Insurance claim - what am I entitled to
Insurance claim - what am I entitled to
Author
Discussion

Fimbo

Original Poster:

313 posts

259 months

Monday 13th April 2015
quotequote all
My Tuscan was rear ended in a pile up (not my fault). My insurers are sorting out the repairs albeit the Insurers of the at fault party have admitted liability for the accident. The repairs will include a respray of pretty much half the car. The paint will be blended into the doors to disguise any slight difference in colour. I've asked the repairers how much to paint the other half of the car and I've been quoted £2k (paint & materials and labour) incl Vat. The paint is a metallic blue (Montreal blue) so it's not a flip flop colour.

My concerns are:

1. I'm going to end up with a car of two halves - the shiny new rear and the weathered front. Not a great combo me thinks.

2. There is very likely to be a slight difference in colour given they have to match the paint to a colour that's been on the car for 12 yrs.

Questions:

1. Am I entitled to seek a contribution to the cost of respraying the front on the basis I wouldnt even be contemplating this but for the accident damage?

2. Does the quote for the additional painting sound reasonable?

Thanks for your help.

MethylatedSpirit

2,114 posts

167 months

Monday 13th April 2015
quotequote all
A painter will blend the paint gradually over the side of the car. They won't respray the front, since that is "betterment".

Best option would be to go ahead with the repair and then have a detailer polish up the front to make it "new again" without the need to paint. You'd have to pay for the detailer yourself.

MJK 24

5,679 posts

267 months

Monday 13th April 2015
quotequote all
I had this with my then ten year old red Elise about five years ago.

Somebody reversed on top of the front of it whilst parking. I said as the car was red and 10 years old it would be difficult to match. The bodyshop agreed but the third party insurers weren't interested.

I paid £1,800 inc VAT to have the remainder of the car repainted which was basically everything behind the windscreen. That included replacing quite a bit of trim.

Your quote sounds reasonable considering it's a much bigger car and metallic paint.

Can you imagine how happy I was three days and 90 miles after I collected my gleaming and perfect shiny car to have someone overshoot a T junction and go straight into the side of me?! Back to the bodyshop for another month...

Fimbo

Original Poster:

313 posts

259 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Thanks for your replies. Still mulling over what to do.

dogzilla

157 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
MethylatedSpirit said:
A painter will blend the paint gradually over the side of the car. They won't respray the front, since that is "betterment"
If it's impossible for them to blend the colour properly then it's not betterment, it's simply the minimum amount of work to return the car to a condition before the crash. i.e. without a bleeding obvious colour blend between the front/back.

Without the repair being done it's impossible to know the outcome so you probably have to accept the repair and then decide whether it's satisfactory or not once complete. If it's left with an obvious difference front/to back and leaves the car in an unsatisfactory condition then you have a right to ask for that to be made good

Edited by dogzilla on Tuesday 14th April 12:18

wd888

88 posts

211 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
find your own paint shop and offer them the insurance job on the terms they do the whole car.

Simond S

4,519 posts

308 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
it may be worth dealing directly with the other insurer.

I have found that the third party company are much nicer to deal with that your own company, and whereas your company have no vested interest the other company who are ultimately paying the bill will source a better car for you to use (without a credit hire agreement!) and will let you propose your prefered garage.


Fimbo

Original Poster:

313 posts

259 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Thanks for further replies. My concern about waiting until after they've painted half is that if its not found to be an exact match (and I we'll see there being debate about that) they'll then try and match unpainted front to the newly painted back using two different paint batches. Perhaps I'm being overly concerned - it's just that I've had to deal with a paint matching issue on the family BMW a couple of yrs ago. Looked like a patchwork quilt. Workshop wouldn't acknowledge obvious difference in colour.

Risotto

3,934 posts

243 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Can't you convince them to use the leading edge of the doors as the boundary? The fact the door is inset compared to the front wing would probably help to make any mismatch less obvious.

You are of course entitled to dictate where the car is repaired too, so if you know of a reputable local bodyshop, have the car sent there.

Personally I wouldn't worry too much - presumably the car has been garaged most of its life so the paint probably hasn't degraded much.

The suggestion that you deal with the 3rd party insurer direct may be a good one. I did that when someone hit me. Emailed them a few photos and a couple of repair quotes from local bodyshops and they sorted it all out. My own insurers wanted me to pay them my excess which they said they would refund at some later point, so I just kept my excess and worked around them in the end.

Edited by Risotto on Tuesday 14th April 19:00

Toltec

7,179 posts

254 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Would it be better to have the front polished first? That way they need to match the cleaned up paintwork, if you polish after the re-spray the front may change colour slightly?

dogzilla

157 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Fimbo said:
Thanks for further replies. My concern about waiting until after they've painted half is that if its not found to be an exact match (and I we'll see there being debate about that) they'll then try and match unpainted front to the newly painted back using two different paint batches. Perhaps I'm being overly concerned - it's just that I've had to deal with a paint matching issue on the family BMW a couple of yrs ago. Looked like a patchwork quilt. Workshop wouldn't acknowledge obvious difference in colour.
I understand what you are saying but I don't think they would argue over what-ifs. There is still a chance the repair could be done to a good standard. The rear of the car is usually the good bit which hasn't been battered by stonechips etc... So having a fresh arse isn't that bad I don't think.

You say the insurers are sorting the repairs, does that mean they have selected a bodyshop for you? Or have you arranged that yourself?

Given it's a TVR I can't imagine it's standard paint, if it's been dropped off at your nearest franchised bks crash repair site it's likely to see more Astra's and Fiesta's than it is classics like a TVR so should be avoided.

You should find and select your own specialist body-shop if you haven't already. You ideally want someone who will be on your side rather than a regular insurance jobby as they will be more concerned with keeping the insurance company happy than you. If in their opinion they say the colour will be difficult to match then you have something to take to the insurance company.

Either way, it's definitely worth pursuing if the repair is not satisfactory though you do have to be reasonable. I hate to think how many PH'ers would get out a spectrophotometers and measure the wavelength to within a nanometer and then claim it's not matched correctly.

Edited by dogzilla on Tuesday 14th April 19:23