Urgent legal advice needed - selling a car to a dealer
Discussion
Hi guys,
I am selling my car and i have been speaking to some dealers about a trade sale as i could do with the money soon due to a separation.
A dealer (whom i won't mention the name of the for the time being), offered me a sum of money, and after some back and forth a figure was agreed to.
In the middle of his increases he said he would increase the price if i delivered it, however i did not see this point in the ebay messages as he was sending me messages every few minutes. We agreed on a deal and he then sent me through a purchase invoice for me to sign and return.
The contract had 2 terms i didn't like - i was to deliver the car, and payment would not be made until the car was delivered. The contract was not signed by me.
I messaged him and said it is a 500 mile round trip so it is not the right deal for me and was not what we had been discussing:
He is now saying if i don't sell him the car he is going to register an interest on it on HPI. Can he really do this? I have not signed his invoice sent to me, nor has he paid me ANY money (not even a deposit)
I am selling my car and i have been speaking to some dealers about a trade sale as i could do with the money soon due to a separation.
A dealer (whom i won't mention the name of the for the time being), offered me a sum of money, and after some back and forth a figure was agreed to.
In the middle of his increases he said he would increase the price if i delivered it, however i did not see this point in the ebay messages as he was sending me messages every few minutes. We agreed on a deal and he then sent me through a purchase invoice for me to sign and return.
The contract had 2 terms i didn't like - i was to deliver the car, and payment would not be made until the car was delivered. The contract was not signed by me.
I messaged him and said it is a 500 mile round trip so it is not the right deal for me and was not what we had been discussing:
He is now saying if i don't sell him the car he is going to register an interest on it on HPI. Can he really do this? I have not signed his invoice sent to me, nor has he paid me ANY money (not even a deposit)
Edited by dbsk on Tuesday 7th April 22:26
I'm not a solicitor...but I seem to remember that consideration for a contract (and by that I mean the funds, good and terms) don't have to be written or signed for, except for a very small number of transactions (like a house sale).
So even if you talked to him on the phone about accepting the deal or said yes in an e-mail or on a forum then that's a contract.
It sounds like you agreed to sell the car to him for an agreed price...but not the delivery or the payment terms. If that's the case, then it sounds like you're ok.
Re the HPI thing, I can't imagine that HPI will just accept someone ringing them and saying that they have an interest in it without proofs.
So even if you talked to him on the phone about accepting the deal or said yes in an e-mail or on a forum then that's a contract.
It sounds like you agreed to sell the car to him for an agreed price...but not the delivery or the payment terms. If that's the case, then it sounds like you're ok.
Re the HPI thing, I can't imagine that HPI will just accept someone ringing them and saying that they have an interest in it without proofs.
Edited by jezzaaa on Thursday 2nd April 18:27
Rick101 said:
I'm sure there is more to this but I won't speculate.
Just ignore him, I very much doubt he'll do owt. What's registering an interest anyway? Finance?
Nothing more than said...the offer wasn't as good as i was hoping for, so to drive 500 miles without being paid for the car just isn't worth the effort/risk/expense in my opinion.Just ignore him, I very much doubt he'll do owt. What's registering an interest anyway? Finance?
Buyer is acting like a knob and if you haven't signed his invoice and he's given you no monies, I'd walk away telling him you'll pass all future correspondence and actions to your solicitor.
Buyer also sounds like he has the potential to be the sort that that will lower the price on the day using a magnifying glass to tell you the car is not as described. All whilst you stand on his rainy forecourt 250 miles from home with a paid for train ticket in your pocket or the prospect of a day out to go 500 miles and arrive home with an unsold car...
Sorry, but this sounds like a really crap environment to do a deal...
If you are desperate then eBay 99p no reserve. Every item I've sold this way looks rubbish for 6 days and 23 1/2 hours and then following a frenzy of activity sells for more than I thought it was worth. It's got its risks, but it's easy to spot the knobs and handle accordingly.
Buyer also sounds like he has the potential to be the sort that that will lower the price on the day using a magnifying glass to tell you the car is not as described. All whilst you stand on his rainy forecourt 250 miles from home with a paid for train ticket in your pocket or the prospect of a day out to go 500 miles and arrive home with an unsold car...
Sorry, but this sounds like a really crap environment to do a deal...
If you are desperate then eBay 99p no reserve. Every item I've sold this way looks rubbish for 6 days and 23 1/2 hours and then following a frenzy of activity sells for more than I thought it was worth. It's got its risks, but it's easy to spot the knobs and handle accordingly.
dbsk said:
Thanks guys. It makes me feel a bit better that you are thinking along the same lines as me. I am really surprised the dealer is acting this way.
I need the car gone in the next month or so, so not needing to down the we buy your car route.
buI need the car gone in the next month or so, so not needing to down the we buy your car route.
You can't name and shame but just out of interest what sort of car are you selling and whereabouts is the dealer?
Well just to give you an update on this.
I spoke with my solicitor and we looked over the contract on detail and there were a few more extra bits put into the contract that were not discussed before hand (copies of reg doc, MOT, service book etc were required at the point of returning the signed contract) I was not told about this before and am not able to do this as the car is currently being stored by a third party and all the docs are there.
He has stated he is also seeking legal advice, but as i stated in the lengthy e-mail to him he has changed the terms of the deal to the point it does not resemble the original offer and will therefore not being going ahead.
I am extremely disappointed by the aggressive unprofessionalism of this dealer, and it is getting to the point that he is trying to bully me into selling him the car by making threats about what he will do on HPI.
Im selling the car due to a seperation from my other half so i can keep the house, so to say i could do without this stress as well is an understatement!
I spoke with my solicitor and we looked over the contract on detail and there were a few more extra bits put into the contract that were not discussed before hand (copies of reg doc, MOT, service book etc were required at the point of returning the signed contract) I was not told about this before and am not able to do this as the car is currently being stored by a third party and all the docs are there.
He has stated he is also seeking legal advice, but as i stated in the lengthy e-mail to him he has changed the terms of the deal to the point it does not resemble the original offer and will therefore not being going ahead.
I am extremely disappointed by the aggressive unprofessionalism of this dealer, and it is getting to the point that he is trying to bully me into selling him the car by making threats about what he will do on HPI.
Im selling the car due to a seperation from my other half so i can keep the house, so to say i could do without this stress as well is an understatement!
Edited by dbsk on Tuesday 7th April 21:51
He's a bulls
tter. Even if these was a binding contract formed between you (which seems unlikely from what you've said), and even if you have breached that contract and he sues you for that breach, he's under a duty to mitigate his loss. Unless you agreed to sell the car to him for significantly less than he would normally expect to pay for a car of that type, such that he could have expected to have made an abnormal profit from it, then it seems that he can quite easily mitigate his loss by finding another car to buy and sell on. Shouldn't be difficult given that that's his job. Whatever loss he may have been caused after taking such mitigating action will be pretty low, almost certainly not worth taking formal legal action over.
I wouldn't worry about it.
tter. Even if these was a binding contract formed between you (which seems unlikely from what you've said), and even if you have breached that contract and he sues you for that breach, he's under a duty to mitigate his loss. Unless you agreed to sell the car to him for significantly less than he would normally expect to pay for a car of that type, such that he could have expected to have made an abnormal profit from it, then it seems that he can quite easily mitigate his loss by finding another car to buy and sell on. Shouldn't be difficult given that that's his job. Whatever loss he may have been caused after taking such mitigating action will be pretty low, almost certainly not worth taking formal legal action over.I wouldn't worry about it.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




