Bucking the trend
Discussion
Any good examples of cars (or even whole marques) that are bucking the trends? For example, Porsche holding out for so long with NA engines (although sadly coming to an end), manufacturers using a sensible number of exhaust tips (BMWs seem to cope with 1 for up to 200bhp), any reasonably priced cars with understated quality materials rather than yards of 'chrome' bling and soft touch plastics, free-revving engines rather than stressed turbo units, etc?
kambites said:
You mean the same BMW who put 4 exhaust tips on an engine with only one bank of cylinders?. 
Well...there's good and bad. 1 tip on the 320i, for example.
Good point re Morgan, but they aren't really subject to the same market pressures.
Very interested to see whether lotus decides to try to take market share from some of the bigger manufacturers by using decent but thirsty engines, etc. Unfortunately, I expect Lotus to go balls deep with eco nonsense. At least they can't afford some of the most pointless tech!
I like Mazda's Skyactiv stuff - all very Eco but without downsizing, turbos etc. (That said, mazda loves all the absurd 'safety' tech)
Is there a decent market for the kind of cars we would like? Would a 330i sell? Would Porsche do well to stick with the NA 6 cyl if VAG can allow it?
kambites said:
You mean the same BMW who put 4 exhaust tips on an engine with only one bank of cylinders?. 
Just two though the e46 and F80 M cars, plenty of others where they show restraint 550i just has 2 for example, the other models with 4 had/have V8 or V10 engines most with supercar rivalling power outputs so pretty fair to have 4 exhaust exits.
Porsche for making the new Cayman GT4 a manual. Would have been so easy to make it paddles ala GT3 whilst wittering on about lap times...
in a similar vein, manual gearbox in the new VW Polo GTi. In a world where Renault will only supply you a hot Clio with paddles, I applaud this move. Especially from a company I've oft assumed is run by clever marketeers and accountants who probably don't actually like driving cars very much...
in a similar vein, manual gearbox in the new VW Polo GTi. In a world where Renault will only supply you a hot Clio with paddles, I applaud this move. Especially from a company I've oft assumed is run by clever marketeers and accountants who probably don't actually like driving cars very much...
I also like the way that not only have Mazda stuck with NA power in the new mx5, they have resolutely avoided the incremental power wars the Germans have now got themselves stuck in. Plus they've made the new one lighter than the old one.
They seem to understand their own brief and over the years stuck with it. And you argue its working for them!
Bmw take note with mini: a good start but the threads are unravelling as the years progress...
They seem to understand their own brief and over the years stuck with it. And you argue its working for them!
Bmw take note with mini: a good start but the threads are unravelling as the years progress...
GT86/ BRZ seems to be the obvious answer. Naturally aspirated, manual box, skinny wheels/ tyres, uncomplicated RWD chassis/ drivetrain. Having briefly lived with one, I can say that they have maintained the 'basic' philosophy on the interior, to the cars detriment. Small manual RWD coupes in general are something of a dying breed...
New MX5 remaining a 'true' MX5. Not exactly 'bucking the trend' as Mazda have never really deviated from the original MX5 philosophy/ formula, but perhaps in the sense of a strong focus on weight saving and retaining a small NA engine- the temptation to put a turbo on there must have been significant.
Anyone who doesn't fall into the 'New Clio Trap' and keep their small sporty hatches naturally aspirated with a stick.
Clearly a pattern then- NA with a proper manual box. Particularly true for manufacturers who know that most buyers won't care or know the difference if they fit auto/ paddles or a turbo. Companies that do this likely share many values with PHers, as modern legislation/ cycles etc are the deciding factors that drive the proliferation of auto/ turbo cars.
I'm sure there are more interesting and discussion-worthy examples of manufacturers 'bucking the trend', but (sadly) this is the one that stands out to me.
New MX5 remaining a 'true' MX5. Not exactly 'bucking the trend' as Mazda have never really deviated from the original MX5 philosophy/ formula, but perhaps in the sense of a strong focus on weight saving and retaining a small NA engine- the temptation to put a turbo on there must have been significant.
Anyone who doesn't fall into the 'New Clio Trap' and keep their small sporty hatches naturally aspirated with a stick.
Clearly a pattern then- NA with a proper manual box. Particularly true for manufacturers who know that most buyers won't care or know the difference if they fit auto/ paddles or a turbo. Companies that do this likely share many values with PHers, as modern legislation/ cycles etc are the deciding factors that drive the proliferation of auto/ turbo cars.
I'm sure there are more interesting and discussion-worthy examples of manufacturers 'bucking the trend', but (sadly) this is the one that stands out to me.
Matt UK said:
manual gearbox in the new VW Polo GTi. In a world where Renault will only supply you a hot Clio with paddles, I applaud this move. Especially from a company I've oft assumed is run by clever marketeers and accountants who probably don't actually like driving cars very much...
It took a long time and a lot of persuasion for them to give it a manual box. The marketeers and accountants did win to start with.nickfrog said:
It took a long time and a lot of persuasion for them to give it a manual box. The marketeers and accountants did win to start with.
Porsche's decision re the GT4 was also said to be the result of pressure from buyers & the motoring press.As someone who drives a PDK car (so I do understand the benefits of an advanced auto/ semi-auto), I can honestly say that every time I see a 'sporty' car that is auto only, I think 'You've just lost all credibility'.
How anyone could want a Jag with that box as a sports car, I have no idea! The same goes for the C64 AMG.
One defining characteristic of a lot of the trends is the move away from producing cars that actually enjoyable to drive and towards cars that are only remotely enjoyable at massively illegal speeds. Where's the fun in 400ft/lb of torque from 1500 revs on a public road, especially when the car also has a EPAS and weighs 1698kg.
It would be a start if motoring journos had to stay within a measurable distance of speed limits when doing road tests! It always makes me laugh when I see someone doing (or describing) a 6800 rev change up from 3rd and then keeping their foot in after engaging 4th. What's that then, about 110mph in any fast, long geared car?!
The genuine innovations that I like are on the tiny, cheap city cars. A lot of those are quite impressively cheap and cheerful and interesting (and some are apparently OK to drive).
I agree about Mazda (but shame the 6 has become so large; the 3 also looks big). GT86 also. It goes to show what a risk a car like the GT86 is these days when even Toyota has to pool resources.
It seems driving enthusiasts have been backed into such a corner that just offering a manual gearbox is considered to be bucking the trend!!
Anyway, I think the Alfa 4C deserves a mention. Yes, it's paddles-only and turbocharged, but it sure takes some balls for a mainstream manufacturer to make their flagship car small, light, hard-to-get-in and bare/noisy.
It will be looked back upon as being ahead of its time.
It seems driving enthusiasts have been backed into such a corner that just offering a manual gearbox is considered to be bucking the trend!!
Anyway, I think the Alfa 4C deserves a mention. Yes, it's paddles-only and turbocharged, but it sure takes some balls for a mainstream manufacturer to make their flagship car small, light, hard-to-get-in and bare/noisy.
braddo said:
I agree about Mazda (but shame the 6 has become so large; the 3 also looks big). GT86 also. It goes to show what a risk a car like the GT86 is these days when even Toyota has to pool resources.
It seems driving enthusiasts have been backed into such a corner that just offering a manual gearbox is considered to be bucking the trend!!
Anyway, I think the Alfa 4C deserves a mention. Yes, it's paddles-only and turbocharged, but it sure takes some balls for a mainstream manufacturer to make their flagship car small, light, hard-to-get-in and bare/noisy.
It will be looked back upon as being ahead of its time.
I was excited about the 4C, and I agree that there is much to recommend it. But it's auto only, has a nasty little engine and has stupid crap like digital instruments. Very tacky.It seems driving enthusiasts have been backed into such a corner that just offering a manual gearbox is considered to be bucking the trend!!
Anyway, I think the Alfa 4C deserves a mention. Yes, it's paddles-only and turbocharged, but it sure takes some balls for a mainstream manufacturer to make their flagship car small, light, hard-to-get-in and bare/noisy.
clowesy said:
I can't understand the need in electric steering on cars like the 911 GT3
Hint: The engines in the wrong end!(think of the cost saving to be had in the move to 'lecy steering, both in terms of components, design and of course production. Add in the much wider tuning and control interaction possibilities of pure EPAS and i'm surprised they haven't done it sooner....... )
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


