Weekend toy: What to do? Fix or move on?
Discussion
Hi all
About 2 years ago, I bought a cat C write-off mx5, spotted on a post here that had been stood for a few months. I patched up the damage myself and got it through the vic and have been using it s a weekend toy ever since. I always thought I'd run it for 4 or 5 years and then build my kit car that I've always fancied.
I've done a couple of trackdays in it, but always felt like it lacked a bit of power. So around 10 months ago I bought a super charger kit from a forum member who was removing it from a car. That transformed the car and at 200hp I felt it was about right. The kit was fitted by a very well regarded specialist. It's got uprated rx8 injectors and some other goodies like a megasquirt ecu. .
About 2 months ago I fitted some coilovers as the suspension was pretty tired, which has compromised the on road handling somewhat, not tried it on track but I think it will be much improved.
Anyway, fast forward to yesterday and the car failed it's mot. Some very minor rust on the sill and concerning moreso its drastically failed the emissions test. It was also advised some minor rust on the front chassis legs. When this comes through enough to cause a fail, its the final nail in the coffin for this car I think.
If I strip it to bits, and part it out, I'd say I've confidently got £3k in parts. I don't think I'd see much over £2k as-is with the mot fail.
So, the decision is:- have it repaired, at unknown cost. I'm guessing it needs specialist tuning work on the ecu at a minimum, plus possibly the injectors reconditioning or a new lambda or new cat.
The other option is to part it out and put the £3k into something else. Thing is, I like the 200hp in the lightweight drop top, I'd be reluctant to buy and 'charge another mx5. That's leaves me with a leggy z4 3.0, possibly an early 2.5 boxster, or something else? Any kit cars out there (7 a like) based on something else in my bracket?
What's the general opinion out there? Have some variety and try something else? Or get the 5 running again and enjoy it some more?
About 2 years ago, I bought a cat C write-off mx5, spotted on a post here that had been stood for a few months. I patched up the damage myself and got it through the vic and have been using it s a weekend toy ever since. I always thought I'd run it for 4 or 5 years and then build my kit car that I've always fancied.
I've done a couple of trackdays in it, but always felt like it lacked a bit of power. So around 10 months ago I bought a super charger kit from a forum member who was removing it from a car. That transformed the car and at 200hp I felt it was about right. The kit was fitted by a very well regarded specialist. It's got uprated rx8 injectors and some other goodies like a megasquirt ecu. .
About 2 months ago I fitted some coilovers as the suspension was pretty tired, which has compromised the on road handling somewhat, not tried it on track but I think it will be much improved.
Anyway, fast forward to yesterday and the car failed it's mot. Some very minor rust on the sill and concerning moreso its drastically failed the emissions test. It was also advised some minor rust on the front chassis legs. When this comes through enough to cause a fail, its the final nail in the coffin for this car I think.
If I strip it to bits, and part it out, I'd say I've confidently got £3k in parts. I don't think I'd see much over £2k as-is with the mot fail.
So, the decision is:- have it repaired, at unknown cost. I'm guessing it needs specialist tuning work on the ecu at a minimum, plus possibly the injectors reconditioning or a new lambda or new cat.
The other option is to part it out and put the £3k into something else. Thing is, I like the 200hp in the lightweight drop top, I'd be reluctant to buy and 'charge another mx5. That's leaves me with a leggy z4 3.0, possibly an early 2.5 boxster, or something else? Any kit cars out there (7 a like) based on something else in my bracket?
What's the general opinion out there? Have some variety and try something else? Or get the 5 running again and enjoy it some more?
get it looked at by a mechanic you know/trust and get a proper diagnosis and a prices/estimates. sometimes silly issues can cause emissions to fail such as cars sitting for a long period or gaskets failing etc. as for rust it gets everything and can be massively costly but again get it looked at it may not all be doom and gloom.
if you get it all looked over and KNOW what needs doing and have a price for it you can make up your mind.
if you get it all looked over and KNOW what needs doing and have a price for it you can make up your mind.
wormus said:
If you like it, stick with and repair it. Cars are never an investment and it sounds like your suggested alternatives, by your own admission would not hit the spot. Loyalty is nothing to be ashamed of.
Yeh. I like the car, don't love it but do like it. My main concern is spending hundreds with a specialist to get it through an MOT, only to fast forward 1 year and it fails on the chassis legs. At this point it's curtains for the car. And I'm 2-3 years too soon (life wise) to build that kit car.

I have had this experience with my rallye, the main problem was of course rust and the potentially costly repairs.
Garages charge and quote a fortune for welding but I found a guy on gumtree who did welding and resto work for £25ph + materials - he was really good and was too busy to be mugging me off. Overall work that was quoted at 500-600 in garage rates came in at 300 with him, and the standard of work was excellent with regular text and picture updates.
If your car failed its emissions after the charger and not before, I would go back to the company that fitted it or get to a decent garage that know how to tune cars... mapping and tuning are different things (to me anyway)
is the cat still present? or does it not need one?
Garages charge and quote a fortune for welding but I found a guy on gumtree who did welding and resto work for £25ph + materials - he was really good and was too busy to be mugging me off. Overall work that was quoted at 500-600 in garage rates came in at 300 with him, and the standard of work was excellent with regular text and picture updates.
If your car failed its emissions after the charger and not before, I would go back to the company that fitted it or get to a decent garage that know how to tune cars... mapping and tuning are different things (to me anyway)
is the cat still present? or does it not need one?
Defcon5 said:
Has it been MOT'd before with the charger fitted?
Nope. Like I say though, fitted by a well regarded specialist and I assume (I know that's not always safe to) it was tuned to pass an mot! It's running very rich at the moment, a CO reading of 2.4, legal max is 0.3.... Whatever that means! 
Mr MXT said:
Build a Westfield Mx5 SDV, put your supercharged engine in, Q plate it, no worries about emissions. Job jobbed.
That's part of the long term plan in my life. I'm too busy with life in general to take on a build right now (3 year old, another in the planning and a very busy job) so it would never get done, I'd never be commited to it enough. eltax91 said:
That's part of the long term plan in my life. I'm too busy with life in general to take on a build right now (3 year old, another in the planning and a very busy job) so it would never get done, I'd never be commited to it enough.
In that case, get it mapped better. Was it 5speed?
Carl-H said:
Personally I'd sort the rust and find a friendly tester for the emissions...
A fair suggestion. But if the car is running this lean and I want to keep it, I need to sort the problem surely? Such a drastic failure leads me to believe it's running lean enough to cause future engine problems. I would find out if the cat is there and working, if so, get it re-mapped - this should also improve the drive, and get it re-tested.
Also contact the place that put the charger in, explain the issue, they might help out in some way - nothing ventured etc.
Look at the rust in due course, but I agree if the rust bites properly, it is tickets.
Also contact the place that put the charger in, explain the issue, they might help out in some way - nothing ventured etc.
Look at the rust in due course, but I agree if the rust bites properly, it is tickets.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


