E90 330d manual or auto?
E90 330d manual or auto?
Author
Discussion

Stevenr

Original Poster:

948 posts

225 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Looking at getting another BMW and due to a lack of manual cars taking my fancy I'm coming round to the idea of an auto.

Now I would hope that the auto boxes have come a long way since I drove one last but I'm still just not sure,she who must be obeyed isn't keen either yet.

Looking for any info really,good or bad idea?

It will be mostly town driving with the odd run out on the open road at weekends,bearing in mind I live in the far north of Scotland so spirited driving is on the cards.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Auto without question.

Also if you did want to remap it the autobox can handle the higher torque as its the same box in the 335d while the stick shifter cannot handle as much.

djdest

6,542 posts

209 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Mine is a remapped manual, no issues with it at all

JeffreyLebowski

453 posts

238 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Lots of other threads on this if you do a search smile You'll find lots of other people saying the auto 'suits' the engine, and that it is a cardinal sin to want a manual with a Diesel engine.
Imo the engine is completely irrelevant, if you prefer autos then get an auto, if you prefer manuals then get a manual. End of.

I had an auto e46 330d for two years (I had to change cars in a rush and couldn't hold out for a manual), the gearbox drove me nuts and spoiled the car for me - thirsty, dim witted, and, for a control freak like me, always in the wrong gear. I've now had my e91 330d manual for 2 months and I love it - the gearbox has a pleasingly mechanical feel to it, the ratios are well spaced, it will pull happily from 50mph in 6th if you choose (you could drive everywhere without exceeding 2k rpm and keep up with traffic, so the stories of constant cog swapping that the auto only brigade like to tell are a myth), and I'm happy to be back in control of what gear I'm in. The fact that it is faster and more economical than the auto is the icing on the cake.

In case it isn't obvious from the above, I'm very much in favour of the manual, and would say if that's what you want, then hold out for one, you won't regret it smile

Edited by JeffreyLebowski on Tuesday 31st March 22:04

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
A diesel that will spend the majority of its life in town. Why would you even consider a manual?

Stevenr

Original Poster:

948 posts

225 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Hmm differing opinions,I must add the town in question is Inverness so nothing like the larger cities.

The idea of the auto handling more power did cross my mind after looking at a 335 too at the weekend too.

Back to the classifieds for another look


Ultuous

2,291 posts

222 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
I ended up buying an auto (325i) despite never thinking I would for the same reasons (couldn't find a manual in the spec/ condition I wanted and had to be won-over by an extended test drive... 12 months on I'm converted, as 99% of the time (even for most B-road blasts in m/s mode) it does exactly what I want.

The only times I'm left wishing I had a manual are for those sudden, short overtaking opportunities that present themselves when either me and/ or the box has got a little lethargic (where the 325 really wants to be revved - I'd imagine the torque on a 330d would alleviate the need to down-change very much) or when I'm feeling really 'in the zone' and want that extra control of a manual set-up - I've concluded that's best saved for when I can have a sports car/ hot (or even mildly warm!) hatch on the drive too - the 3 series hides it's speed well as a 'cruiser' and isn't really about that!

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
djdest said:
Mine is a remapped manual, no issues with it at all
Well the stock shift is torque rates lower than the auto - so provided the remap is at or below that then its fine, if its more then its being stressed beyond its safe level. Could last one more drive or half a million who knows. Driving style and aggression also comes into play but auto would be best option firstly as the choice is so much more v hardly any made to begin with so a miniscule number now.

LordJammy

3,114 posts

220 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
I drive an E90 330d on a regular basis, the auto really suits it. It wafts along when you can't be arsed and when you're up for a drive flick it over to manual and knock it up and down through the gears.
It's perfect for destroying chavs who fancy their chances.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
LordJammy said:
I drive an E90 330d on a regular basis, the auto really suits it. It wafts along when you can't be arsed and when you're up for a drive flick it over to manual and knock it up and down through the gears.
It's perfect for destroying chavs who fancy their chances.
My auto in the e90 330d and the F10 535d are really really good. Smooth seamless changes. You can chill out and relax in traffic and have a lot of fun when the chance arrives. These cars are so often stated as being the best real world car - economical (increased range fewer stops at petrol station), it is fast out of the box very good at the overtaking and has the great ability of lower reving so wife's not complaining about going too fast
Noise is quiet not dagadagadaga

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

265 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
These are not sports cars so the auto is the way forward IMO. My mum has one and it does everything expected.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
SidewaysSi said:
These are not sports cars so the auto is the way forward IMO. My mum has one and it does everything expected.
Hardly any sold new.

Used there will be single digits for sale at any one time and the chance of then having the spec you need and geographic proximity to you to buy means its a non starter unless you are really lucky.

Stevenr

Original Poster:

948 posts

225 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
I've come across a coupe that's not too far away,manual with black leather so fits the bill there.Don't think I could live with the red or cream.A coupe hadn't really crossed my mind until tonight.

Is there much if any difference between the saloon and coupe in the chassis department? My last BMW was a 330i touring and it handled well I thought for a big bus so i'd imagine the saloon would be along the same lines.

Loudy McFatass

8,999 posts

218 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
while the stick shifter
Which part of America are you from?

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Loudy McFatass said:
Welshbeef said:
while the stick shifter
Which part of America are you from?
I love the US

Stick shift
3 on the tree
4 on the floor

wink