Queueing to join an already lengthy traffic jam - why?
Queueing to join an already lengthy traffic jam - why?
Author
Discussion

bitchstewie

Original Poster:

68,506 posts

241 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Got caught up today in traffic coming onto an island where a major A road and motorway cross.

Essentially about half a mile of slow traffic down the A road to the roundabout, at which point there was a queue of traffic backing up all the way from the motorway, and upon crossing the motorway bridge on my way round the island it was traffic as far as the eye could see down the motorway in both directions.

In short, nothing was going to be moving very quickly.

Now, at the roundabout there was a clear choice - queue to go down the sliproad and be faced with god knows how long of a delay, or continue down the A road or go some/any route whatsoever other than sitting queueing in traffic.

So why do many people sit and queue?

I've always taken the view that if I drive out of my way and it takes a bit longer so be it, but I'm moving.

Everyone's different but it seems a little bit of a strange choice vs. just trying to find another route?

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Because if you don't know an alternative route and have no map/sat nav you may well be fked either way. So, better the devil you know.

jimbobsimmonds

1,824 posts

196 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Maybe they don't know where they're going? Or know that the alternative is even worse!

But in general I'd rather be going somewhere roughly en route and just pretend I know where I'm going. Many a time have I said 'I know another way' in places that I can't possibly have been before smile

Issi

1,782 posts

181 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
This is a similar question that I ask of commuters.

There is one major road out of town that is nose to tail from about 1600 -1800 every day.

If people just thought about it, there are numerous little rat runs, short cuts etc which would save them many minutes every day, but they just sit there as 'this is the road that I use to get home, and not the parallel road 200m away'
Bonkers.

xRIEx

8,180 posts

179 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
I'd certainly rather be moving and I'll take a detour if I know the roads well (and what state that traffic will be in). It depends how long the detour will be, if it's going to add 20 or 30 miles on to my journey and be no quicker, I'll (unhappily) sit in traffic.

Roo

11,504 posts

238 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
I sit in traffic every morning and frequently see people turn off to take a short cut.

We always meet at the same set of lights about fifteen minutes. I've been quite happily listening to the radio whilst they've had to negotiate two schools, a leisure centre and a fairly narrow road that's used for several bus routes.

I know which journey is the least stressful to arrive at the same point at the same time.

btsidi

247 posts

262 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Having travelled from London to Kent daily for a couple of years, over the 500+ journeys unless you get lucky it makes no difference.


bitchstewie

Original Poster:

68,506 posts

241 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
I'll sit in traffic on my daily commute because, being my daily commute, I know (roughly) the point at which waiting vs. going "the long way" pays off.

I'm talking more about where you pretty much know you're in for an hour or so of delay because the moment you pull onto that sliproad you're in it for one full motorway junction.

speedking31

3,964 posts

167 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Because satnav says take the motorway rolleyes

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

187 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Generally its faster to just stay on course you were originally. The 'but I'm moving' argument is totally in your head and may cost you more fuel and time.


...and let's not ignore the fact you might not KNOW another route.

ch108

1,127 posts

164 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Many years ago trying to get home from a BTCC race meeting in Donington we got stuck in a massive tailback. I was driving and my mate decided to navigate us out of trouble. Armed only with a road atlas (no sat navs in these days), we set off on the country roads. After about 20 mins we decided to rejoin the main roads and ended up behind the same car we had originally been behind in the tailback. So trying to take a shortcut doesn't always work!

Although when I used to commute on the M8 everyday if there was a huge queue I would come off and go through the east end of Glasgow and rejoin the M73. (This before the M74 extension). I knew it wouldn't save me much in the way of time but it felt like i was moving at more than 2mph and probably saved my clutch too.

Hoofy

80,183 posts

313 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
dave_s13 said:
Because if you don't know an alternative route and have no map/sat nav you may well be fked either way. So, better the devil you know.
yes

Plus if you look at your clock, the time you spend driving round may be longer than the time sitting in traffic. It might seem shorter because you're waving your arms around compared to sitting staring at the tailgate of the car in front. Try both next time and make a note of the times.

Took me years to figure out why everyone sat in the same traffic jam near me every morning even though there were faster if longer routes. I mean, you would think they'd have worked out that there are quicker routes through back roads by now. Turns out, sitting in the traffic jam took about 15 minutes to the problem junction, driving round took about 15 minutes plus all the effort of squeezing between parked cars and turning corners all the time.

bitchstewie

Original Poster:

68,506 posts

241 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Tbh I wouldn't doubt the maths behind it, and I probably don't do enough journeys outside of the commute to have masses of experience here, but I just think I'd take an hour longer and another 50 miles on my trip vs. "sit in this for 2 hours bumper to bumper with nowhere to go".

Point taken about nav and atlases but it's a little worrying if people don't have enough basic awareness to know that "XYZ big city is roughly that direction" and just head off - what did we do before Sat Nav? biggrin

shake n bake

2,221 posts

238 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Britains loves queuing, that's why!

Nickbrapp

5,277 posts

161 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
Because I get paid even when I'm sat in traffic! Who doesn't love a easy day?

Hoofy

80,183 posts

313 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
Tbh I wouldn't doubt the maths behind it, and I probably don't do enough journeys outside of the commute to have masses of experience here, but I just think I'd take an hour longer and another 50 miles on my trip vs. "sit in this for 2 hours bumper to bumper with nowhere to go".

Point taken about nav and atlases but it's a little worrying if people don't have enough basic awareness to know that "XYZ big city is roughly that direction" and just head off - what did we do before Sat Nav? biggrin
Given modern tech, you could probably work things out on Google Maps live if you specify to show traffic jams and fiddle with routes.

cH3wY

287 posts

176 months

Monday 30th March 2015
quotequote all
I commute 27miles each way, 5 miles of A road, 17 motorway then 5 more a road. The motorway, when clear, is a 35min run through 50mph roadworks. Wednesday to Friday evening its anywhere from 30-60mins to do the 5miles to the motorway at the work end, this would bump journey time up to 90mins on average. Taking the B road route and joining the motorway a junction up is 10 mins longer than the motorway route at its fastest. B roads all the way home is still sub an hour. I also do the same on Monday mornings etc to join the motorway at the home end.

I check the traffic as I am leaving work on my phone using Waze and Google Maps. Knowing roughly when and what times to use my shortcuts saves me at least 2-3hours a week.