E46 M3 vs 996 911
Author
Discussion

MichalPH

Original Poster:

97 posts

155 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Which one would You/did You buy and why?

TIA for Your opinions

Michal

Crusoe

4,126 posts

262 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Depends on the price point but assume around £10k. If the M3 has had the boot floor fixed I'd go with that, less likely to give you a large bill if all the consumables are in good condition and plenty to choose from.

MattHall91

1,275 posts

155 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
I just don't get the 996 at all. I've driven a Turbo and even that didn't do anything for me. A 997 then we're talking, but obviously out of budget.

I'd opt for the M3 any day. Or possibly a Boxster, but probably not.

GetCarter

31,339 posts

310 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
I've owned both the E46 M3 (twice) and the 996 turbo S, and driven both on track. All from new.

What would you like to know?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
The golf shoes get carter, tell us about the fking Golf shoes man!!!!

Fastdruid

9,417 posts

183 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Out of those two the 911 every time (and I'm not a Porsche fan at all).

The 911 has been engineered to be a sports car first and foremost, the E46 M3 while undisputed a very quick car is at heart just a 3-series with all the design compromises (and of course failures) of the lowest common denominator of the 316/318 plus a whole load of additional expense on "one off" bits for the M's and while it's far from bad handling is not the best handling car in the world.



anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
FastdruId, did you give thought to the evolution of 911's prior to making that comment?

Speaking from as a guy who adores 993's by the way...

Fastdruid

9,417 posts

183 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
It's a beetle with the engine in the wrong place you mean and that Porsche absolutely refuse to ever admit they've made any kind of mistake and will make bad design work through sheer bloody mindedness and good engineering?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
I was attempting to highlight the fact that pork In their legacy form are really no different from BM and I do get tired of those who profess that M3's are not 'pure' enough to be race cars such as porches (2 syllables apparently) yet E46 M3 CSL's are regarded by many as a 996 Gt3 contender. It strikes me as pure snobbishness and if that's the case, give me a £5k E46 M3 any old day of the week!!!

Olivera

8,851 posts

270 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
E46 M3. There are very good reasons why if you go to the Nurburgring you'll see dozens of M3s of all generations, but hardly a single chocolate engined (non GT) 996 911.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Olivera said:
E46 M3. There are very good reasons why if you go to the Nurburgring you'll see dozens of M3s of all generations, but hardly a single chocolate engined (non GT) 996 911.
Never a truer word spoken....

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

265 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
996 all the way. Some would say it is a better driving car than a 993. And the E46 feels like the fast saloon that it is on the road. Poor steering, clunky gearchange etc. It feels like a heavy, lumbering old thing.

mr_tony

6,351 posts

300 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
I bought the e46 m3 as a daily driver to sit alongside some more exotic stuff and I'm really pleased with it.

I've driven the 996 many times - nearly bought a new one (went for a 3200gt instead at the time) - and its a nice car but the handling isn't as 'fun' as the m3. The m3 will drift all day and is pretty friendly. A good 996 c2 is probably quicker point to point, but not as much of a giggle at low speeds.

The m3 is also more usable as a DD with 5 seats and a decent boot. Interior quality is probably better unless it's a very highly specced 996. Engine noise is rather fabulous too vs the 911.

I'm actually selling a classic air cooled 911 and keeping the m3. It's far more usable day to day and I look forward to enjoying it on track without fretting about bending it like I do with the classic.

My only advice is get a manual - SMG is hateful (the 996 gt3 wouldn't be half as desirable with trip tronic would it? Why is the CSL?)

Also - get a bright colour. The m3 should stand out - blue, red, yellow.



hot66

700 posts

248 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
tiptronic is a slush box

smg is an automated manual box

not really a comparison

991 gt3 is now pdk and pretty desirable

Personally, I think the CSL suits the smg box ( & I'm far from being a flappy paddle kind of person)


hot66

700 posts

248 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
.... when I say the SMG suits the CSL, thats because the SMG is great when 'on it'

If it was a town car or similar then the smg is poor .


uwotm8

30 posts

161 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Hmmm...

E46 M3 for practicality, reliable engine.

996 for driving position, lightness, controls.

It's a close call but I say a 996 with sports exhaust if you're not too concerned about the M96 lump.

Worth bearing in mind at 10k, the 996 will be older.

mr_tony

6,351 posts

300 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
hot66 said:
.... when I say the SMG suits the CSL, thats because the SMG is great when 'on it'

If it was a town car or similar then the smg is poor .
As a pure track car the SMG can make a case for itself. However my various tests suggested that it very much sucks on the road. It's supposed to reduce the distraction of changing gear - but you end up trying to second guess what it's going to do.

I love the PDK in my other car - that's what a paddle shift was always supposed to be like. Instant, seamless, not requiring thought. The earlier versions of robotised manuals will in time be regarded as unfortunate mistakes I think.

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

265 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
mr_tony said:
hot66 said:
.... when I say the SMG suits the CSL, thats because the SMG is great when 'on it'

If it was a town car or similar then the smg is poor .
As a pure track car the SMG can make a case for itself. However my various tests suggested that it very much sucks on the road. It's supposed to reduce the distraction of changing gear - but you end up trying to second guess what it's going to do.

I love the PDK in my other car - that's what a paddle shift was always supposed to be like. Instant, seamless, not requiring thought. The earlier versions of robotised manuals will in time be regarded as unfortunate mistakes I think.
I agree - Most recent tests of the CSL do not rate the 'box. Was great technology 10 years ago and that's the problem with tech - we will be having the same debates in 2025 about how poor a 2015 PDK is.

mr_tony

6,351 posts

300 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
SidewaysSi said:
I agree - Most recent tests of the CSL do not rate the 'box. Was great technology 10 years ago and that's the problem with tech - we will be having the same debates in 2025 about how poor a 2015 PDK is.
Maybe, but I think it's more subtle. Paddle shift tech in road cars went through a fashion phase as being 'cool' high tech etc rathe than good. Like voice control, ABS , traction control or electronic diffs have. They start our poor but people buy them because of marketing, then get developed to fulfil the original potential and we stop thinking s out them as a 'thing' just as something that cars have that just work.,,

popeyewhite

23,087 posts

151 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
E46 M3 < 911 996