economy 1.4 petrol vs 1.6 diesel
Discussion
You've looked at the £3000 car market and picked out two of the biggest bags of s
t available. Well done OP. Whichever one of those you buy is going to be rubbish and has a good chance of constant niggling repair bills that'll dwarf the fuel economy differences. That 1.6D seems to be particularly troublesome in the various french s
tboxes it's fitted to, although it doesn't give trouble in Volvos where a different oil is specified so it might be more down to the maintenance routine. Good luck finding a 10 year old French hatchback that's been serviced properly though.
t available. Well done OP. Whichever one of those you buy is going to be rubbish and has a good chance of constant niggling repair bills that'll dwarf the fuel economy differences. That 1.6D seems to be particularly troublesome in the various french s
tboxes it's fitted to, although it doesn't give trouble in Volvos where a different oil is specified so it might be more down to the maintenance routine. Good luck finding a 10 year old French hatchback that's been serviced properly though.Edited by dme123 on Sunday 5th April 08:01
[quote=dme123]You've looked at the £3000 car market and picked out two of the biggest bags of s
t available. Well done OP. Whichever one of those you buy is going to be rubbish and has a good chance of constant niggling repair bills that'll dwarf the fuel economy differences. That 1.6D seems to be particularly troublesome in the various french s
tboxes it's fitted to, although it doesn't give trouble in Volvos where a different oil is specified so it might be more down to the maintenance routine. Good luck finding a 10 year old French hatchback that's been serviced properly though.
i know french cars arnt very good i only want it to last me a couple of years at the most, im probs better going for a ford fiesta or something....so how do i relate miles that a petrol car has done to miles that a diesel has done? does anyone understand this last question ? lol
t available. Well done OP. Whichever one of those you buy is going to be rubbish and has a good chance of constant niggling repair bills that'll dwarf the fuel economy differences. That 1.6D seems to be particularly troublesome in the various french s
tboxes it's fitted to, although it doesn't give trouble in Volvos where a different oil is specified so it might be more down to the maintenance routine. Good luck finding a 10 year old French hatchback that's been serviced properly though.i know french cars arnt very good i only want it to last me a couple of years at the most, im probs better going for a ford fiesta or something....so how do i relate miles that a petrol car has done to miles that a diesel has done? does anyone understand this last question ? lol
davpat said:
peugeot 207 1.4 5 doors vs citroen c4 coupe 3 doors 1.6 diesel both year 2005
Of those two the 207 1.4 petrol as the 1.6HDI fitted by Peugeot / Citroen is a
of an engine that will invariably need a turbo / DPF on a regular basis.But why saddle yourself with such dull substandard cars?
....so how do i relate miles that a petrol car has done to miles that a diesel has done? does anyone understand this last question ? lol
[/quote]
Simple if the diesel has done 90k & the petrol has done 60k then it's likely that the petrol will be the better long term prospect in terms of overall running costs.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...
£180 R/tax 42.8mpg
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...
£30 R/Tax 64 mpg
you decide what suites you best
[/quote]
Simple if the diesel has done 90k & the petrol has done 60k then it's likely that the petrol will be the better long term prospect in terms of overall running costs.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...
£180 R/tax 42.8mpg
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...
£30 R/Tax 64 mpg
you decide what suites you best
Edited by ZX10R NIN on Sunday 5th April 10:34
Edited by ZX10R NIN on Sunday 5th April 10:35
BritishRacinGrin said:
davpat said:
thought a diesel engine lasted fo ever.
You're wrong. Go do your homework. Then buy a petrol, and not a 207 or C4. Budget?
(Remembers it's the school holidays...)
The thinking behind it was, that if both engines had done 100k, the diesel would have done fewer revolutions than the petrol, therefore less wear on the oily bits.
A well maintained NA petrol engine should easily last 200k without major issues.
What people often forget is that the rest of the car wears as well. Suspension, transmission, steering etc, none of which differ much (transmission may) if a petrol or diesel engine is fitted.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



