Why shouldn't 't I buy an E46 320cd?
Why shouldn't 't I buy an E46 320cd?
Author
Discussion

Cledus Snow

Original Poster:

2,147 posts

219 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
Morning,
I need, well fancy a change of daily driver. I have a budget of £4000ish and I'm after something 2 door, economical and capable of doing a sixty mile commute comfortably. So e46 320cd or something else? I know the obvious answer is a 330cd but will it be noticeably more expensive to run?

Also I already have a toy/money pit/ 2 ton millstone for weekends. So just looking for a daily smoke.

mwstewart

8,615 posts

219 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
They drive very nicely and handle well. Very quiet on the motorway too. Just don't expect great MPG; I got around 38 mixed.

Sump

5,512 posts

198 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
Biggest question here is how many miles PA?

tintopracer

139 posts

198 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
I picked up a 2003 325ci sport auto at the weekend. Decided to take it to work yesterday and drove it at general motorway speeds on the M6 through Birmingham and up to Manchester with lots of roadworks, congestion etc. I wasn't trying to drive economically, I just wanted to see what it was like with my normal style of driving.

I got 39.8mpg according to the trip computer. Pleased with that.

emicen

9,258 posts

249 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
Cledus Snow said:
Morning,
I need, well fancy a change of daily driver. I have a budget of £4000ish and I'm after something 2 door, economical and capable of doing a sixty mile commute comfortably. So e46 320cd or something else? I know the obvious answer is a 330cd but will it be noticeably more expensive to run?

Also I already have a toy/money pit/ 2 ton millstone for weekends. So just looking for a daily smoke.
I've had mine 7.5 years now. 90 mile a day commute, mixture of motorway and A-roads with a snifter of urban at each end. Over the last 90,000 miles it has averaged just over 50mpg, real world measured.

The front wishbone bushes [rear bush] wear out on them with our country's poor roads, but a poly bush tightens things up nicely and is a permanent fix. For piece of mind, you want to remove the swirl flaps from the inlet manifold [I didnt bother until around 160k were on the clock right enough].

golfdsg

228 posts

158 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
tintopracer said:
I picked up a 2003 325ci sport auto at the weekend. Decided to take it to work yesterday and drove it at general motorway speeds on the M6 through Birmingham and up to Manchester with lots of roadworks, congestion etc. I wasn't trying to drive economically, I just wanted to see what it was like with my normal style of driving.

I got 39.8mpg according to the trip computer. Pleased with that.
How many miles did you drive, and what sort of speeds were you cruising at? 70-80? Or lower

triggerh4ppy

422 posts

157 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
one word..... rust


coming from a e46 owner

BuzzBravado

2,949 posts

202 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
triggerh4ppy said:
one word..... rust


coming from a e46 owner
Depends on the age really. The facelifts seem to be faring far better than the early ones.
Since it is the 320cd it will be a facelift.

snowley

183 posts

157 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
As said above, you have to be very careful with rust.

The arches go from the inside out and can quickly deteriorate.

ZesPak

26,164 posts

227 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
triggerh4ppy said:
one word..... rust


coming from a e46 owner
My E46 was by far the worst car I've owned in a lot of ways. But that's merely anecdotal, I had a real stter on my hands, and when things went wrong they went pricey really fast.

mike325112

1,074 posts

215 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
BuzzBravado said:
Depends on the age really. The facelifts seem to be faring far better than the early ones.
Since it is the 320cd it will be a facelift.
Mines a facelift and it's awful! That said someone told me once that the coupes are better than the saloons , which I have. Not sure if there's anything in that.

mike325112

1,074 posts

215 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
BuzzBravado said:
Depends on the age really. The facelifts seem to be faring far better than the early ones.
Since it is the 320cd it will be a facelift.
Mines a facelift and it's awful! That said someone told me once that the coupes are better than the saloons , which I have. Not sure if there's anything in that.

tintopracer

139 posts

198 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
golfdsg said:
How many miles did you drive, and what sort of speeds were you cruising at? 70-80? Or lower
It was about 220 miles. For once the traffic was ok so mainly those sorts of speeds and 50 in the roadworks around junction 17 and junction 12 to 8. Got through the Brum bit (j8 to junction 4a) at 60 as the reduced speed running was on at that time.

Oh, and I had the cruise control on for most of the return journey, as I was feeling lazy.

emicen

9,258 posts

249 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
tintopracer said:
golfdsg said:
How many miles did you drive, and what sort of speeds were you cruising at? 70-80? Or lower
It was about 220 miles. For once the traffic was ok so mainly those sorts of speeds and 50 in the roadworks around junction 17 and junction 12 to 8. Got through the Brum bit (j8 to junction 4a) at 60 as the reduced speed running was on at that time.

Oh, and I had the cruise control on for most of the return journey, as I was feeling lazy.
As a veteran of a 325i manual, your trip computer is telling porkies. 10-25% porkies.

clonmult

10,529 posts

240 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
mike325112 said:
BuzzBravado said:
Depends on the age really. The facelifts seem to be faring far better than the early ones.
Since it is the 320cd it will be a facelift.
Mines a facelift and it's awful! That said someone told me once that the coupes are better than the saloons , which I have. Not sure if there's anything in that.
Not quite the same, I had an '03 model Compact that had absolutely no signs of rust at all. Body was close to perfect. Cracking little car, but don't miss it in the slightest.

Barchettaman

7,308 posts

163 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
Would an E90 320d not be in budget already?

I´ve just got one, 2007, and it´s very quiet on the Autobahn.

The rest of it is pretty non-descript, kind of does its job well, the most impressive thing (so far) is its refinement at (high) speed.

Patrick Bateman

13,219 posts

205 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
mike325112 said:
BuzzBravado said:
Depends on the age really. The facelifts seem to be faring far better than the early ones.
Since it is the 320cd it will be a facelift.
Mines a facelift and it's awful! That said someone told me once that the coupes are better than the saloons , which I have. Not sure if there's anything in that.
My old facelift coupé would strongly disagree. biggrin

If you can afford around 30mpg then go for a 330 petrol. Having experienced the 2 litre 'skeleton in a biscuit tin' and the petrol straight 6 there is absolutely no contest, none at all.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
mike325112 said:
BuzzBravado said:
Depends on the age really. The facelifts seem to be faring far better than the early ones.
Since it is the 320cd it will be a facelift.
Mines a facelift and it's awful! That said someone told me once that the coupes are better than the saloons , which I have. Not sure if there's anything in that.
My old facelift coupé would strongly disagree. biggrin

If you can afford around 30mpg then go for a 330 petrol. Having experienced the 2 litre 'skeleton in a biscuit tin' and the petrol straight 6 there is absolutely no contest, none at all.
They are old cars now so it's no surprise they are starting to rust (just like the e36 before it).

uk_vette

3,336 posts

235 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
I bought a 2003 BMW 320d

What a pile of junk it ended up being.

Turbo threw its hand in, 3 months later, hard starting.

The following 2 months, I had to put 2 injectors internetthe damn thing.

SOLD the following month,

Never again.

Patrick Bateman

13,219 posts

205 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
uk_vette said:
I bought a 2003 BMW 320d

What a pile of junk it ended up being.

Turbo threw its hand in, 3 months later, hard starting.

The following 2 months, I had to put 2 injectors internetthe damn thing.

SOLD the following month,

Never again.
Kind of negates the fuel saving. Prior to buying my 320Td it had just had a new turbo fitted and one or two injectors. At least if you have to spend some money on the petrol car it's something to enjoy at the end of the day.