Strange starting issue. Ideas?
Discussion
Had to take Lady Ace's Sharan to work today as the jag didn't start. Would be grateful for any diagnostic assistance to try and limit the thing happening again.
It's happened a few times, and chiefly occurs when the car has lain without starting for a couple of weeks. This morning however, it was the first time I'd tried to start it after I moved it at the weekend and drove it 20m. The engine was on for about 1 minute. It's my daily driver so months can go past without it happening but this morning was a PITA.
The engine cranks over, and over, but does not catch.
After a while, it sounds like one cylinder is firing, and continued cranking results in the coughing, almost catching noise gettign greater, as if another cylinder is receiving spark and fuel and starting to catch. Usually at this point, I've been cranking so long the battery starts to go flat.
Recharge battery and start again, gradually, after further cranking (and cranking, and cranking), enough cylinders fire for the engibe to fire and I will then keep it at 2k revs for a bit until it settles, or go for a drive. Once the engine is warm, it runs beautifully and the problem is then solved until I either leave the car for a couple of weeks or I start it and turn off straight away.
I live on a cul de sac so it's annoying for the neighbours to keep turning the thing over and over.
Fuel is getting to the cylinders as you can smell the unburnt fuel from the exhaust. Sparking does happen as it catches eventually and once it's going, is perfectly reliable and smooth.
Could it be a compression issue? Starting then stopping the engine could cause unburnt fuel to wash the cylinder bores, and I'm wondering if leaving the car for a couple of weeks could also cause oil to drain from the piston rings. As the engine cranks over and oil circulates, oil would then get wheree it is supposed to, compression is reinstored and the engine fires? It's about the only other thing I can think of.
Car is a 96 Jag x330, with the 3.2l AJ16 engine. Total mileage @186k. I do c. 15k comfy miles p.a. with no issues apart from this.
It's happened a few times, and chiefly occurs when the car has lain without starting for a couple of weeks. This morning however, it was the first time I'd tried to start it after I moved it at the weekend and drove it 20m. The engine was on for about 1 minute. It's my daily driver so months can go past without it happening but this morning was a PITA.
The engine cranks over, and over, but does not catch.
After a while, it sounds like one cylinder is firing, and continued cranking results in the coughing, almost catching noise gettign greater, as if another cylinder is receiving spark and fuel and starting to catch. Usually at this point, I've been cranking so long the battery starts to go flat.
Recharge battery and start again, gradually, after further cranking (and cranking, and cranking), enough cylinders fire for the engibe to fire and I will then keep it at 2k revs for a bit until it settles, or go for a drive. Once the engine is warm, it runs beautifully and the problem is then solved until I either leave the car for a couple of weeks or I start it and turn off straight away.
I live on a cul de sac so it's annoying for the neighbours to keep turning the thing over and over.
Fuel is getting to the cylinders as you can smell the unburnt fuel from the exhaust. Sparking does happen as it catches eventually and once it's going, is perfectly reliable and smooth.
Could it be a compression issue? Starting then stopping the engine could cause unburnt fuel to wash the cylinder bores, and I'm wondering if leaving the car for a couple of weeks could also cause oil to drain from the piston rings. As the engine cranks over and oil circulates, oil would then get wheree it is supposed to, compression is reinstored and the engine fires? It's about the only other thing I can think of.
Car is a 96 Jag x330, with the 3.2l AJ16 engine. Total mileage @186k. I do c. 15k comfy miles p.a. with no issues apart from this.
Edited by 8Ace on Monday 13th April 12:10
Probably just flooded. Although might also be related to the mileage.
Cars don't like being started, driven for a really short period and turned off. They have a tendency of flooding as they run mega rich when cold started and if you shut down in that period they have too much fuel sitting around still.
While things like the RX-8 were know to be really bad that was more they were a bit more sensitive, we didn't have a single issue with the RX-8 (probably because we knew it *could* be an issue) while I've had issues with "normal" cars where they don't want to start again. Best to run it for a bit longer before shutting off (normally until the coolant reaches at least 25degrees C) or just give it some revs for 10s and then turn it off.
Alternatively attempting to start with *full* throttle will probably (see the manual) stick the car into no-fueling mode and clear the flooding.
Cars don't like being started, driven for a really short period and turned off. They have a tendency of flooding as they run mega rich when cold started and if you shut down in that period they have too much fuel sitting around still.
While things like the RX-8 were know to be really bad that was more they were a bit more sensitive, we didn't have a single issue with the RX-8 (probably because we knew it *could* be an issue) while I've had issues with "normal" cars where they don't want to start again. Best to run it for a bit longer before shutting off (normally until the coolant reaches at least 25degrees C) or just give it some revs for 10s and then turn it off.
Alternatively attempting to start with *full* throttle will probably (see the manual) stick the car into no-fueling mode and clear the flooding.
8Ace said:
or I start it and turn off straight away.
Don't do that.What FastDruid said regarding full throttle, alternatively pulling the fuel injection fuse and cranking for 30 seconds or so then putting it back in will do it (check the actual details, the very nice RAC man fixed mine for me) - obviously it will need a very healthy battery (or jump leads to a running car) and two people.
Agree with flooding, but it's not a rotary, I'd expect it to run fine after a brief period of running.
First thought would be coolant temp sensor (ECU one, not dash gauge) as a duff one can cause all sorts of issues on a comms engine depending on what resistance it fails to.
After that then possibly compression check.
First thought would be coolant temp sensor (ECU one, not dash gauge) as a duff one can cause all sorts of issues on a comms engine depending on what resistance it fails to.
After that then possibly compression check.
8Ace said:
Thanks. I had thought that, but why would it happen when the car has lain unused for a while - it's the same symptoms.
Getting the think to crank and start definitely is easier with the throttle depressed so it could well be along those lines...
Valve stem seals? Not sure how it all lines up inside a Jag but I had a car years ago were the seals were weak & it'd oil up the plugs if left long enough.Getting the think to crank and start definitely is easier with the throttle depressed so it could well be along those lines...
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


