Speculation
Author
Discussion

FrankAbagnale

Original Poster:

1,842 posts

143 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
I've seen a few posts over several threads that have criticised speculation. The posters suggesting that people should wait for facts before discussing events. The retort is often that this is a discussion forum and people are discussing.

I once posted something on another forum about Gareth Bale (footballer) and how I thought he would sign for Real Madrid prior to the event. Some guy went mental about my speculation and suggested I just wait for facts in life before discussing anything etc.

Personally, I am intrigued by most speculation. My nature is inquisitive and speculation often creates a fountain of knowledge around a given topic - the event that caused the speculation being the catalyst of discussion.

Is it OK to speculate? Should there be boundaries?

Moonhawk

10,730 posts

250 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Speculation is fine as long as you are clear it is just that.

If you speculate enough - you are bound to get some things right - but this is just blind luck rather than being down to any skill as a speculator.

Some people wear it as a badge of honor when they happen to guess right ("told you so") - yet the same people are strangely silent when their speculations turn out to be wide of the mark.

Brigand

2,547 posts

200 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
I think this sort of thing brings out two types of people, those (like you and myself) who like to speculate, who are open to any ideas and enjoy discussing such matters; and those who are particularly closed-minded and cannot / will not accept anything but the truth.

As for boundaries, well I would say those just fall into common decency depending on what the topic is being discussed. I've seen a few 'sensitive' subjects being talked about on PH where people have suggested something a little callous and they have been shot down, told to shut up and wait for the facts etc.

Edited by Brigand on Thursday 26th March 10:35

Ari

19,841 posts

246 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Brigand said:
As for boundaries, well I would say those just fall into common decency depending on what the topic is being discussed.
The problem with common decency is the same as the the one regarding common sense.

It's not very common...

Brigand

2,547 posts

200 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Ari said:
Brigand said:
As for boundaries, well I would say those just fall into common decency depending on what the topic is being discussed.
The problem with common decency is the same as the the one regarding common sense.

It's not very common...
Oh how true that is! (Sadly)

Jasandjules

72,701 posts

260 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Well, millions of pounds are made and lost by speculating on companies etc....

Jon1967x

8,205 posts

155 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Brigand said:
I think this sort of thing brings out two types of people, those (like you and myself) who like to speculate, who are open to any ideas and enjoy discussing such matters; and those who are particularly closed-minded and cannot / will not accept anything but the truth.

As for boundaries, well I would say those just fall into common decency depending on what the topic is being discussed. I've seen a few 'sensitive' subjects being talked about on PH where people have suggested something a little callous and they have been shot down, told to shut up and wait for the facts etc.

Edited by Brigand on Thursday 26th March 10:35
I think there is a 3rd type or variation of the second; those that speculate but only in a way that suits their agenda/belief and won't accept an alternate path of events or view. For instance I was flamed for suggesting Clarkson punching someone may have committed a criminal act and speculated that worse may be to come - guess what - the police have asked for the file. It still might not come to anything but it wasn't exactly a wild scenario to me.

soad

34,769 posts

207 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
The mother of all evil is speculation! wink