A good idea of a site?
Author
Discussion

Chiddo

Original Poster:

64 posts

144 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
A few months ago I considered setting up a website dedicated for giving potential buyers of cars a register on cars that had been flagged up by other PB's (potential buyers) as not as described.

So for example. Mrs Brown finds a car in Aberdeen that she liked, she contacts the seller of the car and asks a number of questions about the car history and it's condition - If the pictures shown in ad were that of how the car currently sits condition wise. - Seller responds to Mrs Browns enquiry and states everything mentioned in the advertisement is as described and there are no issues with the car.

Mrs Brown who lives 35 miles away in does a HPI check where the car comes back as more owners stated, has current outstanding finance and was previously written off, all of which seller failed to mention in the ad and when put across by Mrs brown when she contacted seller.

Surprisingly after doing the HPI check, Mrs Brown views the car finds it does not start, the car's condition is not as described. She then goes on the site and flags the car up showing pictures/videos proof of the issues and the information gathered from the HPI check that the owner failed to declare.

Scenario 2: Mr A sees the exact same car, online lives 100 miles away and has never heard of HPI checks before, however he knows of the beware website. Mr A types in the car registration number into the site and is made aware another PB (Mrs Brown) has carried out checks on the car that were not as listed/described by the seller. From checking the register Mr B has saved himself a potential round 200 mile round trip.

Any thoughts on such a site whether it would be a good idea? Obviously there will be measures in place to make sure all reports are accurate and not made up by disgruntled buyers who for example were not happy buyer wouldn't come down on the price of their car for example.

Hoofy

80,190 posts

313 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Useful but (ignoring any possible legal issues) what happens if the seller gets the stuff fixed after the first visit? What if the seller didn't notice a problem because he isn't as mechanically informed as someone else might be? What if the buyer/complainer thinks there's a problem but it's not actually a problem or turns out to be a cheap problem to fix but the buyer thinks it's expensive or diagnosis the wrong problem?

Kev T360

366 posts

182 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
I dont like this. Everyone sees things diferntly, I advertise my 15 year old car as "in fair condition for age" and the buyer might kick off about a few trivial age related marks and then goes home and writes a bad report based on his own clouded judgement. And do you just trust that people will advise you the car is sold so that the next honest owner isnt accused of being mr.bad because the car is still on your site from the previous keeper when he sells his new car a week later due to loss if job etc.

marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
You seem to be describing "Tripadvisor" for car adverts. Think about it - how many complaints have there been about bad reviews, biased reporting, bribery etc. ?

You'll spend more time and money policing it to keep it fair than it's worth.



Kev T360

366 posts

182 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Also what if im selling a 2010 desiel fiesta and see that sombody down the road is also, whats to stop me makeing up a false bad review of the other car to make mine more appleling?

blearyeyedboy

6,814 posts

210 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Chiddo said:
Obviously there will be measures in place to make sure all reports are accurate and not made up by disgruntled buyers
"Hi, can I see your car?"
"Yes, so you're thinking of buying it?"
"No, I want to check to see if it's listed accurately because the aggressive bloke you told to get off your property last week has asked me to say bad things about you on the internet. I make a living out of this, y'know."

Cue a clicking phone, or threats of legal or other reprisals etc.

Tripadvisor can solve this because many customers exist for most hotels. If one punter gives scathing criticism then a good hotel can refute that up with hundreds of good reviews. Private sellers of cars have no such chance to present countering evidence because they will have a maximum of one happy buyer... and if they've got one of those it'd be a moot point anyway.

At best, a Tripadvisor type model of car dealers might work but I would expect a lot of opposition from vested interests.

I wouldn't touch this with a barge pole. Sorry OP, because it's nice to see people think about new ideas for businesses, but I'd have a rethink on this one.

Hoofy

80,190 posts

313 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Might it be better for reviewing car dealers rather than specific cars?