2008 Civic VS 2007 Mini Cooper D
2008 Civic VS 2007 Mini Cooper D
Author
Discussion

puffnut

Original Poster:

59 posts

141 months

Friday 3rd April 2015
quotequote all
Title says it all.

Will have about £4000 to spend and these are the two cars I most like. The Civic would be the 2.2 litre diesel.
I would get a lower mileage Civic but I do love the Minis.

Whats your opinion?


rossub

6,069 posts

221 months

Friday 3rd April 2015
quotequote all
I currently have a Cooper D and had a Civic in the past.

The Civic is a fair bit quicker, but will use a little bit more fuel. The build quality of the Mini is better - it really is a solid little thing.

I wasn't a fan of the gearbox in the Civic and I'm sure you're aware to look out for the chocolate clutches. Other than than that, reliability is on a par so far. Nothing much did or has gone wrong with either of them for me. Cant comment on higher mileage though - sold the Civic at 60k and the Mini is on 61k.

My Civic was a Type S, so it looked better and handled better than the 5 doors.

puffnut

Original Poster:

59 posts

141 months

Friday 3rd April 2015
quotequote all
Hiya thanks for your reply. what do you mean by chocolate clutches?

Also which one is more fun to drive? I'm guessing its the Mini but is the Civic still fun?

Cheers

rossub

6,069 posts

221 months

Friday 3rd April 2015
quotequote all
The clutches on the Civic are a well known weak point, as they can't handle the power. If you test drive one, give it the absolute beans in every gear to make sure it's not slipping. I noticed mine slipping on the day I drove it home from the dealer and thankfully it was replaced FOC, along with the Dual Mass Flywheel.

I would say the Mini is more fun, yes. But it's still a diesel, so it's never going to be the same as a Cooper S.

stewy68

1,826 posts

274 months

Friday 3rd April 2015
quotequote all
The Mini is the obvious answer IMO however, the Honda is (by far) the best engine, despite as mentioned the clutch/flywheel is the Achilles Heel. Really down to what drive you prefer. For what it's worth, the Mini is my preference.

puffnut

Original Poster:

59 posts

141 months

Saturday 4th April 2015
quotequote all
Thanks very much, your posts have been much appreciated. I would love a mini. But for the amount I'm paying I think I can get a lower mileage civic. Do you think it is worth getting a lower mileage civic over a higher mileage mini?