Insurance advice after repair.
Insurance advice after repair.
Author
Discussion

The Turbonator

Original Poster:

2,792 posts

182 months

Monday 13th April 2015
quotequote all
Back in December 2014 I had a non-fault accident which cost the insurance company £5500 to repair my car.

The whole front end and nearside had to be replaced, the ABS pump was damaged and had to be replaced and the whole nearside suspension had to be replaced.

Had the car back about a month now and all has been well, until the other day when the windscreen cracked whilst I was washing it.

I couldn't figure out where the crack had come from, there are no stone chips, I'm always avoiding bumps and slowing down for speed bumps and the car has only covered 36,000 miles. The windscreen has never received a knock of any kind.

If you follow the crack it goes right down to the bottom nearside corner of the screen to the black surround (the nearside is where the accident was). The cracks at this point are tiny though, there are literally two hair like cracks that are so small and so insignificant, that you wouldn't know were there unless you were looking for them.

My thinking is that these 2 tiny cracks were caused by the accident and the insurance company has just failed to notice them when they assessed the damage. Then when I've been driving, the cracks have grown until the point it has cracked like it has now.

I rang my insurance up and they sent a man from the garage who repaired the car to take some pictures, so that the assessor could have a look. The man who came agreed that it was probably caused by the accident. Well I've just received a call today saying that they're not going to repair it as they don't think it's related.








[url]
|http://thumbsnap.com/4NWHfQRp[/url]



So what are peoples thoughts on this? Is it unrelated and something else has caused it and I should just bite the bullet.

Or should I pursue it further with the insurance company?

If the latter, how should I go about doing it?

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 13th April 2015
quotequote all
Maybe try 'talking to a supervisor' but if you don't get anywhere after escalating the issue, thoughts are pay the pittance of a windscreen excess and get on with your life.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Monday 13th April 2015
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Maybe try 'talking to a supervisor' but if you don't get anywhere after escalating the issue, thoughts are pay the pittance of a windscreen excess and get on with your life.
Agree here - if you really wanted you could get an independent engineer to assess the damage pattern, pay their fees and try to force the insureco to replace the screen... Or pay your small excess and get on with life - at the end of the day it's small change for the inevitably huge headache that it's going to cause.

The Turbonator

Original Poster:

2,792 posts

182 months

Monday 13th April 2015
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Long story short but the Mrs kind of flirted with the assessor to avoid it being written off. It might only be a Citroën but it's a well loved and looked after car, so we did everything we could to avoid it being written off.

Sheepshanks

41,396 posts

150 months

Monday 13th April 2015
quotequote all
The Turbonator said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Long story short but the Mrs kind of flirted with the assessor to avoid it being written off. It might only be a Citroën but it's a well loved and looked after car, so we did everything we could to avoid it being written off.
Did you have a like-for-like hire car while it was being repaired?

Re the screen, you'd think that if it was damaged in the accident then with all the mucking around while it was being repaired it would have cracked then. Irritating that it's gone now, but they do just randomly break.

The Turbonator

Original Poster:

2,792 posts

182 months

Monday 13th April 2015
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
The Turbonator said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Long story short but the Mrs kind of flirted with the assessor to avoid it being written off. It might only be a Citroën but it's a well loved and looked after car, so we did everything we could to avoid it being written off.
Did you have a like-for-like hire car while it was being repaired?

Re the screen, you'd think that if it was damaged in the accident then with all the mucking around while it was being repaired it would have cracked then. Irritating that it's gone now, but they do just randomly break.
No they offered me one but I made do with a little stty C1.

Boydie88

3,283 posts

180 months

Monday 13th April 2015
quotequote all
Not much to add but a bit of sympathy. Remember reading the original post and them claiming you were at fault iirc?

How did it finish? Assuming it was their insurance that paid the £5500?

The Turbonator

Original Poster:

2,792 posts

182 months

Monday 13th April 2015
quotequote all
Boydie88 said:
Not much to add but a bit of sympathy. Remember reading the original post and them claiming you were at fault iirc?

How did it finish? Assuming it was their insurance that paid the £5500?
Yeah their insurance admitted liability in the end, the worry over liability was why I only accepted the C1, which is included in my policy.