Private Education - parent appeal
Discussion
Came across this amongst the usual rubbish in the Daily Mail, as much as we all have to make sacrifices, to give our children the best, I can't say I support these parents:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3035244/Pa...
The real nail in the coffin was the crowd funding link, they say their child is gifted, yet the appeal is littered with spelling and grammatical errors....
http://www.gofundme.com/qrbd8w
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3035244/Pa...
The real nail in the coffin was the crowd funding link, they say their child is gifted, yet the appeal is littered with spelling and grammatical errors....
http://www.gofundme.com/qrbd8w
davepoth said:
It's Alfie (the younger brother) I feel sorry for here.
"Great news! We're selling the house for your brother, so he can go to a better school. You'll need to survive on hand-me-down clothes and gruel. By the way, we've sent you to the school that wasn't good enough for CJ."
I know, it sounds awful. "Great news! We're selling the house for your brother, so he can go to a better school. You'll need to survive on hand-me-down clothes and gruel. By the way, we've sent you to the school that wasn't good enough for CJ."
davepoth said:
It's Alfie (the younger brother) I feel sorry for here.
"Great news! We're selling the house for your brother, so he can go to a better school. You'll need to survive on hand-me-down clothes and gruel. By the way, we've sent you to the school that wasn't good enough for CJ."
except it says this:"Great news! We're selling the house for your brother, so he can go to a better school. You'll need to survive on hand-me-down clothes and gruel. By the way, we've sent you to the school that wasn't good enough for CJ."
"The Morgans have had to slash their weekly grocery bills by more than half to try and give CJ, and in future his brother Alfie, the private education they believe they deserve"
it might seem extreme - but the right school (whether state or private) can make a huge difference to a child, and I guess that is their over-riding concern...
in he last 20 years or so, the number of jobs requiring sheer intelligence and technical ability has dwindled.
what gets you on, in the main, at work is social skills, the ability to negotiate and influence. he'll have a chip on his shoulder and not a lot else.
I don't profess to be an expert but making your sure your kid stands out for all the wrong reasons is a recipe for disaster. this lad won't be successful because of this, but he may well fail because of this. he'll always be the poor kid at school.
what gets you on, in the main, at work is social skills, the ability to negotiate and influence. he'll have a chip on his shoulder and not a lot else.
I don't profess to be an expert but making your sure your kid stands out for all the wrong reasons is a recipe for disaster. this lad won't be successful because of this, but he may well fail because of this. he'll always be the poor kid at school.
Edited by dave123456 on Sunday 12th April 09:49
I wonder if both boys will look back and thank their parents?
I benefitted massively from getting a scholarship to a reasonable school, but the sacrifices both my mum and I had to make were huge - and still effect me at 32. Mum's sacrifices were financial, mine were experiences.
Wouldn't a tutor be both hugely cheaper and less disruptive?
I benefitted massively from getting a scholarship to a reasonable school, but the sacrifices both my mum and I had to make were huge - and still effect me at 32. Mum's sacrifices were financial, mine were experiences.
Wouldn't a tutor be both hugely cheaper and less disruptive?
Up to them really, I had a friend who has done similar in selling their house and downsizing to get their daughter into a local private school and now their son, however the daughter wasn't gifted, she hated the school and made a name for herself as a trouble maker.
The parents have also spent a small fortune on private tutors too; now I would have thought you woudn't need private tutors if the school was good enough, particularly as you are paying for the privilege of attending said school, anyway she is expected to come away with similar grades to my daughter; who is in the local state school and she is going on to do a BTEC at the local college; money well spent!!
Their son is a different matter; he is extremely intelligent but he is only in his second year at his private school and is thriving, but many of the sacrifices were originally for the daughter.
As for crowd funding; good luck to them but anyone donating money is an idiot.
The parents have also spent a small fortune on private tutors too; now I would have thought you woudn't need private tutors if the school was good enough, particularly as you are paying for the privilege of attending said school, anyway she is expected to come away with similar grades to my daughter; who is in the local state school and she is going on to do a BTEC at the local college; money well spent!!
Their son is a different matter; he is extremely intelligent but he is only in his second year at his private school and is thriving, but many of the sacrifices were originally for the daughter.
As for crowd funding; good luck to them but anyone donating money is an idiot.
OT
I can understand the appeal of a private school, if your local state schools are not great. In some cases, especially if you live out in the country, it's not just about moving to a better address or catchment area.
Kids come in states of Intellegence brom gifted to thick. By thick, I don't mean special needs, just not bright. It makes me laugh when patents of thick kids spend a fortune of their education.
There's a lad I used to know growing up. Lovely kid, but thick as two short planks. His folks sent him to a private school (the only one that let him in I guess). He failed all his O Levels. I see him now and then driving a ride on council mower and get a friendly wave. I can't help but think he'd have had as good an education and been happier in the local comp. As it is, he's found a role in life and good on him.
If you have two or more kids, one bright, the other thick, it must be a very tough call, but why waste your money on the one who won't benefit?
I don't disagree.
However, what you're suggesting is pretty much what happened to me - I won both a scholarship and received the 'assisted place' scheme, my two brothers didn't (both failed the entrance exams and AP had been scrapped).
Even without the assisted place, I know my mum would have done anything to pay for all three of us had they shown the aptitude to benefit, yet I have a very poor relationship with one of my brothers as he just can't see that the reason I have a good job and he's a barman isn't due to what school I went to...
However, what you're suggesting is pretty much what happened to me - I won both a scholarship and received the 'assisted place' scheme, my two brothers didn't (both failed the entrance exams and AP had been scrapped).
Even without the assisted place, I know my mum would have done anything to pay for all three of us had they shown the aptitude to benefit, yet I have a very poor relationship with one of my brothers as he just can't see that the reason I have a good job and he's a barman isn't due to what school I went to...
I can understand their concerns. We have just spent a few months looking at the local state pre-schools and decided to send our son to an independent school.
While our son is bright compared to a lot of kids his age, we are not kidding ourselves that he is 'gifted'.We just want to give him the best chance in life, and feel that the state system will hold him back whereas the independent school will give him the chance to flourish.
We had hoped to send him to the local state pre-school, but comments such as "We only offer extra education if they ask for it", "We don't encourage counting beyond ten" didn't fill us with confidence!
While our son is bright compared to a lot of kids his age, we are not kidding ourselves that he is 'gifted'.We just want to give him the best chance in life, and feel that the state system will hold him back whereas the independent school will give him the chance to flourish.
We had hoped to send him to the local state pre-school, but comments such as "We only offer extra education if they ask for it", "We don't encourage counting beyond ten" didn't fill us with confidence!
Bizarre. Personally never seen the point in private education, everything beneath degree level is mostly worthless as far as 'qualifications' go, and plenty of people got into Oxbridge coming from my scabby state school, and have gone on to decent careers. I'd also be surprised if the curriculum was much more challenging in a private school, certainly none of my privately educated peers dazzle me with their intelligence.
I'd be tempted to say at least he'd at least be able to make good contacts and have a decent network but as has been said, everyone will know how he got there now and probably be ostracised for 'being poor'.
I'd be tempted to say at least he'd at least be able to make good contacts and have a decent network but as has been said, everyone will know how he got there now and probably be ostracised for 'being poor'.
Gassing Station | The Lounge | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



