The unscratched itch what car
The unscratched itch what car
Author
Discussion

randomman

Original Poster:

2,215 posts

220 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Ok,

I'm currently eyeing up running a second car to go with the MR2 and the bike. It needs to be more practical and ideally have 5 seats and a boot. Not a particular hard criteria. However I would also like a decent turn of speed (maybe sub 8s to 60) and some half decent handling. The budget is about 2000. Can't have stupid insurance (28, married, professional, middle risk post code, 10 years driving and NCD). I will be doing about 6-8k a year so MPG of around 25 would be nice. I am aware that diesels in this price range can munch themselves very easily so would like to stick to the green nozzle please.

So far I have identified some cars that I lusted over in my "that's vaguely affordable" period of my youth, making them something of an unscratched itch. I've always fancied owning one of the following, however just never got round to it. Each one has some decent characteristic or advantage over the other and I'm definitely leaning towards one over the rest, however in the interest of fairness I wont say until I've had a few replies.

So the list and what I like, I'm looking for input into what I'm missing and other suggestions

Focus ST170 - Seems reliable enough, slower but decent handling
MK1 Leon Cupra 180 - Tunable turbo, slightly more to go wrong, not as inspiring handling
MK4 Golf 2.8 4motion - Not great power or MPG but usable grunt, heavy
Mk4 Golf v5 170 - Same issues as above but slightly lighter. Fairly bombproof
Clio 172 - Seems to be a bit marmite, definitely capable but smaller and more rattly than the rest
Octavia vRS - Basically the Leon but (IMO) a bit uglier and better equipment for the same price

Civic Type R's are dogs in this catagory and I'm not really tempted by the Bavarian Grunt of BMWs at this price range. So what else am I missing.

Cheers for reading

Ali_T

3,379 posts

288 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Alfa 147 2.0 TS? Not common but very lovely. Just budget for occasional wishbone replacements. Alfa 147/156/GTV front wishbones are consumables!

randomman

Original Poster:

2,215 posts

220 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
A solid suggestion, however the 2.0TS just doesn't do anything for me. I know Alfa can do a solid saloon, but as a hatch it just feels like a nice interior and not a lot else. The engine, whilst sound nice is a little lacking too.

Sadly 147 GTAs are out of budget.

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Jag XJR smile

ws323f

56 posts

210 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Honda Accord Type R ?

Great handling and engine, comfortable, large boot. Decent economy too, I managed between 25-30 mpg during normal driving in mine.

£2000 will get a spot on one too.

randomman

Original Poster:

2,215 posts

220 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Hadn't thought of the ACR. Horror stories of 5th gear syncro and the whole lack of 6th do put me off a little. There are only 1 or 2 that I can see that aren't total dogs in that price range though?

so called

9,160 posts

240 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Still not owned an Alfa and can't see anything on the horizon at the moment.
As a kid, promised myself an E-type but I think the closest I will get to that will be an F-type, hopefully within the next three years.
Also I childhood promise was a Bentley Continental which I got lose to getting a couple of years ago.
Also high on the short list is a DB 9 Volante.

ws323f

56 posts

210 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Apparently the facelift models never suffered from the dreaded 5th gear syncro wear. My own pre-facelift model did however, but at the time it was 13 years old with 140k miles on the clock.

I would say that the gearbox is the weak link in the car, the lack of 6th as you said, and when your giving it some, you really need to hit the limiter to keep the car in its VTEC power band.

Really, prices may have went up a bit since the last time I looked at the them a year ago then. There were normally two types for sale - the rougher models that were only really good for spares, or clean examples.

The Big G

1,004 posts

199 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Legnum vr4s and legacy GTBs will offer a lot of fun for the cash as well as the added practicality of estate form although I may be a bit biased wink

Have a look here for more info

Edited by The Big G on Sunday 19th April 14:47

randomman

Original Poster:

2,215 posts

220 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
The Big G said:
Legnum vr4s and legacy GTBs will offer a lot of fun for the cash as well as the added practicality of estate form although I may be a bit biased wink

Have a look here for more info

Edited by The Big G on Sunday 19th April 14:47
I'd love to know where people are finding these in budget? AT, PH and Gumtree seem to pick up about 1 of each in the price range. However as someone who enjoyed that thread when I first saw it, thank you.

Blayney

2,949 posts

217 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
MGZS 180. I hear they handle nicely and they have a nice v6. Should hit your 25mpg and performance requirements. I personally think they look nice. Well inside your budget too.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
BMW e46 330i saloon seems to fit the brief?

Poopipe

619 posts

175 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
If you can live with not having a great deal of space then the 172 is streets ahead of all the ithers in terms of fun - also very good on fuel if you need a justification that sounds sensible. Bork factor is considerably lower than the meg2 as well.

Id go non cup myself - theyre pretty tightly sprung and crashy even in comfy spec plus the cup seats are awful

Codswallop

5,260 posts

225 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Since you're already considering a load of different mk4 Golf platform cars, I recommend you consider the Seat Toledo V5.

Same as the golf V5 but cheaper to buy, better equipment, and a stiffer bodyshell for better handling. I loved my V5 170 and it sounded fantastic with a sports exhaust.

MattHall91

1,275 posts

155 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
so called said:
Still not owned an Alfa and can't see anything on the horizon at the moment.
As a kid, promised myself an E-type but I think the closest I will get to that will be an F-type, hopefully within the next three years.
Also I childhood promise was a Bentley Continental which I got lose to getting a couple of years ago.
Also high on the short list is a DB 9 Volante.
Wrong thread maybe?

randomman

Original Poster:

2,215 posts

220 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Codswallop said:
Since you're already considering a load of different mk4 Golf platform cars, I recommend you consider the Seat Toledo V5.

Same as the golf V5 but cheaper to buy, better equipment, and a stiffer bodyshell for better handling. I loved my V5 170 and it sounded fantastic with a sports exhaust.
Very good suggestion, if the right one comes up I may snap it up, 170s can fetch as low as 1k now, saves a few quid for fuel!

SofaBear

167 posts

223 months

Sunday 19th April 2015
quotequote all
Leon would be what I'd go for, I had a similar choice I was looking at Clio 172 and Focus ST170, the Clio wasn't comfy enough on the motorway for the driving I do, Focus worked for me, not as bad as some people on here make out but still a flawed car, the fuel economy is really bad around town. Though insurance isn't too bad on either, I'm 25, only had by licence since October '14 and it was £800. (that is a lot, but for my circumstances it's spare change).

The Big G

1,004 posts

199 months

Monday 20th April 2015
quotequote all
randomman said:
The Big G said:
Legnum vr4s and legacy GTBs will offer a lot of fun for the cash as well as the added practicality of estate form although I may be a bit biased wink

Have a look here for more info

Edited by The Big G on Sunday 19th April 14:47
I'd love to know where people are finding these in budget? AT, PH and Gumtree seem to pick up about 1 of each in the price range. However as someone who enjoyed that thread when I first saw it, thank you.
There is a early vr4 on eBay at the moment. The face lifts are generally a bit more though. As with all jap stuff of his vintage, make sure it's not rotten. Good cheap ones don't come up regularly though, you'll have to keep your eyes peeled

so called

9,160 posts

240 months

Monday 20th April 2015
quotequote all
MattHall91 said:
so called said:
Still not owned an Alfa and can't see anything on the horizon at the moment.
As a kid, promised myself an E-type but I think the closest I will get to that will be an F-type, hopefully within the next three years.
Also I childhood promise was a Bentley Continental which I got lose to getting a couple of years ago.
Also high on the short list is a DB 9 Volante.
Wrong thread maybe?
I was a but drunk last night.
Sorry smile

bigkeeko

1,370 posts

174 months

Monday 20th April 2015
quotequote all
so called said:
I was a but drunk
You maybe still are