Stupid cost of second hand parts.
Stupid cost of second hand parts.
Author
Discussion

stuart313

Original Poster:

740 posts

144 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
A few years ago you could pick an engine or gearbox up from the scrappy or loot for about £50, this was for virtually any second hand car you might have driven. Today even for a simple car like a focus you would struggle to get a decent engine for much less than a grand.

When you search for cars invariably the damaged or broken ones show up first in the searches and I have just come across a lovely looking medium sized citroen van about 7 years old with a damaged gearbox, however a quick search on ebay reveals the boxes go for anything up to 2.5K, thats rediculous just for a gearbox, probably 25% of the whole van cost when new. That was a second hand box with about 50K on it, there were cheaper ones on there but not by much and there is no guarantee the will not be sold.

I can only deduce there are that many engines and boxes going wrong nowadays the demand for them is keeping the prices scandalously high.

I would suggest to anyone who is looking to buy a second hand car don't bother with MPG and tax costs and to check the prices of engines/boxes/turbos etc before they buy.

McSam

6,753 posts

206 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
Quite the reverse of your assumption. Major components like engines and gearboxes are now so much more reliable that they are very rarely replaced, so the infrastructure and sales volume for replacements is disappearing. They are also incomparably more complex and expensive to manufacture in the first place.

It wasn't that long ago that engine replacements were quite routine when a car got to mileages we wouldn't even consider high nowadays, so there was plentiful supply. Times have changed. You're not making things easier for yourself by only searching online, though - it's hardly fair to compare that to going down to a scrappy and buying an engine that wasn't advertised and was about to be cubed anyway.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
In 30+ years I've not had to change an engine/gearbox. The cost of these would not be part of my buying decision..

PGN

221 posts

245 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
Why not get the gearbox overhauled rather than replacing it or getting an allegedly reconditioned unit? You need to find someone who know's what they're doing though, which can be tricky - but they are out there. I did this last year and it was definitely the best option.

Lowtimer

4,293 posts

199 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
£2500 for a scrapper gearbox sounds a lot, How much is a proper new one from the dealer network? Can't be much more than that.


Funkycoldribena

7,379 posts

185 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
In 25 years of driving I've never had to replace a clutch let alone gearbox..

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
I find it's more of a problem when people break their own cars for spares and have stupid valuations in mind. With scrappies the price is usually a starting point for negotiation in my experience.

TallPaul

1,524 posts

289 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
If the gearbox is a known weakness (which on those Citroen/Peugeot/Fiat vans it is), they will be in high demand with a limited supply so will always command a premium. Saying that, it is too much money for something thats quite likely not much better than what you're replacing...

rallycross

13,763 posts

268 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
Depends on what car it's for everything has a market value and ebay helps people achieve the market price for stuff;

An Integra type R engine and g/box Dc2 will be about £1750
Last time I had to buy an S2000 s/hand engine we paid close to £2k strong demand for these engines
A 1300cc Ka or Fiesta engine on the other hand will be under £100
I recently had a low mileage Saxo vtr engine that was bought as a spare for my racing car paid £120 but when we came to sell it as no longer required had no interest, best offer was £35 (no one wanted it).


Edited by rallycross on Saturday 18th April 13:32

Andyjc86

1,149 posts

180 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
I just fitted an engine in a vivaro (2.0) for a customer. He supplied the engine, used, 50k, complete (minus starter and alternater). £2100, ouch

Last focus I did (as per OP) was £650 for the engine (1.6 petrol).

Janesy B

2,625 posts

217 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
stuart313 said:
I would suggest to anyone who is looking to buy a second hand car don't bother with MPG and tax costs and to check the prices of engines/boxes/turbos etc before they buy.
Erm, most times cars are scraped because of rust and rot rather than mechanical problems.

laters

324 posts

145 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
For me I have seen prices change for second hand parts from almost nothing to some silly prices depending on where its for sale.
The local scrap yard prices have changed but only by a smaller amount that the price rises of online breakers.

Like a few others I used to buy used engines/gearboxes from the scrap yard (my mother drove reliant regals/robins) so she went through a few engines gearboxes as she wasn't the gentlest driver. A engine used to cost £30-40 and gearbox £20-30 depending.
Ford pinto's that used to get dropped into escorts used to sell for £80-100 & all the other stuff was a similar price. That was a number of years ago and the local scrap yard still only charges £150-250 for a engine unless its something special/rare so I don't see the price rise as being that bad.

When you look on ebay used engines can go for anywhere between local scrap yard prices to silly figures.
The same with electric window motors/electric mirrors. The local scrap yard sells them for a price that's affordable but if its something that they don't have and the search goes to ebay the prices are sometimes not that far off a pattern part, sometimes more.

The prices of used parts to me, especially on ebay etc, are at a artificial level especially considering the value of some of the cars the parts are from.
Rare parts or parts that are known weak items will always sell for more especially if they sell as soon as they go in the breakers/scrap yard.

Edited by laters on Saturday 18th April 14:31

Sir Bagalot

7,114 posts

212 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
Ebay has a wonderful search for sold items. Most expensive sold gearbox was a shade over £2K but this was for a New item. Used items were somewhat cheaper.

J4CKO

47,113 posts

231 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
Janesy B said:
stuart313 said:
I would suggest to anyone who is looking to buy a second hand car don't bother with MPG and tax costs and to check the prices of engines/boxes/turbos etc before they buy.
Erm, most times cars are scraped because of rust and rot rather than mechanical problems.
Not really nowadays, cars generally dont rot for fun liek they used to, the Ford Ka/Puma being a notable exception but generally a ten year old car being scrapped will be in need of a mechanical component like a clutch or a head gasket as gone, can be as simple as needing a couple of suspension components, four tyres and a good valet, it simply comes down to a decision by the owner, if the garage want £1100 to get it through an MOT and its worth £800 then it ends up in the crusher and the owner gets £150 and signs up to a lease or buys another banger.

I think the problem usually comes from people not keeping on top of maintenance and having to pay garage rates rather than DIY rather than the car being actually, completely knackered.



hidetheelephants

36,465 posts

224 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
McSam said:
They are also incomparably more complex and expensive to manufacture in the first place.
Not really; relatively they're getting cheaper every day; think how complex cars are today compared to even 20 years ago, yet the relative price is down. Engineering innovation has brought you this.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
Lowtimer said:
£2500 for a scrapper gearbox sounds a lot, How much is a proper new one from the dealer network? Can't be much more than that.
I was thinking this myself. You could buy a new box for that or get the old one reconditioned for a fraction.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
Janesy B said:
stuart313 said:
I would suggest to anyone who is looking to buy a second hand car don't bother with MPG and tax costs and to check the prices of engines/boxes/turbos etc before they buy.
Erm, most times cars are scraped because of rust and rot rather than mechanical problems.
In 22 years I've not had to get a single engine or box replaced. It certainly isn't a consideration when buying a used car.

Martin4x4

6,506 posts

163 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
The majority of the traditional scrap yards have disappeared, when I was a youth helping my dad there was over a dozen in my home city. Now they mostly all gone what you get are the recycling breakers which are usually part national second hand parts dealers and they charge a fortune for second hand parts. Once stripped of readily saleable components the rest goes straight to the crusher and no longer hang around the yards available for stripping of anything useful.

If you are driving a car/marque that attracts owners clubs you will find they will have members that will buy accident damaged and MOT failures, strip the good and in demand parts and weigh in the rest.

I run an off road Discovery and know a few guys I could go to and one or more will currently be be breaking one for part for their own use. Say one needs a transfer box, instead of buying that they will buy a MOT failure vehicle. Take what they need, sell the other parts to cover the purchase cost. If you are handy with a spanner this becomes a very viable approach.


Edited by Martin4x4 on Saturday 18th April 19:41

Negative Creep

26,153 posts

258 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
Janesy B said:
stuart313 said:
I would suggest to anyone who is looking to buy a second hand car don't bother with MPG and tax costs and to check the prices of engines/boxes/turbos etc before they buy.
Erm, most times cars are scraped because of rust and rot rather than mechanical problems.
In 22 years I've not had to get a single engine or box replaced. It certainly isn't a consideration when buying a used car.
Can't say I do either, I just live in the knowledge the car will get scrapped if it happened. Although surely it's electrics rather than rust that send most modern cars over the bridge of doom?

Mopar440

410 posts

143 months

Saturday 18th April 2015
quotequote all
Janesy B said:
Erm, most times cars are scraped because of rust and rot rather than mechanical problems.
It's when they get scraped that the rust and rot sets in, Shirley?