New Car - Any benefit from "premium" diesel?
New Car - Any benefit from "premium" diesel?
Author
Discussion

bitchstewie

Original Poster:

68,520 posts

241 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
I know this one gets done to death but mostly on petrol from what I can see.

I have a brand new car, Golf with the 2.0 Bluemotion TDI lump in it.

I've always tended to use Shell for fuel as my perception, maybe wrongly, is that it's a bit more of a known quantity than others.

Given a brand new car with a brand new engine, is there any sense at all in using stuff like V-Power regularly vs. alternating every X fill-ups?

I guess the simply answer is try it and see, just trying to understand the "science" because I get that v-power petrol is higher RON but I don't really understand the diesel equivalent as I thought they were less fussy - I know one lad who ran his diesel off chip fat (though it did sort of implode not sure if it was related) biggrin

adsk

109 posts

190 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
I've used premium diesel in my volvo since new over the past 6 years. I do a mainly diesel-unfriendly urban driving and never had any DPF issues. I'd be happy using regular diesel if I was doing long journeys most of the time.

bitchstewie

Original Poster:

68,520 posts

241 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
adsk said:
I've used premium diesel in my volvo since new over the past 6 years. I do a mainly diesel-unfriendly urban driving and never had any DPF issues. I'd be happy using regular diesel if I was doing long journeys most of the time.
Probably should have added that my daily commute is 20 miles each way mostly A roads.

ZX10R NIN

30,662 posts

156 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
I use BP Ultimate for my longer runs and average around 50-60 miles more per tank on my mapped 320cdi compared to regular diesel so I'd say it makes a difference also the my car feels smoother & picks up better same for the OH's Alpina D3

DaveH23

3,355 posts

201 months

philmots

4,666 posts

291 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
I don't use the diesel in the wives new diesel but always use the regular Shell..

I used to use the V Power diesel in my old 335d and saw roughly 20 miles extra to the tank and it felt keener too.

The extra miles probably doesn't make the cost up so I decided it wasn't worth it on the wives car as she wouldn't notice it feeling a bit better. If I used it more I'd use it.

If it was an older car out of warranty I'd use it whatever. Its 'meant' to help keep stuff clean.

soad

34,767 posts

207 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
DaveH23 said:
Fifth Gear Fuel test

Mopar440

410 posts

143 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
philmots said:
I don't use the diesel in the wives new diesel but always use the regular Shell..
That's not good for the engine. I believe you should really use diesel. silly

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Saturday 28th March 2015
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
...

I guess the simply answer is try it and see, just trying to understand the "science" because I get that v-power petrol is higher RON but I don't really understand the diesel equivalent as I thought they were less fussy - I know one lad who ran his diesel off chip fat (though it did sort of implode not sure if it was related) biggrin
The diesel equivalent of RON in petrol is something called "cetane rating" (I believe it is essentially the opposite of petrol's RON because the two types of engine are fundamentally different in how ignition is initiated), so try researching this? smile

Regards the "chip fat implosion", some diesel injection pumps can cope with chip fat etc and others can't... I'm guessing the injection pump topped itself, rather than the engine itself - but it's a several hundred quid bill at least frown .

to3m

1,228 posts

201 months

Sunday 29th March 2015
quotequote all
I put posh diesel in my 320d for about a year, as a long-term test, and didn't notice enough of a difference in MPG to make up for the price. It did feel like the engine sounded a bit smoother and was happier to rev a bit more - not very scientific, but I suppose it might have been having some kind of an effect. But for the price I'd expect more than that.

In 2012 I tried it with my 330d for about 4 months. No difference at all.

LanceRS

2,235 posts

168 months

Sunday 29th March 2015
quotequote all
I put the 'posh' diesel into the family 2.0tdi Ford Smax, my wife doesn't, saying that it's a waste of money. She uses it more than I do, so I couldn tell you the difference in economy but it drives much better when I have filled it up. On the assumption that you don't have to try so hard to get the thing moving, it ought to use less fuel.
I usually put it in the fleet at work and they drive better as well.

Grayedout

418 posts

243 months

Sunday 29th March 2015
quotequote all
Yes it will make a difference in terms of engine cleanliness which helps prevent any issues with injector fouling which will lead to better fuel consumption.

The Mad Monk

11,578 posts

148 months

Sunday 29th March 2015
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
is there any sense at all in using stuff like V-Power regularly
Nah.

Save your money. Snake oil.

vikingaero

13,604 posts

200 months

Sunday 29th March 2015
quotequote all
If it's your own private motor that you plan to keep indefinitely then use it. If it's a lease car that goes back after 3 years then anything will do.

bitchstewie

Original Poster:

68,520 posts

241 months

Sunday 29th March 2015
quotequote all
It's my own vehicle. I was asking specifically from the diesel POV too as I know with petrol there is a clear potential performance benefit in the higher octane fuels.

vikingaero

13,604 posts

200 months

Sunday 29th March 2015
quotequote all
Opinions on premium fuels are very polarised on here. I run the family bus on V-Power diesel. It's a low mileage car (5 years old/37k) that I plan to keep so I only fuel it with V-Power Diesel. On my company car any fuel will do! When I run the Clubman on V-Power Unleaded the staining on the exhaust changes from black to a light grey colour and overall the car seems smoother. At the moment the Clubman is on V-Power, however if fuel price increases to the £1.40 range I'd probably switch back to standard fuel.

bitchstewie

Original Poster:

68,520 posts

241 months

Sunday 5th April 2015
quotequote all
I've been doing as much digging as I can and I've come to the conclusion that it seems a bit of a no-brainer to use the V-Power diesel.

If the MPG is identical then at 12,000 miles a year assuming 10ppl more for V-Power it works out at £100/year more than regular diesel.

Having just dropped a lot of money on a brand new car it seems a bit silly to care too much about that kind of saving on the assumption that using premium fuel certainly can't do any harm even if it's a matter of opinion how much good it does.

BritishRacinGrin

26,711 posts

191 months

Sunday 5th April 2015
quotequote all
Just try both and make your own mind up. My Mondeo TDCI seemed to run just as smoothly on normal BP diesel than any of the premiums, and I didn't observe much of an increase in economy if any so I subsequently stuck to normal diesel.

glasgowrob

3,349 posts

152 months

Sunday 5th April 2015
quotequote all
Run a mapped Mondeo tdci with quite agressive mapping

Normally runs on bp diesel tried it recently on ultimate economy nosedived but it did seem much premier and eager

Although I suspect the nosedive in economy may be due to me being more enthusiastic

Couldn't justify the price difference though as we get our bp diesel for 108 atm but our fuel card supplier bums is for premium fuel prices

Hitch78

6,119 posts

225 months

Sunday 5th April 2015
quotequote all
So after all of your digging you've found nothing factually positive, but have decided to plump for it because.....it's there?!