£10-15k Future Classic?
£10-15k Future Classic?
Author
Discussion

CRB14

Original Poster:

1,494 posts

183 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Looking at going halves with my dad on a little toy that we'll keep for the long haul. Ideally something that might go up if looked after. We've looked at 996s but they're a minefield it seems. I've suggested E36 / E46 M3s but he isn't sure as he's fixated on old stuff (Triumphs and such). Any suggestions to throw into the mix? The only key point is that it needs to be smallish due to garage size.

jdw1234

6,021 posts

246 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Mercedes SL either R107 or R129.

I think E36 M3 have now matured nicely as well.

robsco

7,875 posts

207 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Cerbera.

kambites

71,736 posts

252 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
How about a nice S1 Elise?

sunnym3

158 posts

263 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
How about a Renault Clio V6?

PositronicRay

29,116 posts

214 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
jdw1234 said:
Mercedes SL either R107 or R129.

I think E36 M3 have now matured nicely as well.
I'm not sure the R129 will make classic status anytime soon, far too many about.

TankRizzo

8,031 posts

224 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
VX220.

Denno B

1,001 posts

236 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]

Great car and very low numbers so why not?? Prices have been rising last few years smile

TR4man

5,554 posts

205 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Agree on the R129, prices have been rising quite rapidly over the last year.

How about a Jag XKR?

Or a Z3M roadster (another car that seems to be already on the up)?

Series 1 Elise?

Edited by TR4man on Monday 6th April 21:10

MOTK

347 posts

165 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Z4MC could be a good shout looking at the way the breadvan has gone. They made less of them too.
Should be able to get one around 15k.

Monkeylegend

29,595 posts

262 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Chimaera, find a good one before they go the way of the Griff.

Terzo123

4,764 posts

239 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Monaro VXR - The only way is up. 13k will net you a peach, whilst 10k will get you a rough diamond.

Clio V6

E46 M3, although i don't think they have bottomed out quite yet.

Z3M coupe if your lucky

Z4M

E39 M5

996

B5 RS4

Edited to add, sorry i missed the small garage bit



Edited by Terzo123 on Monday 6th April 21:25

jonah35

3,940 posts

188 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Old old stuff isn't going up as much as 1980s stuff or 1990s stuff

Who wants a triumph stag? Most wannabe owners are getting very old now

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Its got to be a 996 911.

I haven't seen a single other car posted in this thread that has the same sort of universal appeal or such a history of the model/brand having high residuals. Turbos have already seen a massive jump in value and air cooled models are out of control.

A 996 is the only way of getting in a 911 for sensible money - how long do you reckon that's going to last for?

chris333

1,034 posts

270 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
jonah35 said:
Old old stuff isn't going up as much as 1980s stuff or 1990s stuff

Who wants a triumph stag? Most wannabe owners are getting very old now
I was just thinking the same thing this afternoon after seeing an old guy in an MGB. All the people who have bought and kept 60s/70s MGs, Triumphs etc presumably lusted after them when they were new. To someone growing up on hot hatches, MX5s, Imprezas/Evos, there isn't much attraction there.

I wonder what will happen to them all?

007 VXR

64,187 posts

218 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
CRB14 said:
The only key point is that it needs to be smallish due to garage size.
This bit really limits your options frown

roystinho

3,767 posts

206 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
Would have said clio v6, but they're quite wide. I'd go Elise S1, money will be safe in one of those

CRB14

Original Poster:

1,494 posts

183 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
279 said:
Its got to be a 996 911.

I haven't seen a single other car posted in this thread that has the same sort of universal appeal or such a history of the model/brand having high residuals. Turbos have already seen a massive jump in value and air cooled models are out of control.

A 996 is the only way of getting in a 911 for sensible money - how long do you reckon that's going to last for?
I'd be inclined to agree and it's still the ideal for me - it's the potentially huge bills though that's of concern when compared to say a S1 Elise (which I've also been looking at).

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Monday 6th April 2015
quotequote all
CRB14 said:
Looking at going halves with my dad on a little toy that we'll keep for the long haul. Ideally something that might go up if looked after. We've looked at 996s but they're a minefield it seems. I've suggested E36 / E46 M3s but he isn't sure as he's fixated on old stuff (Triumphs and such). Any suggestions to throw into the mix? The only key point is that it needs to be smallish due to garage size.
z3m convertibles are still just about within budget, though most are already north of £20K.

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/search/used/cars/bmw/z...

Heres one at £37.5K with ultra low miles.

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...


daveofedinburgh

556 posts

150 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
279 said:
Its got to be a 996 911.

I haven't seen a single other car posted in this thread that has the same sort of universal appeal or such a history of the model/brand having high residuals. Turbos have already seen a massive jump in value and air cooled models are out of control.

A 996 is the only way of getting in a 911 for sensible money - how long do you reckon that's going to last for?
I've been banging on about the 996 911 for a while now, foolishly- as Im about a year away from being able to afford to put my money where my mouth is.

It's slap-bang in the middle of the £10-15K budget. Infact, if I get my sh*t together quick enough, I reckon I could get a good 'un for not much more than £10K. Pre-facelift 3.4 manual is probably the one to go for (with or without Amber lights though?).

Facelift currently looks smarter to my eye, but the 3.6 is apparently more prone to bore scoring (*waits to be corrected*). Facelift looks also split opinion somewhat, but these things change with time so who knows.

IMS scares everyone, but it increasingly looks like this has been overstated, apparently affecting only ~5% of cars (*again waits to be corrected*). ~5% will ofcourse represent quite a significant risk to people more sensible/ intelligent than me.

Quality issues are well-documented, Porsche wasn't in the great place it is now, so corners/ costs were cut, particularly around the interior. Speaking of interiors, there are some sketchy shades of leather out there...

'Ocean Jade' paint is very period-correct, but the car looks incredibly naff in this colour, and I don't see this improving with age.

Tiptronics are apparently quite good, but everyone will want a manual, particularly as the car becomes more 'classic'. Convertibles will be less desirable (duh) for obvious reasons, I rather like the Targas, but again Im sure the tintop will be the one to have.

RWD rather than 4WD I suspect- buyers will want 'purity' over all-weather usability/ security.

I'm always noncing 996s in the classifieds, and I find that they don't photograph well. They can look a bit 'jelly-mould' in pics, yet they are very well-proportioned and pleasantly compact in the metal. That unique 911 6-cylinder noise is often understated imho- few people seem to mention how good they sound when being wrung out.

The 996 isn't far away from becoming the 'new old 911' now. It'll be viewed as something of an old school, analogue car, as 911s and sports cars in general become increasingly more tech-laden.

In afew years many of us PHers will be sad that we were put off by IMS/ bore score/ build quality issues back when these were £10Kish. Will it go as hyper-inflation mental as the generations that preceded it? I personally don't think so as it has more flaws, and I'm sure Porsche made quite a lot of them. I maintain that they represent a good investment though, and will at the very least be slightly better than 'free motoring' for those who snap up good examples in the next few years.

Some other great mentions in this thread too- many TVRs are getting a bit rich already. A customer of mine has a Cerbera with the flat-plane crank AJP V8. It's a great thing, chassis is flake-free and he looks after it. Interior is very shonky though- it just looks like it's falling to bits to me. To be expected given how they were built I guess, as much as I love the swoopy, eccentric madness, this puts me off them.

Z3 breadvan would be right up there too. Not sure if a good one can be had sub £15K anymore, the ship seems to have pretty much sailed on these now. Z3s in general are vastly underrated, although only the breadvan is a future classic- the M Roadster will never be 'there' imho.

Big, manual, RWD 'barn-door' engineering stuff with V8s like the Monaro/ MG ZT increasingly represent a by-gone era, and both are still well within budget.

I can understand people questioning the VX220s mention (2 Vauxhalls in this list, WTF?!), but I think it's on the money due to small build numbers and good dynamics. S1 Elise is appreciating slower than I had expected...

S2000 owners are laughing right now- relatively small build numbers, hand-built engines etc. Good ones were sub £4K afew short years ago. How many people are gutted having sold theirs due to extortionate insurance premiums I wonder?

E46 M3 manual still looks tempting at this price point- the love for them seems to have dwindled recently though, wonder why?

Many of these cars may not be true 'future classics', but the 996/ Z3M coupe stand the best chance imho.