Blown Turbo Sale of Goods
Blown Turbo Sale of Goods
Author
Discussion

DukeVega

Original Poster:

6 posts

139 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Dear Internet People,

Hope I have posted in the right section, Just need a little advice and help please.


- On the 10/11/14 I purchased a BMW x3 M sport (black / cream leather interior) From XXX over in Sheffield.

I paid just under 9k for the car but also purchased a 2 year warranty for about £500.00


Last week on the 8/4/15 The turbo Blew on the vehicle and I called up the gartage help-line.
- 3 hours later they finaly picked us up with a proper tow truck.

Next day I was told to take the car round the corner to another company as they had better labor rates.
( a BMW specialist ) began work on the car.

Today (1 week later) I have been told that the

Turbo Shaft impella SNAPPED

which in turn caused the intercooler to block

and the exhaust system to fill with oil.


The warranty company is ONLY prepared to cover the Turbo and man hours to fix it (which they seem to think is only 2.5)
the BMW specialist are telling them and me its 4.5


The warranty company is also only prepared to send a second hand recon turbo not a new one.


Also as the Actual repair time on the vehicle is UNDER 8 hours, the warranty company is refusing to give me a courtesy car.
(this is in the small print)



SO.........


I have phone the dealer principle from the Sheffield branch and told him "Under the Sale of Goods Act" I want this fixed...
He has disputed this and told me the vehicle is classed as a "runabout" and sold as seen.
(even though I am 99% sure it was a retail approved vehicle, because i was even told it had a 3month warranty as standard)
(Runabouts only have 1 month... + they left the header board in the car when I drove off, its in Red which means its retail)
- but he has also said, he will look at the paperwork and call me back (that was 4 hours ago)

I have also contacted EH head office and reg an official basic complaint, they have agreed to look into it.



Right now I have NO CAR and not looking at getting my car fixed for another 5 days
Also looking at a bill for about £500.000 to cover the bits not on warranty (ie> the intercooler cleaning / exhaust system)
Also check for contamination of metal filings etc,,,


Steve Roweleys the BMW specialist even told me that the last full service on the vehicle (done at XXX ) they should of replaced the Crank Case Breather or at least checked it... but he thinks no one did.
Also he said the Turbo Shaft impella would of been unfit at point of sale,

(I have only done about 5,000 miles in the car since purchasing it).



SO.......


Give me your thoughts please, where do I stand? What should I do?



Regards,



Matty


Edited by DukeVega on Tuesday 14th April 12:32


Edited by DukeVega on Tuesday 14th April 13:06


Edited by eybic on Tuesday 14th April 13:45

cheesesliceking

1,577 posts

271 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
how does the borken shaft block the intercooler when the intercooler sits before it?

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
What does the wording of the warranty say? A lot don't cover consequential loss, only the part that actually failed. As for the SOGA, it depends whether the fault is classed as "fair wear and tear", which in this instance probably applies.

Edited by Monty Python on Tuesday 14th April 12:36

DukeVega

Original Poster:

6 posts

139 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Yeh the warranty is NAFF!!! it will only cover the failed parts and not towards the parts which it caused to fail.
even though ofc it is a direct result of the turbo failure.

I am going down the Sale of Goods Act route here..... the Warranty is a con!!!

My thoughts are that within 6 months of sale, they need to fix the dam car and not leave me out of pocket

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
How old was the car, and how many miles were on it?

SOGA applies, whether or not the car is a "runabout", but it is not a bumper-to-bumper warranty. The age and mileage of the car - and if the car was sold at a premium for its age and mileage, due to condition - are relevant to what is reasonable to expect in terms of durability and quality, and clearly the car worked when you drove it off the forecourt.

The insurance backed warranty is probably entitled to exclude what it considers consequential loss, but it would need to be very clear about what that is, and you would really need to understand what the wording says to get more detailed advice. The same applies to the labour rates - if there is a dispute as to the amount of effort, it should say how that is to be resolved.

I don't think it's a problem if they are only willing to use a recon turbo - the rest of the car is presumably about eight yeas old, so why shouldn't the turbo be reconditioned to the standard of the rest of the car? That said, the use of the recon turbo could be a bargaining chip to get the other work done.

Simond S

4,519 posts

308 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all

It depends on whether the car was sold as a runaround / approved or premium.

All three sale agreements have different benefits. http://www.evanshalshaw.com/used-cars/


I'd play nice to the dealer principal and try and get some goodwill from him to assist with the warranty company, and additional costs.


anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Mileage of the car and the age? That's relevant because it determines whether the turbo could reasonably be expected to be at the end of it's life or not. If the car has done 150k miles you're on much shakier ground trying to go down the SOGA route than if it's done 50k .

Ignore all the dealer BS about it being sold as a "runabout", they're just trying to put you off.

That said you'll have a much easier time of it if you keep them onside. If you go in shouting the odds about the warranty being a con (it's not, you just need to read the small print before you agree to it, just like any insurance policy) and SOGA you're likely to get their backs up from the word go. Previous poster is spot on IMO in that you should approach the DP looking for a "goodwill gesture" first, see where that gets you.

Edited by anonymous-user on Tuesday 14th April 12:40

dogzilla

157 posts

242 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
If the blown turbo results in filling your exhaust with oil and requires your DPF to be replaced, I don't think that's consequential loss. That's a direct loss from the original failure which the warranty should cover imo, though depends on the wording of the contract.

Consequential loss would be for example you having to rent a car as a replacement.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Also OP, if you want this thread to stay on here edit your thread and delete the name of the garage. It's against the name & shame rules.

Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
dogzilla said:
If the blown turbo results in filling your exhaust with oil and requires your DPF to be replaced, I don't think that's consequential loss. That's a direct loss from the original failure which the warranty should cover imo, though depends on the wording of the contract.

Consequential loss would be for example you having to rent a car as a replacement.
That's not what the likes of Warranty Direct term consequential loss - they define it as damage that occurs as a result of a part failing that isn't directly associated with it. The usual example is a belt failure - if the belt flies off and gets caught somewhere else and causes damage, that's consequential loss.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
DukeVega said:
The warranty company is ONLY prepared to cover the Turbo and man hours to fix it (which they seem to think is only 2.5)
What's the BMW book time for the job?

DukeVega said:
The warranty company yis also only prepared to send a second hand recon turbo not a new one.
Second hand? Or Recon? Which is it? I very much doubt even a BMW dealer would supply a brand-spanking turbo rather than a recon.

DukeVega said:
Also as the Actual repair time on the vehicle is UNDER 8 hours, the warranty company is refusing to give me a courtesy car.
(this is in the small print)
And...?

DukeVega said:
I have phone the dealer principle from the Sheffield branch and told him "Under the Sale of Goods Act" I want this fixed...
And so it shall be. The warranty, which your beefs appear to be about, are on top of your statutory rights under SOGA.

And, for a turbo to fail five months and 5,000 miles after the purchase of what's probably an 8-9yo car (looking at ages of X3s for sale at around that price now), SOGA would definitely class that as wear and tear.

DukeVega said:
He has disputed this and told me the vehicle is classed as a "runabout" and sold as seen.
(even though I am 99% sure it was a retail approved vehicle, because i was even told it had a 3month warranty as standard)
(Runabouts only have 1 month... + they left the header board in the car when I drove off, its in Red which means its retail)
All very nice, and everything, but you bought it five months ago and have a two year warranty - which is covering the turbo replacement.

DukeVega said:
Right now I have NO CAR and not looking at getting my car fixed for another 5 days
Give me your thoughts please, where do I stand?
At a bus stop, by the sound of things.

Can't this BMW specialist sort you a loan car?

DukeVega

Original Poster:

6 posts

139 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
charltjr said:
Mileage of the car and the age? That's relevant because it determines whether the turbo could reasonably be expected to be at the end of it's life or not. If the car has done 150k miles you're on much shakier ground trying to go down the SOGA route than if it's done 50k .

Ignore all the dealer BS about it being sold as a "runabout", they're just trying to put you off.

That said you'll have a much easier time of it if you keep them onside. If you go in shouting the odds about the warranty being a con (it's not, you just need to read the small print before you agree to it, just like any insurance policy) and SOGA you're likely to get their backs up from the word go. Previous poster is spot on IMO in that you should approach the DP looking for a "goodwill gesture" first, see where that gets you.

Edited by charltjr on Tuesday 14th April 12:40
Mileage of the car at sale was 84k its not on ermmm 88k (so yeh I have done 4k miles) - not much


GreatGranny

9,519 posts

257 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
It doesn't matter if its premium, runabout or whatever.
Its a car sold by a dealer/trader so is covered under SOGA.
However because of the age mileage etc.. there's a limit to what you can be expect to be covered if things fail/break etc.. on the car.
The warranty like most, as you said is useless but if the car has done high mileage then not sure if its reasonable to expect the dealer to stump up for all repairs.
But no harm in trying

Edited by eybic on Tuesday 14th April 13:44

BuzzBravado

2,949 posts

202 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
cheesesliceking said:
how does the borken shaft block the intercooler when the intercooler sits before it?
Why would the intercooler be before the turbo? The intercooler is downstream of the turbo. No point cooling the air before it hits the hot turbo.

jimi

521 posts

294 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
On the positive side, Steve Rowley is the best BMW specialist round this way. So what he is saying is correct and will be the best advice.


Monty Python

4,813 posts

228 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
BuzzBravado said:
Why would the intercooler be before the turbo? The intercooler is downstream of the turbo. No point cooling the air before it hits the hot turbo.

If the seals failed then oil could pass from the compressor into the intercooler, likewise from the turbine side into the exhaust system. However, it should be possible to clean it.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
DukeVega said:
Mileage of the car at sale was 84k its not on ermmm 88k (so yeh I have done 4k miles) - not much
So we've got an 8-9yo, near on 90k car, with a turbo that's failed.

How very... unexpected.

Modern turbo diesels, with variable vane turbos, like to get the odd bit of oomph to keep everything clean and unclagged. 10k a year average, now 4k in the last 5mo, in an M-sport X3 all kinda adds up to it having been the local shopping-and-kids trolley. No wonder it's caked up and failed. Like I said - wear and tear, SOGA, warranty.

Look on the bright side - for a bit of contribution from your pocket, you've got a fresh turbo not a 90k timebomb.

Superhoop

4,919 posts

224 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
I think the first question you should asking is what the cause of the turbo shaft snapping was, because I'd be very surprised if the shaft itself was faulty - if was faulty, it wouldn't have made it through the first 88k miles

A turbo is actually quite a simple devise, but they do rely on a good supply of oil to prevent them from failing - A snapped shaft generally means that the turbo stopped rather more quickly than it should have or either the compressor or impellor were impacted by something, so finding out what that was is the most important part. If for example is was a blockage in the oil supply, the new (reconditioned) turbo won't make it past the road test.

BuzzBravado

2,949 posts

202 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Monty Python said:
BuzzBravado said:
Why would the intercooler be before the turbo? The intercooler is downstream of the turbo. No point cooling the air before it hits the hot turbo.

If the seals failed then oil could pass from the compressor into the intercooler, likewise from the turbine side into the exhaust system. However, it should be possible to clean it.
Yeah i dont disagree with that.

RobGT81

5,229 posts

217 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Could be a lot of things causing the shaft the fail. A compressor or turbine letting go can be enough to knock a hub off. Oil starvation is probably the most common though.