Cabriolet rear screen cracked....
Cabriolet rear screen cracked....
Author
Discussion

tezzer

Original Poster:

984 posts

217 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
Youngest daughter selling her ford streetka, so I had it valeted yesterday. To finish the job off, I went to fold the roof down, and the rear(plastic) window cracked.

Phoned her insurance co. to see if it was covered as her policy states "we will replace or repair your windscreen or windows if they are damaged, without affecting your ncb". Except of course, they won't, because it's not glass. She could claim for accidental damage, but being 25 has a £600 excess on that section.

The upshot is they are considering a total loss, as it will not be economical to replace the entire roof, nor will they sanction the use of a non approved repair service, who will replace it for £120- £150.

My argument with them is the policy was based on them knowing it was a cabriolet with a plastic rear wondow, and the documentation supplied by them does not specify the material used in their documents for "windows" under their replacement guarantee.

r11co

6,244 posts

261 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
I think you are on to plums with this one. Almost every policy I have read refers to window glass replacement so that is pretty final IMO. Don't go by the wording of the schedule BTW as that is just a summary of the cover.

Get a formal quote for a repair on paper (£120-£150 sounds about right) and discount the car by that amount, or just stump up.

Edited by r11co on Saturday 28th March 07:55

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
She is not going to thank you for the excess, loss of no claims bonus and hiked up premiums for the next 3 years....

A plastic window cracking on a cabriolet is so obviously age related wear and tear I'm amazed the insurance haven't told you it's not their concern. Sometimes they can be cut out/stitching removed and replaced but I bet a replacement roof can be sourced for considerably less than the costs of going through the insurance.

r11co

6,244 posts

261 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
dme123 said:
She is not going to thank you for the excess, loss of no claims bonus and hiked up premiums for the next 3 years....
yes

Insurance exists to protect you and others from otherwise unforeseen or unfortunate accidents. This is definitely a wear-and-tear issue so attempting to claim on it is verging on fraud IMO.

*Al*

3,830 posts

253 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
Just pay yourself to repair, £120-£150 isn't the end of the world is it?

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
r11co said:
yes

Insurance exists to protect you and others from otherwise unforeseen or unfortunate accidents. This is definitely a wear-and-tear issue so attempting to claim on it is verging on fraud IMO.
It's still early. But the daft comment of the day award goes to...

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
Jimboka said:
r11co said:
yes

Insurance exists to protect you and others from otherwise unforeseen or unfortunate accidents. This is definitely a wear-and-tear issue so attempting to claim on it is verging on fraud IMO.
It's still early. But the daft comment of the day award goes to...
Except for the small detail that it's true.

tezzer

Original Poster:

984 posts

217 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
how can it be fraud if I asked them if it's covered ? Peculiar thought process there.

I'm happy to pay to have it repaired, rather than have them declare it a total loss for the sake of a cracked plastic window.

r11co

6,244 posts

261 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
tezzer said:
how can it be fraud if I asked them if it's covered ? Peculiar thought process there.
Because it was not accidental damage/vandalism/attempt to gain entry for the purposes of theft, which is what glass cover is provided to protect against.

I can understand the though process behind thinking that this might be covered, but a lot of window claims are borderline fraudulent ('fancied a new windscreen because the old one was scratched, so hit it with a brick.... whistle ) but insurance companies let it pass. This is a clear example of where the borderline has been crossed.

Think of it this way - your policy might say paint damage can be claimed for, but while that would include damage due to someone running a key down the side of the car it would not extend to getting a respray because the paint has faded due to UV damage....

Edited by r11co on Saturday 28th March 09:04

frisbee

5,633 posts

141 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
Stick some clear tape over the crack, accept a slightly lower offer for the car from a buyer...

Mave

8,217 posts

246 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
If they're saying it's not covered, why are they also considering it a total loss? Surely it's nothing to do with them?

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
Mave said:
If they're saying it's not covered, why are they also considering it a total loss?
Because if it IS covered, the "proper" repair (using manufacturer parts, etc) is to replace the entire roof, which is not economically viable.

Mave

8,217 posts

246 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
Because if it IS covered, the "proper" repair (using manufacturer parts, etc) is to replace the entire roof, which is not economically viable.
Yes, but in the op he said it wasn't covered and he's arguing that is should be covered because they didn't explicitly state it wasn't. So if it's not covered, why has the subject if writing off the car been raised?

Toaster Pilot

14,867 posts

189 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
Have you looked at the cost of a second hand complete roof ?

TwigtheWonderkid

49,274 posts

181 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
Jimboka said:
r11co said:
yes

Insurance exists to protect you and others from otherwise unforeseen or unfortunate accidents. This is definitely a wear-and-tear issue so attempting to claim on it is verging on fraud IMO.
It's still early. But the daft comment of the day award goes to...
Except for the small detail that it's true.
It would only be fraud if the OP realised the damage was due to wear and tear, knew his policy didn't cover wear and tear, so decided to try and claim whilst hiding the true cause.

In this case, whilst I agree it's wear and tear, there is no evidence to suggest the OP has tried to tell the insurers otherwise, or even knew wear and tear wasn't covered, or knew himself it was wear and tear.

So your fraud allegation appears not to be true.

edc

9,695 posts

282 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
If you're a long time owner if a plastic window convertible then you will know this is just an occupational hazard and an inevitability at some point. It should be about £150-300 to stitch in a replacement panel. They can do it on a Boxster so can't see why they can't on a Ka.

Glassman

25,102 posts

246 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
Choose your battles. Windscreen and glass cover does not include cabriolets; in fact, I'm sure ragtops come under exclusions.

Take the hit. I know a place in north London who'll sort it and won't charge a fortune.

chris watton

22,552 posts

291 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
We have had soft tops in our family for a decade and a half, and at no point have I ever thought that the rear plastic screen was covered in the same category as windscreen/side glass. When they need changing, I just pay for the replacement. Never once considered going through my insurance company!

Swoxy

2,842 posts

241 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
My friend had a policy which included windscreen cover, didn't specify whether it had to be glass and didn't exclude convertibles. I helped her negotiate with her insurer who eventually agreed to have the rear windscreen replaced by BMW at a cost to the insurer of £450.

g3org3y

22,523 posts

222 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
edc said:
If you're a long time owner if a plastic window convertible then you will know this is just an occupational hazard and an inevitability at some point.
This. yes