Used car from a dealer - big repair bill after only 2 weeks
Used car from a dealer - big repair bill after only 2 weeks
Author
Discussion

AM7

Original Poster:

268 posts

160 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Afternoon all, just looking for some advice/opinions/experiences with this sort of situation..

Car in question is a 2010 Ford Fiesta Titanium 1.6 TDCI, great condition, 73k, full service history, bought for typical market value, the usual. It's been quite a series of events so I'll try to keep it simple enough and make a sort of timeline format out of what occurred!

Towards the end of last month a family member bought the car from an independent car dealer, just two weeks after, on the evening of last Tuesday (7/4) the car failed to start. The RAC came along, did a quick roadside diagnosis and clarified it was the fuel system (no fuel flow) and then recovered the car back home later that night, the next day the car was carried to a local reputable diesel specialist and they started a detailed diagnosis. As soon as this happened we contacted the dealer but he claimed it wasn't his problem as no warranty was taken out on the car, he also claimed warranty was offered on purchase (which it was not - he even said it was offered to me over the phone, which I also know is not true..), if a warranty was offered it definitely would've been taken, anyway that part is irrelevant now.

Earlier this week the garage got back to us with the diagnosis, new fuel pump was needed and the whole job would stand at £1050 including VAT. Since this point we had been trying to contact the dealer (calls, messages, voice mail) but he was never available, until this morning when we finally got through to him. We informed him of the quoted price and then the excuses came: "it's our problem because we didn't take the warranty that was supposedly offered, there was nothing wrong with the car on purchase, the quoted price is too much, we've already taken it to a garage so have taken that opportunity away from him" (even though no work has been carried out other than diagnosis).. He then asked for a cost breakdown and for everything in writing, which we have sorted out this afternoon. He did however seem to quieten down a bit after we said we'd send those over and informed him that we had got legal advice.

I understand there is no standalone warranty but situations such as this (should?) be covered by the sales of goods act, I also understand the age and price of the vehicle and repairs are highly relevant if so, in this case a car costing a smidge over £6k with a potential bill of over £1k within 3 weeks of purchase. We've spoken to the RAC legal advice team and they said we stand a good chance if we choose to take it further. Any advice appreciated as this is a first for me ears

Thanks in advance!

16v stretch

990 posts

188 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Speed Plod and Law might be a better forum for this,

But you're still covered by the Sales of Goods act, this is a fairly comprehensive list of what the SOGA covers you for.

Hope you get it sorted.

rigga

8,808 posts

232 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Dealer can't wash his hands of the problem whether warranty was offered and declined or not, sales of goods act is your friend here after such a short space of time.

AM7

Original Poster:

268 posts

160 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
16v stretch said:
Speed Plod and Law might be a better forum for this,

But you're still covered by the Sales of Goods act, this is a fairly comprehensive list of what the SOGA covers you for.

Hope you get it sorted.
I was advised to just drop it in General Gassing, but mods are more than welcome to move it if it's not suitable or they feel it'd get a better response there!

Also I will definitely give that a read, thanks thumbup

Sheepshanks

41,401 posts

150 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Warranties often have a first 30 days exclusion anyway.

Did it not occur to the family member who would have definitely taken the warranty that the car didn't have one?

If you've had proper legal advice then that's better than you're likely to get on an internet forum.

andymc

7,628 posts

238 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
The dealer's problem, £1050 sounds way too much, a pump is under £200

AM7

Original Poster:

268 posts

160 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
Warranties often have a first 30 days exclusion anyway.

Did it not occur to the family member who would have definitely taken the warranty that the car didn't have one?

If you've had proper legal advice then that's better than you're likely to get on an internet forum.
A warranty wasn't necessarily needed on the purchase of a car, but it would've been taken if offered or recommended, if you get what I mean! However as I say the warranty side of things doesn't matter now..

Certainly, we do plan to follow the legal advice but it is also good to hear from other people on the matter as right now we don't know where exactly this is heading and what the most likely outcomes could be. It's far more understandable hearing from someone who has been in the situation rather than somebody telling you what the "usual" procedure is.

rfoster

1,482 posts

285 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
The dealer has responsibility with this issue, regardless of whether you took a warranty or not (under the sale of goods act.). However, you have to give HIM the opportunity to rectify the situation - what you can't do is take it to a different dealer and just land him with the bill (without his prior authorisation)

A pain in the arse, hope you get it sorted.

catman

2,504 posts

206 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
The Dealer needs to sort this out. As said though, you have to give him the chance to fix it, as it would cost him less than you getting it fixed.

He may change his attitude if he knows that you're not going away. The warranty is a red herring.

Tim

iamed

264 posts

205 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
andymc said:
The dealer's problem, £1050 sounds way too much, a pump is under £200
The high pressure fuel pump on my 08 Corsa ecoflex cost about £625 to get replaced (recon unit, including labour).

Butter Face

35,172 posts

191 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Not that it changes anything, but why did you get the car recovered to a different garage instead of the supplying dealer?

If you've only had the diagnosis done, he is now in a position to get the car repaired at his cost on his premises (or where he chooses) you have to give him the chance to do this, if you go ahead and get it repaired elsewhere then stick him a big bill (which I understand is not the case here) then he has every right to fight you (he still has to prove the fault was not present when sold)

Sheepshanks

41,401 posts

150 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
rfoster said:
- what you can't do is take it to a different dealer and just land him with the bill (without his prior authorisation)
Actually the OP probably can. There is a precedent on this. But every case is different.

It's all very well saying the dealer must sort it, but you're a bit stuffed if he pulls down the shutters.

AM7

Original Poster:

268 posts

160 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
iamed said:
andymc said:
The dealer's problem, £1050 sounds way too much, a pump is under £200
The high pressure fuel pump on my 08 Corsa ecoflex cost about £625 to get replaced (recon unit, including labour).
I thought the quote was a bit silly at first, but the pump alone is over £500 (even checked that myself!) and then 8 hours of labour as the fuel pump, from what I hear, is deep down in the engine bay and timing gear may well need to be removed.

The breakdown of costs they gave seems fair enough to be honest and the garage was highly recommended by others.


rfoster said:
The dealer has responsibility with this issue, regardless of whether you took a warranty or not (under the sale of goods act.). However, you have to give HIM the opportunity to rectify the situation - what you can't do is take it to a different dealer and just land him with the bill (without his prior authorisation)

A pain in the arse, hope you get it sorted.
Completely understand, the car went straight to the garage as it needed to be recovered to somewhere, initially we expected a relatively small bill which we would've just paid for ourselves and not bothered with the hassle but of course it's not a small bill so that changes things..

As I say the garage have done no work other than diagnosis (which we are happy to pay for ourselves as that was our decision) so the dealer is free to do as he wishes if that's the case.


Butter Face said:
Not that it changes anything, but why did you get the car recovered to a different garage instead of the supplying dealer?

If you've only had the diagnosis done, he is now in a position to get the car repaired at his cost on his premises (or where he chooses) you have to give him the chance to do this, if you go ahead and get it repaired elsewhere then stick him a big bill (which I understand is not the case here) then he has every right to fight you (he still has to prove the fault was not present when sold)
Unfortunately the car was a good 30 miles from home and even further from the dealer when it failed to start, by the time RAC and then recovery had come to us it was gone 3am, so due to circumstances the car had to be recovered somewhere at short notice and that was local enough to us.

As above, we have no plans to go ahead with further work! Diagnosis done (we're happy to pay for that part), we've sent the invoice for the rest of the work to the dealer so it's now his choice whether he'll go ahead with that or do his own thing.


Thanks all for the input!

Edited by AM7 on Friday 17th April 17:38

Butter Face

35,172 posts

191 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
rfoster said:
- what you can't do is take it to a different dealer and just land him with the bill (without his prior authorisation)
Actually the OP probably can. There is a precedent on this. But every case is different.
Of course you can do that, it's utterly silly to do so as any dealer will fight you.

As many good dealers/repairers there are out there, there are also ones who will look at a 'broken down' recovered car, stick in a lot of extra (unnecessary) work and give the bill to someone else...

Sheepshanks

41,401 posts

150 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Butter Face said:
Of course you can do that, it's utterly silly to do so as any dealer will fight you.
The OP isn't exactly having a lot of joy at the moment....

Dodsy

7,175 posts

258 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
For what its worth I had a lot of problems with a car I bought from a dealer. I gave them 3 goes to fix it, after the 3rd go they would only give me the car back if I paid them £600. So I paid them, immediately issued small claims proceedings and they couldnt refund me fast enough, had their solicitor on the phone within minutes of the legal paperwork arriving offering me money to make it go away.

If you threaten legal action you have to follow through. But you need to give the dealer the opportunity to fix it first.


TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Any bets that the dealer's next comment will be that it must've been caused by mis-fuelling...?

Butter Face

35,172 posts

191 months

Friday 17th April 2015
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
Butter Face said:
Of course you can do that, it's utterly silly to do so as any dealer will fight you.
The OP isn't exactly having a lot of joy at the moment....
Well no, but at the moment consumer law is on his side and he has the high ground.