eBay woes
Author
Discussion

Evolved

Original Poster:

4,079 posts

218 months

Friday 8th May 2015
quotequote all
Wondered where I stand here.

Bought myself a Sigma 24-70 lens off eBay, turned up and excitedly attached it to my camera only to discover the camera wouldn't power up with it on, assumed a flat battery to stuck it on to charge! Tried it again to discover it wouldn't power on again, removed the lens and attached one of my others, camera started and took pictures.

Attached the other lens and turned it on, this time the power came on but it didn't recognise the lens thinking it didn't have one attached. I closely studied the lens to discover a lot of the small retaining screws around the mount were tampered with and worn so had clearly been messed with.

I've opened a dispute with eBay to which he's replied saying the lens works and he assumes I've just had a change of heart though does admit the screws being worn is shown in the pics (can't say I studied the pics that close as they're around 3mm screw heads). He's said that if he gets it back and it works he will be sending back to me an calling it a day with no refund. I have supplied pics of the tampering and my camera showing no lens attached being shown on the screen.

Where do I stand on this?

sday12

5,068 posts

242 months

Friday 8th May 2015
quotequote all
With ebay always siding with buyer, I'ld say very well.

Loudy McFatass

8,999 posts

218 months

Friday 8th May 2015
quotequote all
Generally I've found eBay side with the buyer (in my experience).

He won't be "just calling it a day". There's a procedure to follow which you've done.

if it's been tampered with and you've sent evidence then I'm pretty sure they'll rule in your favour, but you never know.

velocefica

4,732 posts

139 months

Friday 8th May 2015
quotequote all
Had this a few times myself.

If the buyer knows whats good for him he will ask you to return it and cover the postage and refund you.

If he doesn't then you'll get your money plus postage back and eBay will tell you to em 'dispose' of said item.

Evolved

Original Poster:

4,079 posts

218 months

Saturday 23rd May 2015
quotequote all
Strange thing has happened.

Had the refund label from the seller so sent the item back, item received and signed for and finally had a refund for the full amount which was processed yesterday, this was after initially receiving an email saying the refund hadn't been processed. I phoned eBay who told me the account was probably in minus when the refund tried to process and I should give it time which I did and the refund finally went trough, I have now withdrawn the funds back to my account.

I've now had an email from eBay stating that they have reviewed the case and they have ruled in the sellers favour so no refund will be issued - WTF?! Now I've obviously had the refund and he has the lens back but I'm totally confused with this email. What will happen now and why the hell have they ruled in his favour AFTER he has the item back and the refund has been issued.

essdaytwelve

5,068 posts

242 months

Saturday 23rd May 2015
quotequote all
Beggars belief.

but if you've got your refund and withdrawn it your PayPal will just go into debit.

Close PayPal and ebay accounts and move on!

Evolved

Original Poster:

4,079 posts

218 months

Saturday 23rd May 2015
quotequote all
So Paypal can't just pull the money from my account?

essdaytwelve

5,068 posts

242 months

Sunday 24th May 2015
quotequote all
No, not from your bank account, but a negative balance on your PayPal.

AMD87

2,004 posts

233 months

Sunday 24th May 2015
quotequote all
I've had this before when I logged a dispute when someone sold me a "genuine" laptop charger.

Logged a dispute and eBay found in the sellers favour after the seller refunded me as the seller had followed the correct procedure by refunding it therefore no reason for them to get further involved.

Could just be that?

Evolved

Original Poster:

4,079 posts

218 months

Sunday 24th May 2015
quotequote all
Similar, basically he had refunded directly so the case was still open hence them ruling in his favour as the system would automatically rule in my favour and refund again meaning he was out of pocket.

Live and learn and no harm done, can buy a working lens now.

AMD87 said:
I've had this before when I logged a dispute when someone sold me a "genuine" laptop charger.

Logged a dispute and eBay found in the sellers favour after the seller refunded me as the seller had followed the correct procedure by refunding it therefore no reason for them to get further involved.

Could just be that?