Discussion
Hi there, I've posted this in the MX5 Forum but thought I would also put it here for a wider audience 
I'm looking to get a fun (but reliable), everyday car and have decided the MX5 is the way forward.
I owned a Mazda 6 for 10 years and never had any issues so am pretty with pleased with Mazda.
Anyway, I've seen a couple advertised and plan to view / test drive next week when I get back from overseas.
I'll put the links below and would welcome any advice / recommendations.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...
Q. Are there many differences between a 2003 and 2008 model?
Q. Would you consider the 2008 to be worth twice the price of the 2003?
Q. Would you buy either of these cars?
I'm really hoping to buy in the next couple as weeks as the top off weather should be coming and I miss having fun driving!
I am in the Great Yarmouth area if any of you know of any other MX5's for sale.
Thanks
Guy.
(apologies if all this has been asked before!)

I'm looking to get a fun (but reliable), everyday car and have decided the MX5 is the way forward.
I owned a Mazda 6 for 10 years and never had any issues so am pretty with pleased with Mazda.
Anyway, I've seen a couple advertised and plan to view / test drive next week when I get back from overseas.
I'll put the links below and would welcome any advice / recommendations.
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2015...
Q. Are there many differences between a 2003 and 2008 model?
Q. Would you consider the 2008 to be worth twice the price of the 2003?
Q. Would you buy either of these cars?
I'm really hoping to buy in the next couple as weeks as the top off weather should be coming and I miss having fun driving!
I am in the Great Yarmouth area if any of you know of any other MX5's for sale.
Thanks

Guy.
(apologies if all this has been asked before!)
Think those ads have expired?
But from the looks of things you're looking at a mk2.5 or a mk3. The Mk3 is more refined and offers a few more creature comforts than the mk2.
Rust kills many mx5's so check the sills on both sides for rot, mainly kills the mk1-mk2.5 cars so if your inclined to go for an earlier car check it out!
Other than that they're reliable, cheap to run and bloody good fun!
But from the looks of things you're looking at a mk2.5 or a mk3. The Mk3 is more refined and offers a few more creature comforts than the mk2.
Rust kills many mx5's so check the sills on both sides for rot, mainly kills the mk1-mk2.5 cars so if your inclined to go for an earlier car check it out!
Other than that they're reliable, cheap to run and bloody good fun!
Mine's a 2010, so a mk3 - I guess the 2008 car will be also.
It's been faultless, peanuts to run (I service it myself now, cos its out of warranty and easy-peasy).
The 2003 will be a mk2, i'm not a fan of the looks of the mk2 tbh but still an excellent drive. I've been out in a couple of the mk2 1.8 VT Sport's and they do go well, worth a look deffo.
Anyway, nice day today, i'm off to the gym, roof down of course, can't beat it.
It's been faultless, peanuts to run (I service it myself now, cos its out of warranty and easy-peasy).
The 2003 will be a mk2, i'm not a fan of the looks of the mk2 tbh but still an excellent drive. I've been out in a couple of the mk2 1.8 VT Sport's and they do go well, worth a look deffo.
Anyway, nice day today, i'm off to the gym, roof down of course, can't beat it.
I didn't enjoy the mk3 2.0, for want of a better phrase, it felt a lot more of a hairdresser car than it's predecessors to me.
Mk1 was my favourite and I think the most fun, but mk2.5 would be my pick of the bunch as it was nicer finished and still fairly new. Sills on mk1s certainly used to rust, a problem exacerbated by idiots who would then weld new plating over the drain holes. I don't recall the mk2 having the same problems but perhaps I was just lucky.
To be fair I don't think it's far to say they rust more than any other car beyond this though. That said anything but the mk3 is very old technology so very tried and tested. Never do anything earth shattering but won't let you down either.
I used to drive the mk2.5 a "Euphoric" edition (I think?) that was lovely looking, but the wheels were far to big and compromised the ride somewhat.
Mk1 was my favourite and I think the most fun, but mk2.5 would be my pick of the bunch as it was nicer finished and still fairly new. Sills on mk1s certainly used to rust, a problem exacerbated by idiots who would then weld new plating over the drain holes. I don't recall the mk2 having the same problems but perhaps I was just lucky.
To be fair I don't think it's far to say they rust more than any other car beyond this though. That said anything but the mk3 is very old technology so very tried and tested. Never do anything earth shattering but won't let you down either.
I used to drive the mk2.5 a "Euphoric" edition (I think?) that was lovely looking, but the wheels were far to big and compromised the ride somewhat.
I've had all 3 versions of the MX5, you won't go wrong if you buy on condition and not mileage.
The original is the best MX5, the newer ones are the best cars.
Rule 1: Make sure it's got a diff.
Rule 2: Make sure it's got a diff.
Rule 3: If it's tall and floaty (later cars) budget for decent springs.
PS get 6 gears if you do any motorway/dc cruising.
The original is the best MX5, the newer ones are the best cars.
Rule 1: Make sure it's got a diff.
Rule 2: Make sure it's got a diff.
Rule 3: If it's tall and floaty (later cars) budget for decent springs.
PS get 6 gears if you do any motorway/dc cruising.
Mr. Potato Head said:
PS get 6 gears if you do any motorway/dc cruising.
I'm not convinced it made any difference, I'm sure that I've read that the final drive was the same from 5 or 6 speed models, so you're still doing 3500rpm at 70mph.OP, if you're going for a Mk2/Mk2.5 make sure that it isn't a rusty s
tbox like mine was.The 1.8i Sport was definately the best of the Mk2.5s.
At the risk of being pedantic, all MX-5s have a differential. It is a Limited Slip Differential you want, and a Torsen in particular. The 1.8i Sport had the Torsen, 6 speed gearbox (cruising RPM basically similar, but the ratios were obviously closer together), heated seats, front fogs and front strut brace.
The Mk3 is more refined but the Mk2.5 is still an easy car to live with. Looks are subjective but I wasn't keen on the 3.
At the risk of being pedantic, all MX-5s have a differential. It is a Limited Slip Differential you want, and a Torsen in particular. The 1.8i Sport had the Torsen, 6 speed gearbox (cruising RPM basically similar, but the ratios were obviously closer together), heated seats, front fogs and front strut brace.
The Mk3 is more refined but the Mk2.5 is still an easy car to live with. Looks are subjective but I wasn't keen on the 3.
If it is a MK2.5 you're after make sure to check the front chassis rails from inside the engine bay and through the wheel arch. They rust pretty bad here and depending on how far gone they are can be expensive to get sorted. Other than that they're great cars! Only briefly driven a MK3 so can't really comment on them.
Thanks for all the comments so far!
As it's just for fun I'll probably head towards the 2003 model and try and get a deal as it's a private sale...and local!
I was originally looking at a 1976 MG BGT, and although I still very much like the car, I think the MX5 may be more reliable in general and on a longer run as I plan a whiz round the country later in the year.
As it's just for fun I'll probably head towards the 2003 model and try and get a deal as it's a private sale...and local!
I was originally looking at a 1976 MG BGT, and although I still very much like the car, I think the MX5 may be more reliable in general and on a longer run as I plan a whiz round the country later in the year.
Mk1s seem to be slightly better from a like-for-like rust point of view as they're pre water-based paints and as previously mentioned the mk2/mk2.5 cars have double-skinned front chassis rails which once rotten can prove terminal. Mk1s are of course older though, so you've got the extra number of British winters they've endured to contend with.
In a choice between a mk2 and mk3 I'd probably take a mk3 with the extra refinement and hopefully better build/bodywork quality.
In a choice between all of them I'd save a wedge and get a mk1 - indeed, I did.
In a choice between a mk2 and mk3 I'd probably take a mk3 with the extra refinement and hopefully better build/bodywork quality.
In a choice between all of them I'd save a wedge and get a mk1 - indeed, I did.

twocolours said:
If it is a MK2.5 you're after make sure to check the front chassis rails from inside the engine bay and through the wheel arch. They rust pretty bad here and depending on how far gone they are can be expensive to get sorted. Other than that they're great cars! Only briefly driven a MK3 so can't really comment on them.
This, checking the chassis rails is an absolute must (although it's a bit of a ball-ache because you need it up on a ramp/stands with the undertray off). Also check the sills, rear arches and inside boot lip for signs of rust or badly done repairs.The biggest killer of MK2/2.5's is rust and it's not cheap to fix if you do it properly.
luckystrike said:
Mk1s seem to be slightly better from a like-for-like rust point of view as they're pre water-based paints and as previously mentioned the mk2/mk2.5 cars have double-skinned front chassis rails which once rotten can prove terminal. Mk1s are of course older though, so you've got the extra number of British winters they've endured to contend with.
In a choice between a mk2 and mk3 I'd probably take a mk3 with the extra refinement and hopefully better build/bodywork quality.
In a choice between all of them I'd save a wedge and get a mk1 - indeed, I did.
This is good advice, the Mk2 is probably the worst ownership prospect of any MX5 - the rust problems are very expensive when compared to the value of the car. Having previously owned a Mk2 and Mk1 I'd echo luckstrikes's comments. Between a Mk2 and Mk3 I'd get a Mk3. But given any option I'd plump for a well sorted and cared for Mk1. In a choice between a mk2 and mk3 I'd probably take a mk3 with the extra refinement and hopefully better build/bodywork quality.
In a choice between all of them I'd save a wedge and get a mk1 - indeed, I did.

Just check for rust mk3 less so but early ones 2006 was the change to mk3 do have rust forming on some models. Mk2.5 check extremely carefully ask to remove the under cover to check chassis rails.
As for 6 speed box well the ratios is the same between 6 speed and 5 speed just with an extra gear in between the ratio of the diff will make a bigger effect. The 6 speed box are usually used with a 3.9 ratio or 3.6 ratio diff the 3.6 being the Fuji diff which is not the strongest diffs around.
Keep your eyes open off take/ask someone to go with you that knows these cars inside out.
As for 6 speed box well the ratios is the same between 6 speed and 5 speed just with an extra gear in between the ratio of the diff will make a bigger effect. The 6 speed box are usually used with a 3.9 ratio or 3.6 ratio diff the 3.6 being the Fuji diff which is not the strongest diffs around.
Keep your eyes open off take/ask someone to go with you that knows these cars inside out.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



