Clutch wear indicator
Discussion
Technically feasible or not, this is no where near as stupid as some of you are pretending it is.
It would be quite nice to know that your clutch is 10%,50%,80% whatever of the way through its useful life. It would also be worth while knowing if your clutch was on its way out just before setting off on an 800 mile round trip.
It would be quite nice to know that your clutch is 10%,50%,80% whatever of the way through its useful life. It would also be worth while knowing if your clutch was on its way out just before setting off on an 800 mile round trip.
Bennet said:
Technically feasible or not, this is no where near as stupid as some of you are pretending it is.
It would be quite nice to know that your clutch is 10%,50%,80% whatever of the way through its useful life. It would also be worth while knowing if your clutch was on its way out just before setting off on an 800 mile round trip.
Nice to know? Yeah, I suppose so. Necessary? Nah. Clutches don't just stop engaging, a slipping clutch used sympathetically would easily complete an 800 mile journey. It would be quite nice to know that your clutch is 10%,50%,80% whatever of the way through its useful life. It would also be worth while knowing if your clutch was on its way out just before setting off on an 800 mile round trip.
Some of the more sophisticated clutched autos have an estimator for how much clutch is left, presumably based on measurements of how quickly engagement takes place when the actuator is triggered, but it's not very practical in a manual.
You could add an automatic system to find the wear %age, but it's a lot of complexity for not much gain imo.
You could add an automatic system to find the wear %age, but it's a lot of complexity for not much gain imo.
One can potentially gauge the wear of a clutch by assessing the "spin down" time; with the engine on and the gearbox in neutral, depress the clutch and try and engage reverse. The longer you have to hold the clutch down before engaging reverse where it doesnt make a horrible crunching / grinding / 'box-destorying-itself-slowly noise, the more your clutch is worn.
It's a bit crude but it's how I figured my clutch was done.
It's a bit crude but it's how I figured my clutch was done.
thatdude said:
One can potentially gauge the wear of a clutch by assessing the "spin down" time; with the engine on and the gearbox in neutral, depress the clutch and try and engage reverse. The longer you have to hold the clutch down before engaging reverse where it doesnt make a horrible crunching / grinding / 'box-destorying-itself-slowly noise, the more your clutch is worn.
It's a bit crude but it's how I figured my clutch was done.
Genuine question - why would the wear on the clutch change the amount of time it takes to 'spin down'? The amount of material worn from the clutch is a tiny percentage of the rotating mass of the clutch, so should barely alter the time at all.It's a bit crude but it's how I figured my clutch was done.
iloveboost said:
Instead of replacing the clutch after it's died why not use a wear sensor like brake pads?
Because clutches don't normally just "die" with no warning, whereas brake performance to the average plodding driver doesn't change significantly until they hit metal.With clutches the bite point tends to move up, it gets heavier, sometimes it starts dragging making gearchanges stiffer and finally it will start slipping under load, but the car will remain driveable for quite some time if driven with care. At that point the clutch is pretty much dead but you've had loads of warning, so what's the point of an idiot light telling you these things are going to occur some random length of time in the future?
IanCress said:
thatdude said:
One can potentially gauge the wear of a clutch by assessing the "spin down" time; with the engine on and the gearbox in neutral, depress the clutch and try and engage reverse. The longer you have to hold the clutch down before engaging reverse where it doesnt make a horrible crunching / grinding / 'box-destorying-itself-slowly noise, the more your clutch is worn.
It's a bit crude but it's how I figured my clutch was done.
Genuine question - why would the wear on the clutch change the amount of time it takes to 'spin down'? The amount of material worn from the clutch is a tiny percentage of the rotating mass of the clutch, so should barely alter the time at all.It's a bit crude but it's how I figured my clutch was done.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



d"
were is that piccy of a tongue in bottom lip when you need it