Cracked Crankshaft
Author
Discussion

OSGrooves

Original Poster:

38 posts

250 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
So my in-laws were driving down the motorway in their 07 plate Skoda Fabia on Sunday when all sorts of warning lights came on. It seems that there was a problem with the speed sensor and the net result is that the crankshaft is cracked and it needs a new engine. Cost of the new engine is £5.5k and the car is worth £3k on a good day.

What does the great and the good recommend for this situation?

Are there any companies out there who buy cars in this kind of condition and then do the work themselves? This seems like the painless option.

Are there specialist companies who deal with engine work? I've only heard bad things about these kinds of companies but does anyone have a recommendation?

DickP

1,180 posts

181 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
I would be asking more along the lines of how on earth did the engine break its crankshaft?? Is it a known fault with a line of engines with substandard crankshafts?

George111

6,930 posts

282 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Used eBay engine and local garage.

Don't buy VW group again, reliability is going out of the window with VW right now.

mighty kitten

431 posts

164 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Bit sparse on details but I doubt a decent engine from a salvage yard would be more than £4-500 with some warranty and to swap would be around the same plus timing belt kit and water pump if it's one of the belt driven engines

SuperPav

1,360 posts

156 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Who diagnosed the cracked crankshaft?

This is about as major an engine failure as you can have. I know VWs aren't exactly bulletproof, but is this really a not uncommon occurence??

kev b

2,756 posts

197 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Has the dual mass flywheel been replaced with a solid one I wonder?

I would definitely recommend a second opinion before replacing the engine however as a cracked crank is not that common.

OSGrooves

Original Poster:

38 posts

250 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
I very much doubt the flywheel will have been replaced.

It sounds like it could have been misdiagnosed. How do you go about diagnosing a crack crankshaft? I kind of assumed that they'd have had to take the engine apart to visually inspect it. Is this true? Could they tell anything by cycling the pistons?

SuperPav

1,360 posts

156 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
If they'd taken the sump off, you'd notice a cracked crank pretty quickly!

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
SuperPav said:
If they'd taken the sump off, you'd notice a cracked crank pretty quickly!
Should be pretty easy to spot - drop the sump and get a big bar on the crank pulley to turn it over slowly for inspection.

BFG TERRANO

2,172 posts

179 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
What are its symptoms? I'd be very surprised if the crank has cracked

robinessex

12,045 posts

212 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
SuperPav said:
If they'd taken the sump off, you'd notice a cracked crank pretty quickly!
Not neccesarily. Cracks often start from a stress concentration region,usualy the fillet radius at the ends of a bearing surface, or a surface defect. If the crack is across a bearing joirnal, it won't be visible. If it's across one of the web, it may/may not be visable. I do query that this 'fault' can be diagnosed without stripping down the engine down though.

Megaflow

11,671 posts

256 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Something doesn't add up here.

1) How does a speed sensor problem lead to a cracked crankshaft?
2) Cracked to me says it has a crack, but is largely intact, broken into two halves is generally described as a snapped crank. How did they diagnose this crack without opening the engine?

Mave

8,217 posts

246 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Did it have any symptoms other than warning lights? And which warning lights came on?

Leptons

5,493 posts

207 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
I don't really understand how a cracked crank would affect the engine running full stop. IF its snapped in half it would be pretty damn obvious. You'd only find a crack of you went looking for it. The diagnosis is bks. Sounds like a typical main dealer response where the receptionist is pieing you off with some bullst.

gvij

365 posts

155 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
If its the 1.4 I dont think you can loosen the bearing shells without destorying the engine. I would get another opinion first.