Frustrating tyre reviews...........
Frustrating tyre reviews...........
Author
Discussion

PistonheadRob

Original Poster:

49 posts

147 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Hi I am currently looking for some new tyres and have been looking at online reviews and car forums for reviews and feedback.
I understand that different tyres suit different cars/drivers and their driving styles etc but the reviews vary so much!!!! I think a lot is in peoples heads because the reviews cant vary so much.
One review will say they are amazing grip in wet and dry and wear rate is excellent, then another review will say worst tyres ever useless ditch finders and have nearly worn out in no time.......
this varies from forum to forum and different tyre review sites, I just decide on one tyre to order then the next review I read says rubbish.
There then seems to be some brand snobs who if it is not a top brand they are rubbish and this is not always the case. They say they bought a car and it had x brand on and they where rubbish so they replaced them and the difference was instant. Some mid range tyres are very good and are adequate for most cars and drivers.

what are other peoples thoughts on this ?

jagnet

4,442 posts

233 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
PistonheadRob said:
what are other peoples thoughts on this ?
Stick to properly measured comparison tests rather than anecdotal evidence in the main. Even amongst those there are occasional anomalies, but across multiple tests it's easy to see which tyres tend to come out on top.

Davie

6,281 posts

246 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Reviews written by Joe Public are garbage... nothing more than conflicting opinions so you only end up lost in a sea of doubt and depression. As said, some of the magazine / website reviews are better but then again I wonder how many agreeable lunches and free F1 passes change hands to help massage the results....

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
my rule is, ignore anything, anyone ever tells you about tyres, it's a whole industry built on very small differences and marketing fluff to make those small differences seem really really really important

poing

8,743 posts

231 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
I look at this one: http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk

I take most of the results with a pinch of salt and only use it as part of the buying process. Over the years I've been mostly happy with my choices but there are a couple of times when I've been left disappointed despite my best efforts. Good luck.

PistonheadRob

Original Poster:

49 posts

147 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Hi yes I was looking at the tyre review site you listed, can be confusing......
I think the manufacturer ads clearly work on some people.

jagnet

4,442 posts

233 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
ging84 said:
my rule is, ignore anything, anyone ever tells you about tyres, it's a whole industry built on very small differences and marketing fluff to make those small differences seem really really really important
Often the differences are small, particularly amongst the better tyres, but when comparing premium to budget the differences are noticeable:

tyrereviews said:
As always, the gap in the dry isn't too large, with the best to worst being seperated by under 5 metres when stopping from 100 kph. In the wet however the range is much larger. When stopping from the same speed on a wet track, the difference is over 38 meters!
http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Article/2015-Market-O...

38 meters difference braking from 62mph in the wet eek

expensivegarms

683 posts

228 months

Tuesday 31st March 2015
quotequote all
Personally, I think it depends on driving style. Any tyres I've had, i've adapted my driving style to suit them, unless they're hideously st like the Nankangs I had on the Corsa when I first got it. I had Kumho's on my ST before the Toyos, I find I have to drive slightly slower in the wet now I have these, but can drive slightly quicker in the dry. Personally I think it's different strokes for different folks.

PositronicRay

29,110 posts

214 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
The method I use (for most things actually)

Ignore the really cheap/expensive stuff.

Look @ feedback/reviews for midrange (ignore items with only a few reviews) and look @ the best rating for type of item/features I want. A Brand I recognise always helps, but not the be all and end all. Brands get confusing/diluted/improved.

Seems to work, from holiday accomodation, electronics, household items, tools & tyres.

karma mechanic

841 posts

153 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
I hate it when people over-generalise. 'The Pirellis wore down really quickly, I'll never buy Pirelli again'... It is almost as if most people buy on brand rather than the suitability of the tyre for their car and driving. There is also the 'replaced worn-out xxxxx tyres and the new yyyyy tyres were a huge improvement in grip and much quieter'. Of course they were, the xxxxx tyres were worn out...

CallorFold

860 posts

164 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
Tyre Reviews seem excellent - great little chart showing how each aspect of the tyre is rated.

http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Tyres_For/Renault/cli...

I'll almost certainly be picking up Eagle F1's next unless the Vreds are considerably cheaper at the time.

r11co

6,244 posts

261 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
jagnet said:
http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Article/2015-Market-O...

38 meters difference braking from 62mph in the wet eek
ABS systems on many cars are optimised for particular line-fit tyres. Very often a tyre that 'wins' in this sort of comparison will not perform nearly as well when fitted to a different vehicle, and if the entire test was re-run using a different tyre size/test vehicle the order can vary quite considerably.

I've only ever seen one tyre test where different vehicles were used and different sizes of the same tyres were tested. It was conducted in Australia, and when the results were averaged out across the different test conditions the margins between the tyres were minimal, with some expensive brands being embarassed by cheaper ones. What came across was that every tyre by every manufacturer is a compromise in one way or another and that a lot of tyres are developed specifically to do well in tests, just like certain manufacturers tweak their cars to perform exceptionally well under the letter of the C02 test conditions to win better tax levels, but don't actually perform significantly better in real world use.

Edited by r11co on Wednesday 1st April 12:05

Sump

5,512 posts

198 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
I don't read peoples reviews on tyres, that's just pointless. Lets say you are looking at reviews of the F452.

A chav running triangle tyres will find the F452 amazing.

A money no object chap running Super Sports will find the F452 rubbish.

RizzoTheRat

29,153 posts

223 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
Autobild are pretty good for tyre reviews, agree that users reviews are a waste of time as it's way to subjective.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
CallorFold said:
Tyre Reviews seem excellent - great little chart showing how each aspect of the tyre is rated.

http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Tyres_For/Renault/cli...

I'll almost certainly be picking up Eagle F1's next unless the Vreds are considerably cheaper at the time.
It's still just based on individual personal reviews. Also that won't tell you things like the fact that the Eagle F1's are utterly useless for track work - but then you probably wouldn't use a generic review site as a source for that information.

I tend to read as many comparison reviews as I can and make a choice from there based on how I'm going to be using the tyre. The requirements for a commuter tyre are pretty different to a weekend toy tyre. It's always a balance.

Ali_T

3,379 posts

288 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
RizzoTheRat said:
Autobild are pretty good for tyre reviews, agree that users reviews are a waste of time as it's way to subjective.
Just found a review on Tyrereview posted after zero miles! Some folk just want to be heard!

philmots

4,666 posts

291 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
As said a proper test in set conditions are probably the best comparison.

Someone who goes on Pistonheads raving about the £80 Falkens on his M3 is bound to say they're great, he's got to justify his cheapo purchase.

I've never seen them in a test be anything other than bad.

If you stick to the big names you generally won't go too far wrong, but make sure you buy a sporty tyre if you want decent grip..

For example, I've got Goodyears on my 550i.. But they're the NCT5 and they really struggle to get the power down in conditions anything other than perfect.

PositronicRay

29,110 posts

214 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
philmots said:
As said a proper test in set conditions are probably the best comparison.

Someone who goes on Pistonheads raving about the £80 Falkens on his M3 is bound to say they're great, he's got to justify his cheapo purchase.

I've never seen them in a test be anything other than bad.

If you stick to the big names you generally won't go too far wrong, but make sure you buy a sporty tyre if you want decent grip..

For example, I've got Goodyears on my 550i.. But they're the NCT5 and they really struggle to get the power down in conditions anything other than perfect.
http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Tyre/Goodyear/Eagle-NCT5.htm

http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Tyre/Falken/ZE914.htm

Just saying

Conscript

1,378 posts

152 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
Also, most people replace their tyres for a reason, usually wear.
So, a review saying "My new tyres (x), are a huge improvement over the old tyres (y) I had before!" is a bit worthless when you consider that tyre x is brand new whilst y is worn and like to be offering reduced performance anyway.

VolvoT5

4,155 posts

205 months

Wednesday 1st April 2015
quotequote all
Davie said:
Reviews written by Joe Public are garbage... nothing more than conflicting opinions so you only end up lost in a sea of doubt and depression. As said, some of the magazine / website reviews are better but then again I wonder how many agreeable lunches and free F1 passes change hands to help massage the results....
Not sure I agree. It is possible to filter out the garbage reviews with little effort. Then focus on the well written reviews and see what the general tend is. Tyrereviews is a decent site and I think the overall trend probably does reflect the quality of the tyre.

If all else fails I just buy Pireli P6000s, I have found them to be brilliant over the years.