Torn...upto £400/month VAG...BMW...Mercedes...
Discussion
Afternoon all.
First post here. I've been in turmoil for last few days, head spinning about which car to "aim" for next.
Currently driving an 08 Golf TDi Match. Becoming a little long in the tooth. Wife and I both have decent jobs currently so would like to spoil myself a little (not a lot).
Golf is probably worth 3-4k max trade in.
Could put 2-3k cash to that.
Do about 5-6k miles per year as I travel a lot. So I'm not against petrol. Must be auto box really though.
Budget is around £400/month. Although could stretch a little for right car. Prefer PCP or lease as don't like selling on cars.
Looking for something fairly comfortable (I'd estimate that 66% of my driving is on dual carriageway), nice place to be and quick.
Don't really care what they look like from outside too much, although it'll be parked on the road so nothing orange which may attract the attention of local idiots. Sat Nav, Park Assist (parallel parking on street), driving upgrades (ACC/DCC) would be my preference of options.
Current front runners
Golf GTD DSG 3/5Dr - Long lead time apparently on DSG box. Diesel (good MPG, short powerband).
Golf GTi DSG 3/5Dr - Long lead time apparently on DSG box. Fun to drive. Always hankered after GTi. Quick. Performance Pack.
Golf R DSG 3/5Dr - Long lead time apparently on DSG box. Fun to drive. AWD.
M135i Auto - Expensive...RWD (nervous)...small cabin. Reports of steering being not ideal. Petrol.
M125D Auto - An option.
335D xD Auto - Some great lease deals right now. But expensive to run. Bugger to park due to length. High insurance.
S3 S Tronic - AWD, Expensive. Bland looking? Options put it probably outside of my price range.
Don't fancy Skoda. Focus ST3 only comes in manual. Not sure what's available in the mercedes range.
EDIT - Should be new or nearly new (1 year max). Nothing too big due to space limitations.
Any thoughts or advice?
Thanks in advance.
First post here. I've been in turmoil for last few days, head spinning about which car to "aim" for next.
Currently driving an 08 Golf TDi Match. Becoming a little long in the tooth. Wife and I both have decent jobs currently so would like to spoil myself a little (not a lot).
Golf is probably worth 3-4k max trade in.
Could put 2-3k cash to that.
Do about 5-6k miles per year as I travel a lot. So I'm not against petrol. Must be auto box really though.
Budget is around £400/month. Although could stretch a little for right car. Prefer PCP or lease as don't like selling on cars.
Looking for something fairly comfortable (I'd estimate that 66% of my driving is on dual carriageway), nice place to be and quick.
Don't really care what they look like from outside too much, although it'll be parked on the road so nothing orange which may attract the attention of local idiots. Sat Nav, Park Assist (parallel parking on street), driving upgrades (ACC/DCC) would be my preference of options.
Current front runners
Golf GTD DSG 3/5Dr - Long lead time apparently on DSG box. Diesel (good MPG, short powerband).
Golf GTi DSG 3/5Dr - Long lead time apparently on DSG box. Fun to drive. Always hankered after GTi. Quick. Performance Pack.
Golf R DSG 3/5Dr - Long lead time apparently on DSG box. Fun to drive. AWD.
M135i Auto - Expensive...RWD (nervous)...small cabin. Reports of steering being not ideal. Petrol.
M125D Auto - An option.
335D xD Auto - Some great lease deals right now. But expensive to run. Bugger to park due to length. High insurance.
S3 S Tronic - AWD, Expensive. Bland looking? Options put it probably outside of my price range.
Don't fancy Skoda. Focus ST3 only comes in manual. Not sure what's available in the mercedes range.
EDIT - Should be new or nearly new (1 year max). Nothing too big due to space limitations.
Any thoughts or advice?
Thanks in advance.
Edited by GeordieSPG on Thursday 2nd April 16:51
For 5-6k miles per annum, forget diesel as it's not worth it.
For £400 a month you won't get anything exciting from Mercedes as the A45 is way overpriced.
I would look at both PCP deals and contract lease as there can be some cracking deals for 8k miles for £400 per month and you won't need all of the £5k-£6k deposit either.
So for me the choice for me would be the Golf R for your monthly price, as I think the M135i is going to cost more given that it's a new model and the S3 is pricey with options.
Going against my earlier point the 335d is a good lease vehicle and will fit your budget so could be worth looking at, but do you really need diesel and it's not going to be a fun car to drive.
To summarise Golf R versus M135i.
Work out your spec online, check out Broadspeed or similar for typical discounts, check out www.contracthireandleasing.com for average lease costs get yourself to the dealer, test-drive both and then haggle to wring the life out of them and get a deal that you are happy with.
For £400 a month you won't get anything exciting from Mercedes as the A45 is way overpriced.
I would look at both PCP deals and contract lease as there can be some cracking deals for 8k miles for £400 per month and you won't need all of the £5k-£6k deposit either.
So for me the choice for me would be the Golf R for your monthly price, as I think the M135i is going to cost more given that it's a new model and the S3 is pricey with options.
Going against my earlier point the 335d is a good lease vehicle and will fit your budget so could be worth looking at, but do you really need diesel and it's not going to be a fun car to drive.
To summarise Golf R versus M135i.
Work out your spec online, check out Broadspeed or similar for typical discounts, check out www.contracthireandleasing.com for average lease costs get yourself to the dealer, test-drive both and then haggle to wring the life out of them and get a deal that you are happy with.
Well you don't really need a diesel for that sort of mileage, but given your other criteria, what about a 535d M Sport?
https://www.contracthireandleasing.com/car-leasing...
https://www.contracthireandleasing.com/car-leasing...
Just noticed you mentioned the S3 being possibly outside your range.
They're under £350/mth with 6 months upfront if you have a look around on www.contracthireandleasing.com
They're under £350/mth with 6 months upfront if you have a look around on www.contracthireandleasing.com
Jimboka said:
Unless of course, like many, you prefer the way diesels drive.
Hahaha yeah right...The M135i Auto seems to be around £400 per month with a £2.4k deposit to lease (36 month deal), so likely around £450-£500 at a dealer.
Golf R's are much cheaper to lease on the same format as above 6+35, £325 per month with DSG but no other extras. The other advantage is the deposit is lower 6 x £325 = £1,925
Both the above are personal lease so include VAT.
Regardless of wanting to lease or not, consider the numbers and total cost of ownership and then use when haggling at a dealer if you want to go that route.
I think the "problem" with diesels is the fact that they seem to have better residuals. So can often get something higher in the range for similar money to petrol (maybe it's just my perception).
I'd love the 5 series but think parking it in my street would be a pain. Not that we intend to live here forever...hmmm
I'd love the 5 series but think parking it in my street would be a pain. Not that we intend to live here forever...hmmm
DUMBO100 said:
I got a Golf R DSG a week ago and am mightily impressed. It's 2 cars in 1,sensible family transport and then a massively entertaining hot hatch. I waited 6 moths for mine but I'm very glad that I chose the VW. You should also get a fair bit of change from your budget
The long lead time puts me off a little. I was so convinced, then started reading about delays and nonsense. I'll change my mind 500 times in the next 6-8 months!GeordieSPG said:
I think the "problem" with diesels is the fact that they seem to have better residuals. So can often get something higher in the range for similar money to petrol (maybe it's just my perception).
I'd love the 5 series but think parking it in my street would be a pain. Not that we intend to live here forever...hmmm
You are partly right but it depends on model e.g. 320d versus 320i the residuals will be better with the d.I'd love the 5 series but think parking it in my street would be a pain. Not that we intend to live here forever...hmmm
But when you are looking a hot hatches e.g 135i, S3, R etc there are no diesel equivalents so it's not really an issue.
If I was to buy a 5 series (unless M5) I would also buy a diesel as it's more suited to the car, especially with smaller engines e.g. 2.0d or 3.0d.
But the hot hatches you listed are so much more fun than any diesel and at your mileage the running costs will be minimal too especially if you buy a service pack from new.
Your current car, define long in the tooth?
200k Miles?
DPF issues?
an 08 car, is not that old, 7 years?
Personally, I'd buy something that I would enjoy driving and could afford to run, sod the depreciation.
I'd look at something like a E46 M3, or get a Mint E39 M5. You're willing to spend £400 a month, with you 6k deposit on a 12k car (example) 6k loan over 24 months is roughly £250, the £150 I would put into an MOT/Slush/Modification fund and let that build up, and if after a year and the car has been faultless, you've got £1800 to either spend all, a portion, or keep aside.
That way, you have the benefit of owning your car too.
A lease sounds great, but a Golf R is still merely a Golf. Whereas an M5 is a different league, and you never own the car.
All IMO
200k Miles?
DPF issues?
an 08 car, is not that old, 7 years?
Personally, I'd buy something that I would enjoy driving and could afford to run, sod the depreciation.
I'd look at something like a E46 M3, or get a Mint E39 M5. You're willing to spend £400 a month, with you 6k deposit on a 12k car (example) 6k loan over 24 months is roughly £250, the £150 I would put into an MOT/Slush/Modification fund and let that build up, and if after a year and the car has been faultless, you've got £1800 to either spend all, a portion, or keep aside.
That way, you have the benefit of owning your car too.
A lease sounds great, but a Golf R is still merely a Golf. Whereas an M5 is a different league, and you never own the car.
All IMO
I simply would like a new car. Fewer reliability, maintenance issues. I often drive 2-3 hours to catch a flight. I'd rather not be worrying about an older vehicle or leaving an hour earlier "just in case".
I work hard. I deserve something nice. I'm not prepared to spend an awful lot more than £400 simply because I don't do many miles.
I'm in a bit of a catch 22. 6000 miles last year. I'd rather they were comfortable. But £7000 per year for that (excluding other costs)...
Then again, if I was doing 20000 miles per year, I wouldn't WANT to spend a fortune on a nice car that'll be trashed...
I work hard. I deserve something nice. I'm not prepared to spend an awful lot more than £400 simply because I don't do many miles.
I'm in a bit of a catch 22. 6000 miles last year. I'd rather they were comfortable. But £7000 per year for that (excluding other costs)...
Then again, if I was doing 20000 miles per year, I wouldn't WANT to spend a fortune on a nice car that'll be trashed...
R2T2 said:
That way, you have the benefit of owning your car too.
A lease sounds great, but a Golf R is still merely a Golf. Whereas an M5 is a different league, and you never own the car.
All IMO
Does anyone really care about 'owning' the car?A lease sounds great, but a Golf R is still merely a Golf. Whereas an M5 is a different league, and you never own the car.
All IMO
I've bought £20k+ cars outright, financed others and now have a lease. It doesn't make any difference, IMO, how it's being funded; surely all that matters is the total cost of ownership?
(Serious question, not being arsey).
PorkInsider said:
Does anyone really care about 'owning' the car?
I've bought £20k+ cars outright, financed others and now have a lease. It doesn't make any difference, IMO, how it's being funded; surely all that matters is the total cost of ownership?
(Serious question, not being arsey).
That's how I feel really. The cash wouldn't be a massive issue to arrange. But it's a personal choice to want to do it this way.I've bought £20k+ cars outright, financed others and now have a lease. It doesn't make any difference, IMO, how it's being funded; surely all that matters is the total cost of ownership?
(Serious question, not being arsey).
demus24 said:
But then having a brand new car doesn't mean it will be completely faultless, this thread is a example.....www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&f=86&t=1498751&mid=306290&nmt=Brand+new+Golf+R+broke+down+today+after+12+days+ownership
No. That's fair comment. I don't have the statistics to back up this claim, but I'd imagine that generally a newer car has a lower occurrence rate of issues. Also, lower maintenance requirements etc. Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


