Modern synthetic engine oil deterioration
Modern synthetic engine oil deterioration
Author
Discussion

Matt UK

Original Poster:

18,084 posts

231 months

Thursday 16th April 2015
quotequote all
Just curious really, what causes a more rapid deteriation, usage or time?

Assume the engine oil / filters in a given car should be changed every 12k miles or every 12 months.

If the service is late and with all things being equal, in which scenario would the engine be suffering more; the car which did 24k miles in a year or the car that did 6k miles but in 2 years?

It was a question I was asked and confess that I'm not really sure. I'm going with over usage causing more issues than time though.

Please enlighten me. Use of complicated science welcome hehe


cirian75

5,808 posts

264 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
I ignore what the book says and change every 6 month or 6k, which ever is sooner.

Tyred

23 posts

145 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Oil deterioration is typified by the reduction of efficiency of the additive package, anti-foaming agents, anti-oxidents, detergents, viscosity improvers, corrosion inhibitors and anti-shear (extreme pressure) additives. In use the oil also becomes contaminated with chemical deposits from engine combustion, and microscopic metal contamination from wear elements in the engine such as bearings and shells. In addition, viscosity increases with use, and lubricative properties decrease.

A car sat for two years with only 6000 miles on it will subject its oil to only one fourth of the deterioration of an engine with 24,000 miles on it, everything else being equal.




kambites

71,748 posts

252 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Engine oil doesn't deteriorate much with time at all.

However, mileage isn't a very useful metric either because not all miles are equal in terms of oil damage. I think the "time or mileage, whichever comes first" was an attempt at putting a simple description on something far too complicated to explain properly. I suspect this is why modern cars have electronic service indicators which can take things far more complicated than the average buyer would be willing to understand into account.

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
The service indicator on my car started second guessing the milage I'd do to try to count down to 12 months after its PDI date - despite being at half the milage interval.

I reckon the manufacturer just wants the car in to the dealer every 12 months minimum to have a look and do the warranty health check.

J4CKO

47,113 posts

231 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
cirian75 said:
I ignore what the book says and change every 6 month or 6k, which ever is sooner.
I change mine once a year, never get anywhere near on mileage, it is just a bit of a ritual, the 350Z only has a couple of thousand miles since last year, I reckon at that rate I could go another year with no ill effects but when I come to sell it I want to be able to show it has had some attention yearly.

I cant see the point of doing it more often than that, it may make the difference between the engine doing 400,000 and 450,000 before needing any work but realistically that will be another 200 years before I go that far and usually something else gets most cars before a well designed, correctly serviced engine with no known inherent faults (Porsche I am looking at you here....) fails.

conkerman

3,520 posts

166 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
cirian75 said:
I ignore what the book says and change every 6 month or 6k, which ever is sooner.
This post was brought to you from 1957.

Robert Elise

958 posts

176 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
oil can last a long time, take a look at the many oil analyses online, especially for proper synthetics.
water and fuel will kill it, which is why OBCs count starts and don't count down the mileage so much with long m'way runs.
Oil hates short runs.

Tyred

23 posts

145 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
conkerman said:
This post was brought to you from 1957.
You don't have any idea of what the car is, what oil is being discussed, or the conditions it's being driven in. My 2014 car manual stipulates 6000 mile intervals for hard service life vehicles.

Also, there is demonstratably less engine wear with more frequent oil changes. The 3000 mile interval of Jiffy Lube in the USA is ludicrous but 6000 miles on a modern engine with hard service, cold weather short runs or towing is not.

Back to the original question: oil (additives) absorb water and carbon which leads to acid contamination. On short run engines condensates are not always boiled off and acid contamination builds up.

If our 6000 miles car only drives two miles each way for each trip the oil additives may not be coping too well with the acid content.


kambites

71,748 posts

252 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
I think that's the key really. Time doesn't kill oil but cold running certainly does.

A car which does 6000 summer miles a year and is SORNed for six months in the winter will probably suffer from less oil degradation in two years than a car which does 12k miles a year (by being used in the same way all year round) does in one. However, a car which does 6000 miles a year because it's being used for journeys half the length all year round will probably suffer almost as much degradation per year as the 12k mile car.

Edited by kambites on Friday 17th April 09:03

Matt UK

Original Poster:

18,084 posts

231 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Genuinely insightful replies, thanks all.

Grayedout

418 posts

243 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
An oil only has a fixed number of various additives such as base molecules to combat the acids, dispersants to handle soot and other debris and also surface active molecules that provide anti friction films.

Once these have run out then it's time to change your oil !

Fastpedeller

4,390 posts

177 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Robert Elise said:
oil can last a long time, take a look at the many oil analyses online, especially for proper synthetics.
water and fuel will kill it, which is why OBCs count starts and don't count down the mileage so much with long m'way runs.
Oil hates short runs.
The above is VERY true. If you only use the car once a week and do a 120 mile journey that will be about 6000 miles a year, and will be getting the engine oil hot for a long period each usage. Compared with a 10 mile journey each way to work every day, where it will clock up a similar mileage, but be more detrimental. As a stark example of what can happen, when I worked in the car industry a university was doing a cold start study for us ...... the engine would be started, run for 2 minutes then stopped, left for 5 minutes and then repeated - After the equivalent of 300 miles driving the bores were shagged, and the oil dilution was horrific! The fuel enrichment for cold start, and never reaching hot running are not good for an engine. So don't buy the 6000miles, 4 year old car that's never had it's oil changed from the little old lady down the road - rather buy the 50k miles, known to have been serviced 4 year old car!

Qubit

142 posts

154 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Ive recently moved and my daily commute is up to about 15 miles each way with the first 20 mins on a run and then 30 mins stuck in central Cambridge. I figure that ill be changing the oil and filter once a year and a mid yearly change of just the oil. Total mileage probably around 12-13k, but with the truly awful Cambridge traffic the additional oil change is probably worth it.