Cheryl's Birthday
Discussion
I hate to think how much time this has wasted in my office...

Full article here http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-32297367

Full article here http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-32297367
iambeowulf said:
How does he know Bernard doesn't know it and why would that change the fact either of them know now?
Because of the Month Albert is told, he knows that every possible day-of-the-month is shared with at least one other month, so that's why he says he knows Bernard cannot possibly know.e.g. If Albert had been told June, it's possible Bernard could have been told 18, so Bernard would then know. So it's not August, as Albert declares that there's no way Bernard can know.
When Albert reveals this, Bernard can deduce which month Albert has been told.
Edited by ReallyReallyGood on Wednesday 15th April 10:33
Got May the 19th fist - but re-reading Bernard and Alberts responses i'm not so sure. Having another think.
edit: OK can't be the 19th May or 18th June because if it was - Bernard (knowing the number) would know which date it was straight away:
That being the case - i'd say it's June 17th.
If you matrix the months and days up - then cross off the dates that Bernard can't know as above - the only month with only one possible day is June.
edit: OK can't be the 19th May or 18th June because if it was - Bernard (knowing the number) would know which date it was straight away:
That being the case - i'd say it's June 17th.
If you matrix the months and days up - then cross off the dates that Bernard can't know as above - the only month with only one possible day is June.
Edited by Moonhawk on Wednesday 15th April 10:44
Albert says he knows that Bernard doesn't know the birthday. Assume that Cheryl's birthday was on 18th or 19th, then Albert would had received either June or May. If he had received June or May, then he wouldn't had said he knows "Bernard doesn't knows about the birthday" as if it was June 18th, he would had received June and thus Albert wouldn't had been sure about this (If Bernard received 18th, he would had known the birthday instantly). SO, WE KNOW THAT HER BIRTHDAY IS NOT IN MAY OR JUNE.
Now Bernard didn't know her birthday, but on the basis of Albert saying Bernard can't have known initially, he now knows. Let's assume the birthday of Cheryl was on 14th, in that case Bernard would had been confused between July and August and thus wouldn't had been sure, but he is. This means her birthday is on EITHER 15, 16 or 17.
Now Albert says, on the basis of Bernard now being able to work out her birthday, that he also knows her birthday. If the month Albert received was August, then we wouldn't had been sure about the birthday, but he is - THIS MEANS HER BIRTHDAY IS ON JULY 16th.
Now Bernard didn't know her birthday, but on the basis of Albert saying Bernard can't have known initially, he now knows. Let's assume the birthday of Cheryl was on 14th, in that case Bernard would had been confused between July and August and thus wouldn't had been sure, but he is. This means her birthday is on EITHER 15, 16 or 17.
Now Albert says, on the basis of Bernard now being able to work out her birthday, that he also knows her birthday. If the month Albert received was August, then we wouldn't had been sure about the birthday, but he is - THIS MEANS HER BIRTHDAY IS ON JULY 16th.
Edited by TwigtheWonderkid on Wednesday 15th April 10:47
Gassing Station | The Lounge | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




k can't a woman give a straight answer to a straight question".
