how many cars gone scrappage scheme!!
how many cars gone scrappage scheme!!
Author
Discussion

arfur daley

Original Poster:

834 posts

197 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Saw this today https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/car-scr...
which made me think of three things:
1. plenty of Astra s have gone!
2. Salesmen cannot spell very well.
3. did not know that the scrappage scheme got rid of soooooooooo many cars.rotate

Spare tyre

12,750 posts

161 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
That list is so bad,many duplications

Fun Bus

17,911 posts

249 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
Previously discussed several months ago ( http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=144...) and it brought up some interesting points.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Tuesday 7th April 2015
quotequote all
That'll be the scrappage scheme that ended over five years ago?

Spare tyre

12,750 posts

161 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
I liked the bit where number plates are used as the make

You'd assume someone would have normalised that data by reg / vin number to make it meaningful

droopsnoot

14,801 posts

273 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
When this information was first released, I emailed the department involved and asked if they could provide the data from the other side of the deal - that is, a list of makes and models that the scrappage cars were traded in against. I got no reply to that and my two subsequent emails, so I wrote to my MP and asked if he could find out. After a while he did, and it showed that the four manufacturers that benefited from the scheme were:

Hyundai - 43524 cars sold
Ford - 43091
Volkswagen - 31252
Kia - 29130

It annoyed me a little that the scheme, which I understood to be intended to give a boost to the motor industry, was never limited to either new cars that were made in the UK, or cars that were made by companies that have at least some kind of manufacturing presence in the UK.

On the other hand, 34 new Porsches were bought under the scheme.

RobinBanks

17,551 posts

210 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
droopsnoot said:
When this information was first released, I emailed the department involved and asked if they could provide the data from the other side of the deal - that is, a list of makes and models that the scrappage cars were traded in against. I got no reply to that and my two subsequent emails, so I wrote to my MP and asked if he could find out. After a while he did, and it showed that the four manufacturers that benefited from the scheme were:

Hyundai - 43524 cars sold
Ford - 43091
Volkswagen - 31252
Kia - 29130

It annoyed me a little that the scheme, which I understood to be intended to give a boost to the motor industry, was never limited to either new cars that were made in the UK, or cars that were made by companies that have at least some kind of manufacturing presence in the UK.

On the other hand, 34 new Porsches were bought under the scheme.
Do you not think that if we had limited it to manufacturers with UK production facilities the European Union might have blocked it?

I'm amazed that some people still don't understand the concept of free trade agreements and these subsidies and incentives being illegal.
A free trade agreement of the type that the EU has with South Korea, for instance notwithstanding that most of those Hyundais and Kias were probably built in the EU.

SuperHangOn

3,486 posts

184 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Well if that's the case why did they bothe?

Reducing the number of older cars on the road and the promotion of disposable motoring will have a knock on effect on many independent garages, factors, specialist suppliers etc who keep them running. And those jobs are obviously here, unlike a Hyundai factory.

Like everything, it must come down to who has the power to lobby the government into stupid decisions.

Edited by SuperHangOn on Wednesday 8th April 14:34

Dave Hedgehog

16,393 posts

235 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
SuperHangOn said:
Well if that's the case why did they bothe?

Reducing the number of older cars on the road and the promotion of disposable motoring will have a knock on effect on many independent garages, factors, specialist suppliers etc who keep them running. And those jobs are obviously here, unlike a Hyundai factory.

Like everything, it must come down to who has the power to lobby the government into stupid decisions.

Edited by SuperHangOn on Wednesday 8th April 14:34
after such a huge amount of time any artificial impact it had will have been ironed out by now, most of these cars are now budget bangers and over the next few years many will be scrapped

the motivation for this scheme was purely political to keep the stupid sheep happy

the bankers had just pissed all the money up the wall and the public where baying for blood, as the incumbent political self serving feckless tards do you:

1) bring stability to the banking industry, introduce new laws and regulations to ensure it never happens again, reclaim the money lost, prosecute those responsible

or do you

2) create some daft headline PR scheme to take stupid peoples focus off the issues whilst encouraging them to focus all their tiny brain power on one individual - fred the banker


guess what, they did no of 1) and all of 2) and the feckless majority lapped it up

RobinBanks

17,551 posts

210 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
SuperHangOn said:
Well if that's the case why did they bothe?

Reducing the number of older cars on the road and the promotion of disposable motoring will have a knock on effect on many independent garages, factors, specialist suppliers etc who keep them running. And those jobs are obviously here, unlike a Hyundai factory.

Like everything, it must come down to who has the power to lobby the government into stupid decisions.

Edited by SuperHangOn on Wednesday 8th April 14:34
1: It may have encouraged the sale of some cars that were built here.
2: Components for those cars may have been built here (see that Ford sold a lot due to the scheme).
3: Newer cars are on higher tax bands than most of those sold (benefits the government).
4: VAT on new cars (benefits the government).
5: Stimulating the UK finance industry.
6: Support dealer networks across the UK which were struggling due to the slump in car sales.


There are other reasons, but giving six of them seems enough for now. Is it now more obvious? wink
It wasn't necessarily for the benefit of UK manufacturers at all although it may have helped them very slightly. And don't think it was because Hyundai and Kia lobbied the government.

I think the reason that Volkswagen got in there is because they probably offered other good incentives on top of the scrappage deals and because Volkswagen has had a rapidly growing presence in the UK market for many years anyway.

ETA: I've just read that and it may have sounded condescending. It wasn't meant to be, but I can't be arsed to rewrite all that to make it sound friendlier.

Edited by RobinBanks on Wednesday 8th April 15:35

Jim AK

4,029 posts

155 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Some 492.000 vehicles,registered in March this year. Highest figure since 1999 apparently.

I did change a car during the scrappage malarkey although not in with the scheme I did what I considered to be a good deal at the time & am sure that scheme allowed me to do it because of the volumes dealers wanted for their Final Bonus.

FWIW I reckon the schemes probably saved jobs in the motor industry anyway in sales & admin departments as well as with the manufacturers. Although I do agree that some vehicles were scrapped just because that was the rule but I als don't think cars of the last decade are future classics anyway.

People love old Ford Cortinas, Escorts & Capri's but I don't think my children will be hankering after a 2008 plate Mondeo!

The scheme did what it did, made the then Labour Government 'look' proactive

31mph

1,308 posts

166 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Funny that this is being discussed today

This popped-up in my newsfeed earlier

https://www.facebook.com/RedlineMagazine/posts/101...






hidetheelephants

36,454 posts

224 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Hundreds of thousands of entirely serviceable automobiles scrapped in an orgy of mindless consumerism, benefiting a few car salesmen and the satsumas who run the PR department of the SMMT. Big whoop. All this from a government which claimed to be green while despoiling the countryside with whirligigs and building stty rabbit hutches on floodplains.

droopsnoot

14,801 posts

273 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
RobinBanks said:
Do you not think that if we had limited it to manufacturers with UK production facilities the European Union might have blocked it?

I'm amazed that some people still don't understand the concept of free trade agreements and these subsidies and incentives being illegal.
A free trade agreement of the type that the EU has with South Korea, for instance notwithstanding that most of those Hyundais and Kias were probably built in the EU.
I must admit it hadn't occurred to me. That said, I am also out of touch with just how many companies build cars in this country, I recall looking into it when I posted those numbers somewhere else but have forgotten the results since.

DonkeyApple

70,901 posts

200 months

Wednesday 8th April 2015
quotequote all
Dave Hedgehog said:
after such a huge amount of time any artificial impact it had will have been ironed out by now, most of these cars are now budget bangers and over the next few years many will be scrapped

the motivation for this scheme was purely political to keep the stupid sheep happy

the bankers had just pissed all the money up the wall and the public where baying for blood, as the incumbent political self serving feckless tards do you:

1) bring stability to the banking industry, introduce new laws and regulations to ensure it never happens again, reclaim the money lost, prosecute those responsible

or do you

2) create some daft headline PR scheme to take stupid peoples focus off the issues whilst encouraging them to focus all their tiny brain power on one individual - fred the banker


guess what, they did no of 1) and all of 2) and the feckless majority lapped it up
Yup. And milk the feckless for a chunk of VAT and other taxes while also getting them to take out more debt to keep the debt fuelled merrygoround alive.

It was one of the final farcical moves by the party that invented the farcical debt monkey voter benefit slave.

A few grannies will have used it to get a better car though.