Insurance co wants to write off car but you don't.....
Discussion
To cut a long story short, a JCB digger bucket fell off a truck and hit my car this morning. Luckily it was a small digger (trench size) but it wrecked the front wheel & tyre and also damaged the bumper. The car is a MB ML270 which I have had since new, 03 plate with 133,000 miles on the clock.
Obviously not worth a lot in the trade but worth a lot to me as I like it and certainly do not want to buy a new car.
The insurance co was fairly adamant it would probably be a write off (car worth about £2,250) but garage who took it away confirmed just needs new wheel, tyre & bumper so no issues re safety. They have now sent their quote to insurance co.
The other party was insured and all details exchanged so their insurance will be paying.
My question is, if insurance wants to write it off where do I stand? Lets say they would have given me £2k after excess etc, can I negotiate say £1,500 off the repair bill, pay the rest myself and then carry on insured as before?
Alternatively, can they refuse to pay out anything and cancel my insurance if I do not agree to a write off?
I may be jumping the gun as they have not come back on the quote but I guess this issue could affect anyone with a low value car they have a fairly minor bump in.
Any feedback appreciated.
Phil
Obviously not worth a lot in the trade but worth a lot to me as I like it and certainly do not want to buy a new car.
The insurance co was fairly adamant it would probably be a write off (car worth about £2,250) but garage who took it away confirmed just needs new wheel, tyre & bumper so no issues re safety. They have now sent their quote to insurance co.
The other party was insured and all details exchanged so their insurance will be paying.
My question is, if insurance wants to write it off where do I stand? Lets say they would have given me £2k after excess etc, can I negotiate say £1,500 off the repair bill, pay the rest myself and then carry on insured as before?
Alternatively, can they refuse to pay out anything and cancel my insurance if I do not agree to a write off?
I may be jumping the gun as they have not come back on the quote but I guess this issue could affect anyone with a low value car they have a fairly minor bump in.
Any feedback appreciated.
Phil
I believe the car is yours and if you accept the write-off price then you are selling the car to the insurance company. If you refuse the offer then I'm not sure there is anything they can do.
I'd like to think that you can negotiate a lower amount and make up the difference yourself but to avoid insurance fraud that may not be possible.
I'd like to think that you can negotiate a lower amount and make up the difference yourself but to avoid insurance fraud that may not be possible.
You are claiming off the third party's insurance so how exactly can they cancel the insurance on your car?
My understanding from previous posts was that when claiming against your own insurance it was all down to the terms as to how and when a write off decision was made. When against a third party they must cover your loss and while you cannot expect to be paid the full value of the car and keep the car they cannot just declare it is write off.
This is just 'bloke in a pub' thoughts though, I am sure one of the insurance bods will put it right.
My understanding from previous posts was that when claiming against your own insurance it was all down to the terms as to how and when a write off decision was made. When against a third party they must cover your loss and while you cannot expect to be paid the full value of the car and keep the car they cannot just declare it is write off.
This is just 'bloke in a pub' thoughts though, I am sure one of the insurance bods will put it right.
philcray said:
The insurance co was fairly adamant it would probably be a write off (car worth about £2,250) but garage who took it away confirmed just needs new wheel, tyre & bumper so no issues re safety.
Safety's nothing to do with it. A wheel, tyre and painted bumper for an ML? Yep, I can _easily_ believe that'll be £2k-worth at insurance prices. So CatC.Since you're working with the third party's insurance (you are, aren't you? You've said their insurance accepts liability, but not who you're actually claiming off), you've got a bit more scope. Aim for a payout, keep it, and no record. CatD at worst.
I am going through the same as you, i have a heavily modified 200sx, which has rear bumper damage only and I don't want it recorded as written off, last Friday I was told it was catD total loss but drivable.
they gave me a low ball figure 2k and I provided some adverts with price for a lot more around 5k. Today I mailed them about negotiating a smaller payout if they don't write the car off as I can get bumper and spray job for 600, I was told they need to speak to the engineers, but they were not available so expecting a call tomorrow.
I am not getting my hopes high, as I know they don't have my interest at heart, but lets see what they say.
they gave me a low ball figure 2k and I provided some adverts with price for a lot more around 5k. Today I mailed them about negotiating a smaller payout if they don't write the car off as I can get bumper and spray job for 600, I was told they need to speak to the engineers, but they were not available so expecting a call tomorrow.
I am not getting my hopes high, as I know they don't have my interest at heart, but lets see what they say.
Should be a Cat D write off and normally you get 1st dibs on a buy back.
It happened to us when my daughters Corsa was hit in the drivers door by a taxi. The assessor came up with a ludicrous figure to repair so it was written off as a CAT D. We got just over £2k payout and we were offered the car at £200. We bought it, got a door in the right colour off e-bay, got it MOT'd (must be done after a write off) and back on the road for a total additional cost of £75.
If you are so attached to the car and are confident it will sail through an MOT then I would go with this option.
It happened to us when my daughters Corsa was hit in the drivers door by a taxi. The assessor came up with a ludicrous figure to repair so it was written off as a CAT D. We got just over £2k payout and we were offered the car at £200. We bought it, got a door in the right colour off e-bay, got it MOT'd (must be done after a write off) and back on the road for a total additional cost of £75.
If you are so attached to the car and are confident it will sail through an MOT then I would go with this option.
This happened to me, I was able to keep the car and received a cheque for the estimated cost of the repair less the VAT.
I would have been willing to accept far less but this was their first offer, the car was not put on the Cat C/D list and I repaired the cosmetic damage myself with enough money left over to fit new suspension all around.
However, this was after a truck turned up at my house unannounced just days after the accident to take away the "wreckage". I would advise sticking to your guns, once they know you mean business and realise they won't be paying for a hire car then they will be happy to let you keep your car.
I would have been willing to accept far less but this was their first offer, the car was not put on the Cat C/D list and I repaired the cosmetic damage myself with enough money left over to fit new suspension all around.
However, this was after a truck turned up at my house unannounced just days after the accident to take away the "wreckage". I would advise sticking to your guns, once they know you mean business and realise they won't be paying for a hire car then they will be happy to let you keep your car.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


