Do you trust online reviews?
Discussion
As the title says, how much trust do you put in online reviews?
I bought a couple of things recently which were not great. Both items were reviewed as 4.5 out of 5, with hundreds of reviews.
What is going on? Either my standards are much higher than everyone else (not likely) or there are a lot of fake reviews out there.
I'm starting to think that the old fashioned way of doing things i.e. go to the shop, see the item, make up your own mind might be the only solution.
I bought a couple of things recently which were not great. Both items were reviewed as 4.5 out of 5, with hundreds of reviews.
What is going on? Either my standards are much higher than everyone else (not likely) or there are a lot of fake reviews out there.
I'm starting to think that the old fashioned way of doing things i.e. go to the shop, see the item, make up your own mind might be the only solution.
I use the reviews to steer my opinion and try and validate elsewhere. I have shopped online very successfully, only one issue with one product in the last year and sorted immediately by the retailer - no hassle. I'd much rather that than having to drag myself around a town centre on the weekend!
NelsonP said:
As the title says, how much trust do you put in online reviews?
I bought a couple of things recently which were not great. Both items were reviewed as 4.5 out of 5, with hundreds of reviews.
What is going on? Either my standards are much higher than everyone else (not likely) or there are a lot of fake reviews out there.
I'm starting to think that the old fashioned way of doing things i.e. go to the shop, see the item, make up your own mind might be the only solution.
I normally use it as a guide. If i have 2 or 3 items to choose from i try and take a look at the reviews as user feedback might sway me one way or the other. Also remember your expectations might be different, also sods law you could have bought the lemon version that constantly breaks. I bought a couple of things recently which were not great. Both items were reviewed as 4.5 out of 5, with hundreds of reviews.
What is going on? Either my standards are much higher than everyone else (not likely) or there are a lot of fake reviews out there.
I'm starting to think that the old fashioned way of doing things i.e. go to the shop, see the item, make up your own mind might be the only solution.
I worry that some of the retailer reviews might be bent; how do "online review" sites prevent fiddling? Company I was looking to buy something recent had on an independant review site 350 glowing 5* reviews, 30 4* and over 100 1* saying they were absolutely dire.
This is where sites like facebook could expand and be really useful, as reviews backed up by appreciably real people would be worth something.
This is where sites like facebook could expand and be really useful, as reviews backed up by appreciably real people would be worth something.
drivin_me_nuts said:
It depends. I tend to search forums before purchasing from an unknown to me company. this follows an abysmal experience from a jeweller in northern Ireland. Forums at least give a response other than the spiel of 'amazing' and 'awesome' often read on the sites themselves.
I tend to do this. To be honest most of the stuff I buy online is stuff I've purchased over the years from shops. Can't say actual reviews really sway my decision. NelsonP said:
Either my standards are much higher than everyone else (not likely) or there are a lot of fake reviews out there.
What was it about the product that differed from the reviews other people left?Could it be a difference of opinion or even a faulty item?
We sell online and can sell 10 of exactly the same item - 9 people think it's wonderful, and 1 person will think it's the worst thing in the world. No difference in the product, just a difference in opinion.
It just seems odd that there were hundreds of positive reviews for something - would a company even bother?
northwest monkey said:
We sell online and can sell 10 of exactly the same item - 9 people think it's wonderful, and 1 person will think it's the worst thing in the world. No difference in the product, just a difference in opinion.
I often go straight to neg reviews and try to read between the lines, it's normally quite easy to tell if they have a genuine grievance or are just sobbing that their life isn't all they wanted it to be.northwest monkey said:
It just seems odd that there were hundreds of positive reviews for something - would a company even bother?
If a company has 50 neg reviews then submitting 200 false positives will give them a 4 out of 5 average which a lot of punters will glance at think it's "good enough"The actual review site and quality of reviews are the major determinants. Amazon, Booking.com, Qype, TripAdvisor, etc on balance are very good because there is a self-correcting mechanism and it is easy to determine useful reviews from the not so useful. Do your research and read a broad spectrum of reviews and you'll generally won't be disappointed.
Note: when buying big ticket items, stick to retailers that provide a good returns, warranty policy, etc. I'd rather spend a little more and have peace of mind that I can trust the retailer to resolve a problem than have the ball-ache of buying a lemon and than dealing with a recalcitrant retailer and spending half my life writing letters, emails, having to record delivery everything for proof, yada yada yada.
I bought my fiancées engagement ring online from a company last year. Never heard of them before, but performed some research, checked out reviews on Trust Pilot (that I never used before), and everything went smoothly. Excellent service and fiancée was pleased with my choice. Again it comes down to recommendations from sites and users whom you either know or judge to be legit. Mumsnet was actually helpful in this regard, as was PH.
Note: when buying big ticket items, stick to retailers that provide a good returns, warranty policy, etc. I'd rather spend a little more and have peace of mind that I can trust the retailer to resolve a problem than have the ball-ache of buying a lemon and than dealing with a recalcitrant retailer and spending half my life writing letters, emails, having to record delivery everything for proof, yada yada yada.
I bought my fiancées engagement ring online from a company last year. Never heard of them before, but performed some research, checked out reviews on Trust Pilot (that I never used before), and everything went smoothly. Excellent service and fiancée was pleased with my choice. Again it comes down to recommendations from sites and users whom you either know or judge to be legit. Mumsnet was actually helpful in this regard, as was PH.
hairyben said:
northwest monkey said:
We sell online and can sell 10 of exactly the same item - 9 people think it's wonderful, and 1 person will think it's the worst thing in the world. No difference in the product, just a difference in opinion.
I often go straight to neg reviews and try to read between the lines, it's normally quite easy to tell if they have a genuine grievance or are just sobbing that their life isn't all they wanted it to be.northwest monkey said:
It just seems odd that there were hundreds of positive reviews for something - would a company even bother?
If a company has 50 neg reviews then submitting 200 false positives will give them a 4 out of 5 average which a lot of punters will glance at think it's "good enough"We've had some stupid reviews on Amazon - 3/5 was one item as she'd "bought it for a gift so I don't know if it's any good or not yet"

northwest monkey said:
What was it about the product that differed from the reviews other people left?
Could it be a difference of opinion or even a faulty item?
As an example - one of the purchases was some kitchen bar stools. Reviews (on the sellers own site) were all overwhelmingly positive, saying things like great, fab product, strong, easy to assemble, speedy delivery etc. All either 4 or 5 out of 5 stars.Could it be a difference of opinion or even a faulty item?
To be fair their delivery service was excellent. You could track the delivery yourself in real time. Don't know why more folks don't use it.
But the product was rubbish. When they arrived some of the joints in the wood were cracked. The timber was of varying quality and colour. They looked as though they would last approximately 5 minutes. We bought 3 stools and I could only assemble one of them by using the serviceable parts from all three boxes and junking the rest.
So we're now into returns / after sales service etc. Which will be a joy I'm sure.
northwest monkey said:
We've had some stupid reviews on Amazon - 3/5 was one item as she'd "bought it for a gift so I don't know if it's any good or not yet"
I recently bought some supplements for one of my dogs, one review was "Dog died before I could try them!!!" and gave it 3 stars. 

Hooli said:
Depends on the website.
I don't trust them on laterooms, because we once booked a hotel that I reviewed as 'unfit for human habitation' via them & the hotel were allowed to veto the review. So no wonder everywhere gets good ratings.
We had that happen with a very well known site that Advises people who are thinking of taking a Trip. I don't trust them on laterooms, because we once booked a hotel that I reviewed as 'unfit for human habitation' via them & the hotel were allowed to veto the review. So no wonder everywhere gets good ratings.
Complained about a hotel which had terrible service, the hotel had that comment removed and suddenly a flurry of over the top 5* reviews appeared on it's page.....
I review on Trip Advisor a lot and I am honest but you have to read the reviews to see why they gave that rating. I downgraded a restaurant as they had a play area open late at night with screeching children that were not supervised. In fact when the parents were approached they complained themselves about being victimised. The staff were helpless.
However if you have small children, it may appeal to you.
I actually read the reviews and judge if the issue they had would affect me. Sometimes it is irrelevant (or even spurious).
I am about to buy a new dishwasher so I will research reviews from various different sites before purchase.
However if you have small children, it may appeal to you.
I actually read the reviews and judge if the issue they had would affect me. Sometimes it is irrelevant (or even spurious).
I am about to buy a new dishwasher so I will research reviews from various different sites before purchase.
Gassing Station | The Lounge | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




)