Red diesel : hypothetical question
Red diesel : hypothetical question
Author
Discussion

feef

Original Poster:

5,211 posts

214 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Hypothetical question:

Red diesel is not permitted for use in road vehicles.


Red diesel is permitted for use in generators, for heating, marine and agricultural vehicles.


If you were to charge an electric vehicle from a generator, powered by red diesel and used solely for the purpose of charging that electric vehicle, would that be illegal or not?

Fastdruid

9,415 posts

183 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
In theory there is nothing different from charging the car from the mains or the generator and there is nothing to say what you can charge from a red-diesel powered generator so I'd suggest that from that POV it logically *should* be fine.

However HMRC are a law unto themselves so I'd expect it to be illegal unless specifically allowed. biggrin

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Perfectly legal - there's no stipulation about where the electricity used in an electric car has to come from.

At the end of the day a hookup to the grid would be much more cost effective than a diesel generator.

marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
There is a list of excepted vehicles, which are allowed to use red diesel on the road. Electric vehicles aren't in the list.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/excise-...

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
marshalla said:
There is a list of excepted vehicles, which are allowed to use red diesel on the road. Electric vehicles aren't in the list.
Of course they're not, since they don't use diesel of any colour on the road...

Now, if the i3 REX was diesel instead of petrol, THAT could be an interesting test case.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
At the end of the day a hookup to the grid would be much more cost effective than a diesel generator.
yes Much cheaper!

feef

Original Poster:

5,211 posts

214 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
marshalla said:
There is a list of excepted vehicles, which are allowed to use red diesel on the road. Electric vehicles aren't in the list.
Of course they're not, since they don't use diesel of any colour on the road...

Now, if the i3 REX was diesel instead of petrol, THAT could be an interesting test case.
I think that depends on your definition of "use".. the electric vehicle will have, in this case, used red diesel to allow it to travel on the public road. There's nothing in the red diesel to specifically state that the diesel needs to be carried in a tank on the vehicle for use in an onboard combustion engine.

Yes, I'm arguing semantics and being a pedantic sod :P

Pothole

34,367 posts

313 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
feef said:
TooMany2cvs said:
marshalla said:
There is a list of excepted vehicles, which are allowed to use red diesel on the road. Electric vehicles aren't in the list.
Of course they're not, since they don't use diesel of any colour on the road...

Now, if the i3 REX was diesel instead of petrol, THAT could be an interesting test case.
I think that depends on your definition of "use".. the electric vehicle will have, in this case, used red diesel to allow it to travel on the public road. There's nothing in the red diesel to specifically state that the diesel needs to be carried in a tank on the vehicle for use in an onboard combustion engine.

Yes, I'm arguing semantics and being a pedantic sod :P
Have you thought of a scenario where you're likely to get 'caught'?

Motorrad

6,811 posts

218 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Krikkit said:
Perfectly legal - there's no stipulation about where the electricity used in an electric car has to come from.

At the end of the day a hookup to the grid would be much more cost effective than a diesel generator.
This and it's a hell of a lot easier to steal electricity than it is to use red diesel or steal fuel. Assuming of course you're a scrote.

feef

Original Poster:

5,211 posts

214 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Pothole said:
feef said:
TooMany2cvs said:
marshalla said:
There is a list of excepted vehicles, which are allowed to use red diesel on the road. Electric vehicles aren't in the list.
Of course they're not, since they don't use diesel of any colour on the road...

Now, if the i3 REX was diesel instead of petrol, THAT could be an interesting test case.
I think that depends on your definition of "use".. the electric vehicle will have, in this case, used red diesel to allow it to travel on the public road. There's nothing in the red diesel to specifically state that the diesel needs to be carried in a tank on the vehicle for use in an onboard combustion engine.

Yes, I'm arguing semantics and being a pedantic sod :P
Have you thought of a scenario where you're likely to get 'caught'?
nope.. which is why it's a purely hypothetical question. I don't have an electric car, and it's cheaper to use mains than a gennie.. It's just an interesting question.

Pothole

34,367 posts

313 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
feef said:
Pothole said:
feef said:
TooMany2cvs said:
marshalla said:
There is a list of excepted vehicles, which are allowed to use red diesel on the road. Electric vehicles aren't in the list.
Of course they're not, since they don't use diesel of any colour on the road...

Now, if the i3 REX was diesel instead of petrol, THAT could be an interesting test case.
I think that depends on your definition of "use".. the electric vehicle will have, in this case, used red diesel to allow it to travel on the public road. There's nothing in the red diesel to specifically state that the diesel needs to be carried in a tank on the vehicle for use in an onboard combustion engine.

Yes, I'm arguing semantics and being a pedantic sod :P
Have you thought of a scenario where you're likely to get 'caught'?
nope.. which is why it's a purely hypothetical question. I don't have an electric car, and it's cheaper to use mains than a gennie.. It's just an interesting question.
Not really, but hey ho.

David87

7,046 posts

243 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
Now, if the i3 REX was diesel instead of petrol, THAT could be an interesting test case.
Indeed it would. hehe

Gavin0478

480 posts

172 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Could you not just recycle cooking oil to use in the diesel generator as it would be cheaper than red diesel and you can use a substantial amount of the bio fuel before it becomes subject to vat?

J4CKO

47,100 posts

231 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
I think you are ok until they develop red electricity.

Vacumatic

188 posts

144 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
I used red diesel in an industrial steam pressure washer. Because I was seen and reported filling a container with red diesel at a garage. HMRC seized my car and took it to a lab to see if it had any red diesel inside the tank, this was on a sunday lunchtime with all the family round, until I made a fuss they said the car would not be back for 24 hours, because it was weekend working.

You really dont want to mess with these guys and for the small amount of fuel that is used in a generator or washer etc dont pi55 about.



Edited by Vacumatic on Tuesday 31st March 17:34

feef

Original Poster:

5,211 posts

214 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
So what if you towed the generator behind you, keeping the car charged? :P

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Vacumatic said:
HMRC sized my car and took it to a lab to see if it had any red diesel inside the tank.
Why didn't they just dip it, like they normally do?

Paradaxos

135 posts

149 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Yeaah I suppose it wouldn't be illegal although I don't think it would really save you any money either. Charging an electric vehicle in the UK is surely cheaper than buying X litres of red diesel to generate Y watts of energy to charge your EV with?

Although maybe that isn't going to be the case forever. Until we move to nuclear in the UK which has been delayed for far longer than it should have been electricity is going to get expensive in the next 10 years.

And I would think that with the investment into production of biodiesel, red diesel would increase in price slower than mains electricity?

I don't know.

The increase in EV ownership in the next 10 years is going to raise demand for mains energy by a large margin if it takes off as fast as it looks like it might.

Electric fleet cars etc.

This has been a ramble.

J4CKO

47,100 posts

231 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
I think HMRC lurk round at farmers markets and pounce on anyone in an old 405 estate or Pajero.


aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
HMRC also visit marinas (not the car rolleyes ) and horsey events...

Ie places where red diesel is either available, or places where it is very likely the weaker-willed diesel vehicle owners visiting such places will have access to red diesel elsewhere wink .