RE: Parking problems solved: Time For Tea?
RE: Parking problems solved: Time For Tea?
Thursday 26th March 2015

Parking problems solved: Time For Tea?

Fifth wheels, paternoster car parks and French brainiacs - solutions to problems throughout the ages!



If there's anything predictable about motoring, it's that everything is predictable. Think of what you might be absolutely convinced is the most original idea ever, and the chances are that if you go far enough back in automotive history you'll find it, or something very like it.

Take parking. Long before it was really an issue, Brainiacs types were coming up with genius solutions. Here's one from the late 1920s. If anyone can explain how this French madness works, Dan will send you a special prize of half his luncheon sandwich, which today is made from white bread, diet margarine, spam and lettuce. If you manage to build a working specimen, he'll send you the whole butty.

Why park yourself when there's a machine?
Why park yourself when there's a machine?
Good luck with it though, because there aren't that many modern cars you could base it on. For a start, it would have to be rear-wheel drive. Up front, you'd need full turning-wheel clearance. A Caterham, maybe? Your engineering efforts might compromise the Seven's handling purity somewhat, but surely this is worth it in exchange for the convenience of nabbing that impossible space.

Something a little simpler here, in the form of a homebrewed parallel-parking device that sort of follows the 90-degree wheel principle, but instead of complicating the steering mechanism, it's a rather more straightforward rear-end affair. Popular in Egypt apparently. Once again though, nothing new: here's an American version from the '50s.

You may prefer to leave the drudgery of parking to someone else. Or something else. Parking machines are a common sight in Japan nowadays, but they were around in the States nearly a hundred years ago, as this vid from 1932 Chicago shows. The idea of this 'paternoster' style structure attached to the side of an existing building (assuming you could find one with the external space for such a thing) was to minimise the car park's footprint. On that score at least this design works admirably. Woe betide anyone living within about half a mile of it, though: the clanking and snorting from this infernal machine must have been horrendous. And of course should the mechanism ever break down, which you'd guess it must have done on a fairly regular basis, that's you missing your appointment.

Back in the 1970s Leicester University had passenger versions of this paternoster system in some of its buildings. They consisted of an open-sided constantly-moving vertical belt of compartments. It moved pretty smartly too so you had to time your leap quite precisely to jump into the next hole. Not for the nervous or faint-hearted, or indeed for those on the other side of the bravery coin, i.e. drunken undergrads. You'd never get it past the health and safety now.

French madness here.

 

 

 

Author
Discussion

NDT

Original Poster:

1,767 posts

294 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
anyone ever tried a paternoster lift?
There was one in Oxford's engineering department - but by the time I got there it had been replaced with a boring conventional lift.

kiethton

14,669 posts

211 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
What killed the paternoster lift in buildings?

The Disability Discrimination Act - not possible to make one DDA compliant

Watchman

6,391 posts

276 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
Leicester Poly had a pedestrian one in the early 1990s - James Went building (now flattened). It was quite fun but you had to stand very still if you braved going over the top or into the pit because the cars decoupled from the guide rails there. If you rocked the car at all, preventing re-engagement into the guide rails, it would stop entirely and you'd be stuck until a pissed off janitor manually wound you round.

There was one in a Birmingham college or Uni in the 1950s and early 1960s - my Dad used to attend. It must have been bigger than the 2-man Leicester Poly one because there was room for my Dad and at least 2 of his colleagues - they used to play-up whoever got in first, holding him in until the last moment so that he went over the top.


And I'm certain there was an automatic car park near Victoria only 15-20 years ago. My company had an office in Greencoat Place, and I remember it being opposite, or at least very nearby on the walk from Victoria station. I don't work for that company any more neither Streetview or Bing shows me what I would have expected to see.

andyps

7,819 posts

313 months

Thursday 26th March 2015
quotequote all
There was a Paternoster lift in the NatWest bank building on King Street in Manchester in the 70's. My dad worked there and I I did go in it. Apparently the cleaners were frightened to use it as they didn't know what would happen if they didn't get off in time and ended up going around the top or bottom, one of my Dad's colleagues said to them one day that it was perfectly safe and he would show them by doing that. He got in the lift and once past the floor where he started he did a handstand so that when he went back passed the cleaners assumed it flipped at the top and bottom - don't think they used it still!

exceed

455 posts

207 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
Feel like I've come onto Classic Cars this morning. What is a posternaster or whatever you guys are talking about.

smile, this looks quite fun but obviously not possible in today's society with the massive variation in car sizes and as someone posted above the issue with DDA.

Watchman

6,391 posts

276 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
andyps said:
There was a Paternoster lift in the NatWest bank building on King Street in Manchester in the 70's. My dad worked there and I I did go in it. Apparently the cleaners were frightened to use it as they didn't know what would happen if they didn't get off in time and ended up going around the top or bottom, one of my Dad's colleagues said to them one day that it was perfectly safe and he would show them by doing that. He got in the lift and once past the floor where he started he did a handstand so that when he went back passed the cleaners assumed it flipped at the top and bottom - don't think they used it still!
Brilliant. hehe That chimes with another story my Dad told me about his abuse of the Birmingham Uni paternoster.

iloveboost

1,531 posts

193 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
At least one big problem with these parallel parking devices: How do cars that you've now parked a few cm away from, get out of their parking space?!

soad

34,759 posts

207 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
exceed said:
Feel like I've come onto Classic Cars this morning. What is a posternaster or whatever you guys are talking about.

smile, this looks quite fun but obviously not possible in today's society with the massive variation in car sizes and as someone posted above the issue with DDA.
A paternoster or paternoster lift is a passenger elevator which consists of a chain of open compartments (each usually designed for two persons) that move slowly in a loop up and down inside a building without stopping. Passengers can step on or off at any floor they like. The same technique is also used for filing cabinets to store great amounts of (paper) documents or for small spare parts. As a result of safety issues, many such lifts have been shut down. However, a few survive around the world. The largest of these is located in the Arts Tower at the University of Sheffield, which also remains the tallest university-owned building in the UK. Another one can be found at the IG Farben building In Frankfurt am Main. The much smaller Belt manlift which consists of an endless belt with steps and rungs but no compartments is also sometimes called a Paternoster.

Paternosters were popular throughout the first half of the 20th century as they could carry more passengers than ordinary elevators. They were more common in continental Europe, especially in public buildings, than in the United Kingdom. They are rather slow elevators, typically travelling at about 0.3 metre per second, thus improving the chances of getting on and off successfully.

The construction of new paternosters is no longer allowed in many countries because of the high risk of accidents (people tripping or falling over when trying to enter or exit). In 2012, an 81-year-old man was killed when he fell into the shaft of a paternoster in The Hague. Elderly people, disabled people, and children are the most in danger of being crushed. In 1989, the paternoster in Newcastle University's Claremont Tower was taken out of service after a passenger undertaking an up-and-over journey became caught in the drive chain, necessitating a rescue by the Fire Service. A conventional lift was subsequently installed in its place.

In April 2006, Hitachi announced plans for a modern paternoster-style elevator with computer-controlled cars and normal elevator doors to alleviate safety concerns. A prototype has been revealed as of February 2013.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paternoster



Video: paternoster at Arts Tower, University of Sheffield

330p4

668 posts

261 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
I remember the paternoster at Leicester university well good fun hopping on and off I worked for a large electronics distributor at the time went in with a case and about 20 catalogues had an appointment on the top floor and the dam thing had broken down
Ian

330p4

668 posts

261 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
I remember the paternoster at Leicester university well good fun hopping on and off I worked for a large electronics distributor at the time went in with a case and about 20 catalogues had an appointment on the top floor and the dam thing had broken down
Ian

330p4

668 posts

261 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
I remember the paternoster at Leicester university well good fun hopping on and off I worked for a large electronics distributor at the time went in with a case and about 20 catalogues had an appointment on the top floor and the dam thing had broken down
Ian

Pit Pony

11,515 posts

152 months

Friday 27th March 2015
quotequote all
There was a patenoster at the HQ of Lucas CAV / Lucas Diesel Systems in Acton London.

I went to visit their "Global Product Costing Manager"