like the plague.
Why do people focus on what comes out of vehicles in the capital, but seem to be able to ignore what is coming out of people, buildings, factories, shops etc there? these contribute by far the greatest to air pollution in capital cities.