P38 Rangey - how ruinous is ruinous?
Discussion
Hello all - seeking some advice on the above.
GF and I are moving to the country this summer and I'd like to get her mobile. She passed her test years back but has not driven much since. She likes Land Rovers and used to own a Series III, so with a budget set at around £3k I was planning to get her a Disco of some flavour... except that I've noted that I could get her a waft-tastic Rangey for the same (if not less!) money.
Now, I do recall that these things have a bit of a reputation for big bills, but what's the reality like?
Ta muchly in advance.
GF and I are moving to the country this summer and I'd like to get her mobile. She passed her test years back but has not driven much since. She likes Land Rovers and used to own a Series III, so with a budget set at around £3k I was planning to get her a Disco of some flavour... except that I've noted that I could get her a waft-tastic Rangey for the same (if not less!) money.
Now, I do recall that these things have a bit of a reputation for big bills, but what's the reality like?
Ta muchly in advance.
They are lovely when they work but as you've read they are a bit of a "last hurrah" for truly badly developed and engineered British cars. A colleague longed to own one for years, and when he got one it wasn't really a single big bill that made the eyes water as it was a continual and never ending series of small(ish) bills and niggles so £300 here, £250 there, another £500 a few months later. Back then it was quite new and expensive so he tended to fix the problems, but I guess if you ran it as a banger and only fixed the faults that stopped it going with a bit of luck it might not be that bad at all.
They're very cheap now, so the risk isn't so great now. Be wary of people who say there are no real problems and lots of cheap fixes because what they actually seem to mean is that the fixes are now cheaper than going to a main dealer and getting half the car replaced. Even buying all the bits of the air suspension himself and doing the work it still racked up a few hundred quid. I think in the end the expansion tank split and the water managed to pour down the loom into the ECU and it was never right again. More piss poor design. I think he threw in the towel and punted it on at 7 years old and lost a fortune on it.
I've had the use of one a couple of times over the year and it's absolutely miles nicer to drive than a Disco, but the amount of "go" on offer from that old grandma of an engine is distressingly little for the fuel consumed
I'd be inclined to go on the neckbeard LR forums and buy one someone has spent a fortune on. It's one of those cars where you can have a £2k P38, spend £5k on it over a year or two and be left with a £1800 P38. Take advantage of that
They're very cheap now, so the risk isn't so great now. Be wary of people who say there are no real problems and lots of cheap fixes because what they actually seem to mean is that the fixes are now cheaper than going to a main dealer and getting half the car replaced. Even buying all the bits of the air suspension himself and doing the work it still racked up a few hundred quid. I think in the end the expansion tank split and the water managed to pour down the loom into the ECU and it was never right again. More piss poor design. I think he threw in the towel and punted it on at 7 years old and lost a fortune on it.
I've had the use of one a couple of times over the year and it's absolutely miles nicer to drive than a Disco, but the amount of "go" on offer from that old grandma of an engine is distressingly little for the fuel consumed

I'd be inclined to go on the neckbeard LR forums and buy one someone has spent a fortune on. It's one of those cars where you can have a £2k P38, spend £5k on it over a year or two and be left with a £1800 P38. Take advantage of that

Edited by dme123 on Monday 13th April 17:42
TTwiggy said:
Hello all - seeking some advice on the above.
GF and I are moving to the country this summer and I'd like to get her mobile.
Jesus fGF and I are moving to the country this summer and I'd like to get her mobile.
king Christ, you don't need a f
king Range Rover if you move into the countryside. My dad used to have a herd of cows and he had a 2wd Skoda Pickup. I have been brought up on a farm and have worked on farms for 25 year and don't have a f
king 4x4. I worked in the USA on a custom harvest crew. Sometimes we were 35 miles down dirt roads and we didn't have 4wd pickups. Just by a car, any car you like, if you want a RR, get one, but don't tell me you need one just because you live near a field.
Willy Nilly said:
Jesus f
king Christ, you don't need a f
king Range Rover if you move into the countryside. My dad used to have a herd of cows and he had a 2wd Skoda Pickup. I have been brought up on a farm and have worked on farms for 25 year and don't have a f
king 4x4. I worked in the USA on a custom harvest crew. Sometimes we were 35 miles down dirt roads and we didn't have 4wd pickups.
Just by a car, any car you like, if you want a RR, get one, but don't tell me you need one just because you live near a field.
king Christ, you don't need a f
king Range Rover if you move into the countryside. My dad used to have a herd of cows and he had a 2wd Skoda Pickup. I have been brought up on a farm and have worked on farms for 25 year and don't have a f
king 4x4. I worked in the USA on a custom harvest crew. Sometimes we were 35 miles down dirt roads and we didn't have 4wd pickups. Just by a car, any car you like, if you want a RR, get one, but don't tell me you need one just because you live near a field.

Willy Nilly said:
Jesus f
king Christ, you don't need a f
king Range Rover if you move into the countryside. My dad used to have a herd of cows and he had a 2wd Skoda Pickup. I have been brought up on a farm and have worked on farms for 25 year and don't have a f
king 4x4. I worked in the USA on a custom harvest crew. Sometimes we were 35 miles down dirt roads and we didn't have 4wd pickups.
Just by a car, any car you like, if you want a RR, get one, but don't tell me you need one just because you live near a field.
I believe what he actually told you was that "she likes Land Rovers", but do carry on
king Christ, you don't need a f
king Range Rover if you move into the countryside. My dad used to have a herd of cows and he had a 2wd Skoda Pickup. I have been brought up on a farm and have worked on farms for 25 year and don't have a f
king 4x4. I worked in the USA on a custom harvest crew. Sometimes we were 35 miles down dirt roads and we didn't have 4wd pickups. Just by a car, any car you like, if you want a RR, get one, but don't tell me you need one just because you live near a field.

I bought my 2001 ,114k 4 litre county v8 11 months ago . It was 1 local doctor owner fsh all main dealer with printout totalling £23000 just for service and maintenance and bill of sale for £44000, new mot and a years tax. Never been painted or damaged and in lovely condition.Purchase price just £2600 (tax was 300 of that). The car has been epic and is lovely.It has not cost me a penny to date. Dont be frightened by the horror stories just buy a good one..be fussy ..these things are incredible value for money. You cant get more car for your money.
tomsugden said:
I owned a 4.0 SE P38, and it was fairly relentless with the bills it threw at me. If I was doing it again, I'd choose one without LPG, and that someone has already removed the air suspension from, and converted to springs.
The air suspension is far more reliable than its given credit for and not as complex nowadays ...its generally bad or wrong diagnosis or repairs that cause the issues....a range rover running on springs is to be avoided...the cost of springs outweighs a proper repair and renders the car as tat imo. Besides the insurance and other implications.I bought one last October, a 4.0 V8 SE , 97 vintage.
It's got heated leather, dual zone climate, 4 electric windows, cruise control, 18 alloys with nearly new GG AT2's.
It came with 11 months MOT.
Problems so far have been water ingress from screen (fixed by duct tape until I get time to remove trims an re-seal. The battery drained down, due to the RF receiver picking up spurious wifi signals (this has been fixed by cutting the orange signal wire from the RF box to the BECM and fitting a remote RF relay(£4 from ebay).
I've also fitted a solar panel to keep the battery topped up (it's a 5th car and doesn't get much use).
It was brilliant over winter, and is a great place to be.
Just finished cleaning (wash, dry, clay, wash, dry, polish, wax) it, and it looks a lot of car for the money.
Get over to Landyzone, brilliant, if sometimes blunt advice on that forum.
It's got heated leather, dual zone climate, 4 electric windows, cruise control, 18 alloys with nearly new GG AT2's.
It came with 11 months MOT.
Problems so far have been water ingress from screen (fixed by duct tape until I get time to remove trims an re-seal. The battery drained down, due to the RF receiver picking up spurious wifi signals (this has been fixed by cutting the orange signal wire from the RF box to the BECM and fitting a remote RF relay(£4 from ebay).
I've also fitted a solar panel to keep the battery topped up (it's a 5th car and doesn't get much use).
It was brilliant over winter, and is a great place to be.
Just finished cleaning (wash, dry, clay, wash, dry, polish, wax) it, and it looks a lot of car for the money.
Get over to Landyzone, brilliant, if sometimes blunt advice on that forum.
Everything you have ever heard about the P38 is . . . . . . . . . . true! Only acquire one if you a) have very deep pockets; or b) are handy wielding spanners and a soldering iron and have plenty of spare time!
Having said that I have owned my 2001 4.6 V8 Vogue for 11 years now and wouldn't be without it. Parts are readily available and not that expensive and it has kept my spannering techniques sharp - it has been a labour of love keeping it in top nick but it usually needs something or other sorting out. Just replaced the rear screen washer pump yesterday - £10 for the pump but takes a bit (lot) of know how to fit!
Having said that I have owned my 2001 4.6 V8 Vogue for 11 years now and wouldn't be without it. Parts are readily available and not that expensive and it has kept my spannering techniques sharp - it has been a labour of love keeping it in top nick but it usually needs something or other sorting out. Just replaced the rear screen washer pump yesterday - £10 for the pump but takes a bit (lot) of know how to fit!
Garvin said:
Everything you have ever heard about the P38 is . . . . . . . . . . true! Only acquire one if you a) have very deep pockets; or b) are handy wielding spanners and a soldering iron and have plenty of spare time!
Having said that I have owned my 2001 4.6 V8 Vogue for 11 years now and wouldn't be without it. Parts are readily available and not that expensive and it has kept my spannering techniques sharp - it has been a labour of love keeping it in top nick but it usually needs something or other sorting out. Just replaced the rear screen washer pump yesterday - £10 for the pump but takes a bit (lot) of know how to fit!
I used to have one and never had any serious problems but I fixed the common faults on it. Best advice I read from a poster on the Landyzone forum is to think of them as a hobby first and car second. Having said that I have owned my 2001 4.6 V8 Vogue for 11 years now and wouldn't be without it. Parts are readily available and not that expensive and it has kept my spannering techniques sharp - it has been a labour of love keeping it in top nick but it usually needs something or other sorting out. Just replaced the rear screen washer pump yesterday - £10 for the pump but takes a bit (lot) of know how to fit!

May I suggest you take a look at a classic Range Rover?
Bought mine about 6 months ago now and it has been truly brilliant. Used it all winter with no issues and will use it sporadically during the summer.
It uses no oil, barely any water and a decent bit of petrol. It's also the first car I've had that everyone has loved straight away.
My girlfriend is 27, recently passed her test and would be driving it everyday if insurance allowed.
Plus, values are on the up too. What's not to like?
Bought mine about 6 months ago now and it has been truly brilliant. Used it all winter with no issues and will use it sporadically during the summer.
It uses no oil, barely any water and a decent bit of petrol. It's also the first car I've had that everyone has loved straight away.
My girlfriend is 27, recently passed her test and would be driving it everyday if insurance allowed.
Plus, values are on the up too. What's not to like?

J4CKO said:
P38, why did they name it after body filler ?
From memory it got the project name from room P38 - a room in the Land-Rover factory where it was designed.I've always liked these. A mate had one for a few years towing horse boxes and for in the snow. It did throw up a few problems during his time with it. He had a good cheap specialist who looked after it.
I'd go for it, but I've owned 5 MGs so I'm attracted to trouble. :-)
How about an older Classic? Better looking but probably more expensive these days.
My choice would be a low spec small wheeled old L322. They are still a bit pricey though.
+1 for 'labour of love'
+1 for 'hobby first, car second'
Set out afew years ago to find a decent P38 diesel. Joined a couple of OCs. The consensus even there was that you really must be able/ willing to wield spanners often. There are a handful of very lucky owners who get examples that could be considered reliable. I'm useless with spanners, so wisely avoided.
Air suspension needs to be done, check for a receipt. Don't bother with coil spring converted cars, defeats the purpose. Some owners even consider the constantly high CoG of the coil springs to be a bit dangerous. Electrics suck, 2000> cars got Bosch components, and are less borky. Things like heated seats rarely seem to work. Tailgates are all rusty by this point. Brown velour interiors are so naff that they're cool now, but obvz you want leather. Batteries discharge, there are ways around it. Cooling circuit needs watching, V8 blocks crack when overheated. Diesel tempted me, but everyone on an RR OC will tell you they're ridiculously slow.
I totally get the temptation given current prices, but having done even limited research have accepted its not a car for me. Many 4x4s for a little more money that will be infinitely 'better', I'd be after a Land Cruiser or a Mitsubishi something.
+1 for 'hobby first, car second'
Set out afew years ago to find a decent P38 diesel. Joined a couple of OCs. The consensus even there was that you really must be able/ willing to wield spanners often. There are a handful of very lucky owners who get examples that could be considered reliable. I'm useless with spanners, so wisely avoided.
Air suspension needs to be done, check for a receipt. Don't bother with coil spring converted cars, defeats the purpose. Some owners even consider the constantly high CoG of the coil springs to be a bit dangerous. Electrics suck, 2000> cars got Bosch components, and are less borky. Things like heated seats rarely seem to work. Tailgates are all rusty by this point. Brown velour interiors are so naff that they're cool now, but obvz you want leather. Batteries discharge, there are ways around it. Cooling circuit needs watching, V8 blocks crack when overheated. Diesel tempted me, but everyone on an RR OC will tell you they're ridiculously slow.
I totally get the temptation given current prices, but having done even limited research have accepted its not a car for me. Many 4x4s for a little more money that will be infinitely 'better', I'd be after a Land Cruiser or a Mitsubishi something.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



