What fun family car that won't cost the earth to run
What fun family car that won't cost the earth to run
Author
Discussion

Chris71

Original Poster:

21,549 posts

273 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
Mrs Chris71's Focus appears to be on its last legs and we're starting to think about options.

We need one vehicle with four seats, decent motorway manners, modern(ish) safety standards and room for a pram in the boot, but she doesn't drive that often so we might swap round so that I drive the 'family' car day-to-day. And if I'm giving up my 172 Cup I'd like something that isn't going to send me to sleep.

Budget is up to about £5k and it needs to be at least Golf-sized. That money seems to be a bit marginal for a decent mk5 Golf GTi and I need something that won't cost the earth to run, so Imprezas and M3s are probably out.

I was thinking something like a mk2 Octavia vRS. Any other suggestions?

UK345

441 posts

189 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
Ford Mondeo ST TDCI plenty of choice around that price. Well equipt excellent cars and look sporty too.

nunpuncher

3,770 posts

156 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
Seat Leon FR.

gtidreamer

176 posts

146 months

Tuesday 24th March 2015
quotequote all
If you can get one go for the golf. My man maths calculator shows spending even a bit more on the golf will be better as it will hold it's value better than other comparable cars.

Gad-Westy

16,660 posts

244 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
If you can live with the questionable rear spoiler, how about an Accord Type R? Might be stretching the definition of 'modern' but ticks your other boxes.

When I was in position with our first born on the way, I went for a manual 330 touring. Was a nice car but cost a little bit to maintain.

rb5er

11,657 posts

203 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
An impreza is not an expensive car to run, very surprised anyone would think it would even be close to the amount an M3 would cost to run. Small wheels so cheap tyres and other than caliper refurb, servicing and cambelt mine has never made me spend any money over the 4 years I have had it.

Other than 3mpg difference over a Skoda Octavia Vrs I think they could have been comparable to run. One is about 100 times more interesting than the other though.

In fact if you have a clio 172 you may well be reducing your yearly maintenance bill.

Edited by rb5er on Wednesday 25th March 08:21

JimmyConwayNW

3,658 posts

156 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Focus ST 2.5 5door ?


Kozy

3,169 posts

249 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Accord Type R. Good one will cost £3k, leaving the rest to refresh suspension/brakes if needed.

Seriously good car, the drive is head and shoulders above any other FWD I have driven, second only to a DC2 (and even then, only really pipped by the extra 200kg)


s m

24,494 posts

234 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
If you can live with the questionable rear spoiler, how about an Accord Type R? Might be stretching the definition of 'modern' but ticks your other boxes.

When I was in position with our first born on the way, I went for a manual 330 touring. Was a nice car but cost a little bit to maintain.
Did they do a small spoiler version of the ATR?

Fuzzarr

330 posts

142 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
I've become mildly obsessed with the breadvan-shape Civic Type-S recently. Decent ones seem to be around £2.5k, 160 horsebeans and they've got a baffling amount of rear legroom. Tax is £225 but when the purchase price is so low it pretty much becomes irrelevant. I suppose MPG wouldn't be great but it'd be a top all-rounder I reckon.

Kozy

3,169 posts

249 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
s m said:
Did they do a small spoiler version of the ATR?
There was a spoiler delete option from the factory, but not many chose it.

Chris71

Original Poster:

21,549 posts

273 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
rb5er said:
An impreza is not an expensive car to run, very surprised anyone would think it would even be close to the amount an M3 would cost to run.
I wasn't suggesting it would be as expensive as an M3, but that anything from a Scooby upwards - the M3 being one of the obvious candidates - could be out of reach.

I do quite high mileages, so fuel consumption is a factor. Official figures for the four cylinder mk2 vRS and the Blob Eye WRX STi are 37 and 25 mpg respectively, so it's a bit more than 3 mpg. According to Evo their vRS long termer has seen over 40 mpg on a run and I'd be very impressed if you could get that in a Scooby.

Don't get me wrong, I'd rather have the Impreza, but I'm not convinced the difference in running costs is quite that small.

danp

1,658 posts

293 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Fuzzarr said:
I've become mildly obsessed with the breadvan-shape Civic Type-S recently. Decent ones seem to be around £2.5k, 160 horsebeans and they've got a baffling amount of rear legroom. Tax is £225 but when the purchase price is so low it pretty much becomes irrelevant. I suppose MPG wouldn't be great but it'd be a top all-rounder I reckon.
Brilliant vfm family wagons, mine is the early, even more dull looking one. Would have loved a type-r but 5 doors and a reasonable ride probably more important for my daily.

Does about 33/34mpg in suburbia, chain cam, reasonable fun, feels very well designed and built and as you say it's massive inside.

Biggest downside is probably the rubbish turning circle, but you get used to it. (Edit: and the electric steering feels artificial at times)


Edited by danp on Wednesday 25th March 09:49

Chris71

Original Poster:

21,549 posts

273 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
If you can live with the questionable rear spoiler, how about an Accord Type R? Might be stretching the definition of 'modern' but ticks your other boxes.
Certainly worth looking into. Had an idea that the Type Rs were quite thirsty too, though? Plus there's the nagging suspicion that I'd rather have an Integra (retaining a more basic car for the family bus) if I was to go down the Type R route.

The other thing is I'd prefer to go for a slightly more modern design if it's for the family car. I used to ridicule people who fussed over that sort of thing (and I don't think about it too much when I'm alone in my non-ABS French crisp packet with the airbag light on...) but we had a big smash on the A1 a couple of years ago that's changed my perspective a little.

danp

1,658 posts

293 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
- EP3 CTR if you can cope with 3 doors and it's hardcore ways
- 130i if you can cope with it's lack of room
- Leon Cupra/R if you can cope with it being a bit dull (might even get a mk5 Golf based one)

Kozy

3,169 posts

249 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
The ATR chassis is renowned for being pretty damn strong in a smash according to a few lucky/unlucky owners on the forum.

Mine returns about 28mpg rural, 31mpg on a longer motorway run at around 90mph. Perfectly acceptable for the power available, if you drive around off VTEC it's a reasonably economic engine and only really starts drinking when you use VTEC.

The only downside for me is road and wind noise really. Oh and that despite being a big car (they are the next size up from an Impreza or Evo) you can't get anything sizeable in them. But that's just a general saloon issues rather than ATR specific.

I would seriously give one a go!

dai1983

3,198 posts

180 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Kozy said:
The ATR chassis is renowned for being pretty damn strong in a smash according to a few lucky/unlucky owners on the forum.

Mine returns about 28mpg rural, 31mpg on a longer motorway run at around 90mph. Perfectly acceptable for the power available, if you drive around off VTEC it's a reasonably economic engine and only really starts drinking when you use VTEC.

The only downside for me is road and wind noise really. Oh and that despite being a big car (they are the next size up from an Impreza or Evo) you can't get anything sizeable in them. But that's just a general saloon issues rather than ATR specific.

I would seriously give one a go!
I had one and Id echo the above really but I'd say it's in the same size category as the other Japanese saloons mentioned. They could have really done with different gearing or a six speed gearbox for cruising. The engine eggs you on and it's was a joy to go all the way to the redline thus decreasing MPG. Rear seats don't fold flat either if that matters to you..

Tickle

6,536 posts

235 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Ecurie Ecosse said:
The ultimate fun family car that won't cost the earth to run.

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
I love these!

Kozy

3,169 posts

249 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
dai1983 said:
I had one and Id echo the above really but I'd say it's in the same size category as the other Japanese saloons mentioned.
It's much bigger than an Impreza. When the coilpacks failed on mine I borrowed my mates WRX for a week, I had to roll the drivers seat so far forward to get the baby seat in behind that it was actually uncomfortable to drive. The rear legroom on the ATR is way more generous, I can position the seat so that my leg is almost full extended by the bottom of the pedal travel.

dai1983

3,198 posts

180 months

Wednesday 25th March 2015
quotequote all
Kozy said:
It's much bigger than an Impreza. When the coilpacks failed on mine I borrowed my mates WRX for a week, I had to roll the drivers seat so far forward to get the baby seat in behind that it was actually uncomfortable to drive. The rear legroom on the ATR is way more generous, I can position the seat so that my leg is almost full extended by the bottom of the pedal travel.
Ok I stand corrected. I always assumed that they were the same class of car with the Legend/Legacy being bigger.