Different tyre tread depths on same axle ok? Audi say yes.
Different tyre tread depths on same axle ok? Audi say yes.
Author
Discussion

logit

Original Poster:

82 posts

237 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Hi guys,

I'm just in the process of buying an A1 from Audi. It's gone for its inspection and it's caoe back saying that one of the tyres is on 3mm so they're going to replace it with a new tyre. I'm going to check with them that they're replacing it with the same brand and model as the tyre on the other end of the axle, but is there any case to be made for them changing the other tyre on the same axle tyre as well? The other tyre is at 4mm, so there'll be one tyre of 8mm and another of 4mm on the same axle. Could this not cause potential stability problems as the level of grip is different across the axle. Say for example that I went through some standing water, or the roads are really wet, the new tyre should dispel the water more effectively than the old (which is more likely to aquaplane) which could cause the car to become unstable. Audi say not and they will only replace one tyre. Am I wrong to ask for both tyres on the same axle to be replaced? Grateful for your views on this guys.

Cheers

kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
There is certainly no obligation to replace it, but then there's no obligation to replace the 3mm one either. It'll just come down to what they're own policies are.

Personally, I'd be a bit wary of any car where the tyres on the same axle have worn at significantly different rates. It could just indicate the previous owner had a lot of roundabouts on his commute or it could be an indication of a suspension issue of some kind.

Foliage

3,861 posts

153 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Yes its fine, the only thing that shouldn't be on the same axle is different types of tyre ie radial and cross ply and since all (most) tyres are radial these days it really doesn't matter.

Im not saying that having matching tread/tyre brand isn't a nice thing to have but its not dangerous to have 4 different brand tyres with different tread depths on the 4 corners.

Plus your buying an A1 its not a sports car, its just a every day hatch, unless your getting an a45 or something.

BOBTEE

1,034 posts

195 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
kambites said:
There is certainly no obligation to replace it, but then there's no obligation to replace the 3mm one either. It'll just come down to what they're own policies are.

Personally, I'd be a bit wary of any car where the tyres on the same axle have worn at significantly different rates. It could just indicate the previous owner had a lot of roundabouts on his commute or it could be an indication of a suspension issue of some kind.
Or it had a puncture that wasn't repairable. smile

I'd prefer to have matching tyres, I'd pay for one myself to match up, especially when buying a car as it'll only cause more aggro down the line smile

kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
BOBTEE said:
Or it had a puncture that wasn't repairable. smile
Yes, it could easily be nothing, but it would certainly make me take a close look at the suspension.

logit

Original Poster:

82 posts

237 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Thanks for the quick replies guys. My fiancee and I are downsizing to one car so we needed something we'll both be mildly happy with so we agreed on the A1 sportback 182bhp s-tronic. It won't set the world alight but it's fairly nippy.

I won't push Audi on the tyres then. I don't think the current treads are wildly out of sync, one's at 3mm and the other at 4mm. Audi have just decided to replace the 3mm one.... which I suppose is the least they can do given the premium they charge for their used approved stock biggrin I'm just normally used to replacing tyres in pairs as the tread depths are normally roughly the same.


Rick1.8t

1,463 posts

210 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Sounds like a pain in the bottom chasing tyre wear in the future though - e.g. remaining 4mm tyre wears requiring replacement and your new tyre is now also worn so you wont ever have 'even' tyres.

Maybe see if they can do a deal where you contribute to getting the other tyre replaced at the same time?

thatdude

2,660 posts

158 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Ask them to replace that one tyre, and ask them to fit another tyre on the other side at your expense perhaps

Than at least you have a new set of front tyres sorted out

Riley Blue

23,217 posts

257 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Most cars that have had a puncture will have tyres of different tread depths on the same axle, including my own Audi. I haven't experienced any significant aquaplaning.

vikingaero

13,573 posts

200 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
thatdude said:
Ask them to replace that one tyre, and ask them to fit another tyre on the other side at your expense perhaps

Than at least you have a new set of front tyres sorted out
^ This. Keep the 4mm one as a spare or buy a steel rim from eBay for it.

HertsBiker

6,443 posts

302 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Try calculating circumferences of both tyres. If there is more than 1% difference, consider that every 100 revolutions of one wheel, the other is doing 99 or 101. Maybe the diff will be fine, maybe it'll wear out faster. I'd get 2 new ones for sure. Or am I being paranoid?

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
BOBTEE said:
I'd prefer to have matching tyres, I'd pay for one myself to match up, especially when buying a car as it'll only cause more aggro down the line smile
This +1 .. Also no harm in asking them to change the one with only 4mm ? You never know your luck smile

eltax91

10,792 posts

237 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Foliage said:
Yes its fine, the only thing that shouldn't be on the same axle is different types of tyre ie radial and cross ply and since all (most) tyres are radial these days it really doesn't matter.
By the above you imply its perfectly safe to have two different sizes on the same axle, as the only thing that matters is tyre construction type??!! By your mark I could have a 15" and 17" wheel on the same axle.

I'm pretty sure that's why space savers are speed restricted.

It's an mot failure to have two tyres of different sizes on the same axle.