Rev matching/downshift question
Rev matching/downshift question
Author
Discussion

Kp5991

Original Poster:

4 posts

139 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
I'm really new this all so this is probably a dumb question. The way I was taught to downshift was to basically push the clutch all the way in, go down a gear with the clutch is still in. Start braking until I'm at my desired speed with the clutch still in and once I'm at that speed to bring the clutch out. I was going to start rev matching pretty soon, but I am missing something. Say i wanted to downshift, I would brake while still in my current gear, and then push the clutch in and 'blip' the throttle as I'm downshifting to the required number of revs and then finally release the clutch.


My first question is:
Because in my initial method, when I push the clutch down and brake as I shift, i'm decreasing the speed of the car as the engine speed also decreases, is this having the same effect as rev matching?
My second question is:
Why is rev matching better than the method I'm using?

I apologise for this being an amateur question, it's just I couldn't find an answer elsewhere.

kambites

71,734 posts

252 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
The idea of rev matching is that the two sides of the clutch are spinning at the same speed when the clutch is reengaged, this means you get no sudden surge of engine braking as you bring the clutch back up to destabilise the car. It's also kinder to the clutch, although modern clutches seem to usually outlast the cars they're fitted to so that's a bit of a moot point.

The technique you describe as how you do it now will mean you're using the clutch to drag the engine up from idle RPM to whatever engine speed you'll be at in the new gear. It would only truly have the same effect as rev matching if your new gear will put the engine at idle RPM when you engage it, which would be a very odd way to drive. I'm surprised you've been taught to do your braking with the clutch down, I wonder what the rationale behind that is.

As for why it's better, in normal circumstances on the public road, it's not really. It'll probably make your driving slightly smoother.

Edited by kambites on Sunday 12th April 18:52

R_U_LOCAL

2,708 posts

239 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
You're pressing the clutch far too soon.

Brake down to your desired speed with the clutch out, then, when you've finished braking (or you've almost finished braking), change down to the most appropriate gear. Match the engine revs to the road speed in your chosen gear by gently raising the revs rather than blipping the throttle.

A whole post on gearchanging here:

Zen and the art of changing gear

Loads more similar info is available - click my username!

Kp5991

Original Poster:

4 posts

139 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
Thanks guys, got the answer I was looking for straight away!

Kp5991

Original Poster:

4 posts

139 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
R_U_LOCAL said:
You're pressing the clutch far too soon.

Brake down to your desired speed with the clutch out, then, when you've finished braking (or you've almost finished braking), change down to the most appropriate gear. Match the engine revs to the road speed in your chosen gear by gently raising the revs rather than blipping the throttle.

A whole post on gearchanging here:

Zen and the art of changing gear

Loads more similar info is available - click my username!
Thanks!

Kp5991

Original Poster:

4 posts

139 months

Sunday 12th April 2015
quotequote all
kambites said:
The idea of rev matching is that the two sides of the clutch are spinning at the same speed when the clutch is reengaged, this means you get no sudden surge of engine braking as you bring the clutch back up to destabilise the car. It's also kinder to the clutch, although modern clutches seem to usually outlast the cars they're fitted to so that's a bit of a moot point.

The technique you describe as how you do it now will mean you're using the clutch to drag the engine up from idle RPM to whatever engine speed you'll be at in the new gear. It would only truly have the same effect as rev matching if your new gear will put the engine at idle RPM when you engage it, which would be a very odd way to drive. I'm surprised you've been taught to do your braking with the clutch down, I wonder what the rationale behind that is.

As for why it's better, in normal circumstances on the public road, it's not really. It'll probably make your driving slightly smoother.

Edited by kambites on Sunday 12th April 18:52
Thanks!!