Traffic light mood swings
Traffic light mood swings
Author
Discussion

Howard-

Original Poster:

4,964 posts

233 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
There's a fairly large junction on my way home - fairly standard crossroads affair with 2 lanes at each intersection etc. Now, sometimes the lights for my direction will go green and stay green for a while, long enough to let a good number of cars through. But there are times, like today (which prompted by curiosity, and subsequently, this thread) where they go green, let about 4 cars through, and then go red again.

I can't see any reason for this - no emergency vehicles or anything like that.

Sorry for the rather dull question but I'm curious as to why this might be! I presumed they'd just be on a fixed timer, during normal hours anyway.

tomsugden

2,483 posts

259 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Different times of the day?

Howard-

Original Poster:

4,964 posts

233 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Nope it's always at about half 4 when I leave work. Amount of traffic is usually consistent too.

to3m

1,228 posts

201 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
There was one like this near where I used to work, with traffic lights controlling access to a roundabout. Sometimes the cycle for straight on - which is where I'd be going - would miss a beat. As best I could tell, the cycle was being influenced by a nearby works that had two sites on opposite sides of the road and its own set of traffic lights that they could use when they needed to transfer material from site to the other. (This would block traffic for maybe up to a minute.)

This only stopped people entering at that particular point, but this had by far the largest volume of traffic during peak times and so my assumption was that this was just a spot fix to reduce the chance of the roundabout getting blocked.

(There were some other more inexplicable day-to-day variations on my commute, some of which seemed to make a real mess of traffic when they occurred - often wondered whether these were helping on average in some other area. Would have loved to have a bird's eye view.)

Edited by to3m on Thursday 16th April 17:50

grahamr88

426 posts

204 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
to3m said:
There was one like this near where I used to work, with traffic lights controlling access to a roundabout. Sometimes the cycle for straight on - which is where I'd be going - would miss a beat. As best I could tell, the cycle was being influenced by a nearby works that had two sites on opposite sides of the road and its own set of traffic lights that they could use when they needed to transfer material from site to the other. (This would block traffic for maybe up to a minute.)

This only stopped people entering at that particular point, but this had by far the largest volume of traffic during peak times and so my assumption was that this was just a spot fix to reduce the chance of the roundabout getting blocked.
Forgemasters in Sheffield?

to3m

1,228 posts

201 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
grahamr88 said:
to3m said:
There was one like this near where I used to work, with traffic lights controlling access to a roundabout. Sometimes the cycle for straight on - which is where I'd be going - would miss a beat. As best I could tell, the cycle was being influenced by a nearby works that had two sites on opposite sides of the road and its own set of traffic lights that they could use when they needed to transfer material from site to the other. (This would block traffic for maybe up to a minute.)

This only stopped people entering at that particular point, but this had by far the largest volume of traffic during peak times and so my assumption was that this was just a spot fix to reduce the chance of the roundabout getting blocked.
Forgemasters in Sheffield?
The very one smile - I used to work in the office park down the bottom, near the river. I'd drive in along Brightside Lane coming from town.

Sheepshanks

41,401 posts

150 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Howard- said:
Sorry for the rather dull question but I'm curious as to why this might be! I presumed they'd just be on a fixed timer, during normal hours anyway.
There are several different ways of doing it but certainly most main junctions around me (near Chester) will clear all waiting traffic and then change. So they're obviously looking for a gap in the traffic - that's why you can get stopped unexpectedly if a car in front of you doesn't move away smartly.

Some as you get further into town are timed such that driving into town late afternoon is a pain as the lights cycle quickly to give outgoing traffic more time.

They might also be centrally controlled as part of some wider traffic management system.

SuperPav

1,360 posts

156 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
I think there's only one obvious explanation....


LordGrover

34,191 posts

243 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
I to get a little irked when a car in front is slow to cross the sensors. It's clear that they look for a gap to change the lights but often someone will leave too great a gap and the feckers change while there's still a queue. irked

skip_1

3,514 posts

221 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Also some towns such as Leeds have sensors in the buses to give them priority at lights.

IntriguedUser

995 posts

152 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
skip_1 said:
Also some towns such as Leeds have sensors in the buses to give them priority at lights.
I think there's a magnet method also..