Obesity in Children
Author
Discussion

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,427 posts

292 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all


Article in today's telegraph about Childhood obesity.

I just don't believe these figures. I know I live in a bit of a Surrey bubble, but this cannot be true? Can it?

In total, 25 per cent of children are obese or overweight by the age of seven, rising to 35 per cent by the age of 11, according to a study of 11,000 British children.

Full article

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/nhs/11592808/Goldi...

Terminator X

21,020 posts

235 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
I call bullst, hardly any fat kids round here. Newspapers selling papers etc.

TX.

Edit - regardless, the parents of fat kids do need to slap themselves.

Edited by Terminator X on Sunday 10th May 21:53

rehab71

3,362 posts

221 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
I don't believe it either when I read articles like this, but as you say we live in a relatively wealthy part of the country here in the South.. I'm sure in the big cities in the Midlands and the North this could be true. Don't want to generalise 'up north' nor offend, so I'm guessing a bit.

twing

5,836 posts

162 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
I call custard!

iva cosworth

44,044 posts

194 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
twing said:
I call custard!
Skimmed or full fat milk ?...confused

Dodsy

7,175 posts

258 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
Its all lies and statistics. I remember when my oldest came home from school with a letter telling us he had been tested and found to be obese, borderline morbidly obese and they wanted him to go on a special diet immediately.

He was the tallest in his class, did karate 3 times a week, cycled every day and swam 1 or 2 days a week and had a healthy diet. Took after me and was skinny as a rake, in fact he looked under nourished but was all muscle.

Apparently they only weight them and if they are too heavy then the file gets tagged as obese. They dont worry about little things like height and build. Just weight.

All this crap spouted by the press about how so many kids are obese is based on these measurements.

Gargamel

Original Poster:

16,427 posts

292 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
Glad it isn't just me.

One third of all kids are obese by age Eleven. Just doesn't fit with my experience when I am collecting my lot from school.

This is supposedly a clinical study, it is just nonsense.

eldar

25,363 posts

227 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
I call bullst, hardly any fat kids round here. Newspapers selling papers etc.

TX.

Edit - regardless, the parents of fat kids do need to slap themselves.

Edited by Terminator X on Sunday 10th May 21:53
I have the pleasure of living in the place with the most overweight population - 76% allegedly overweight or obese. Being north a lot of pies do get consumed but 76% is bks.

As you say, papers selling papers.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-26037619

RobinBanks

17,551 posts

210 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
My sister was told she was obese when she was 12. She was heavier than most 12 year old girls but she was also 5'10".

I think that this is just rubbish.

austinsmirk

5,597 posts

154 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
Might as well link this to the council thread.

It us noticeable how fat kids and teenagers are now. Especially girls in their early 20's etc

Crush

15,078 posts

200 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
We know a couple who give into their child's tantrums by giving them sweets. Unsurprisingly their four year old looks like a dough ball with legs. They have now ended up in a vicious circle that they're terrified to break in case their child has a flounce.


Impasse

15,099 posts

272 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
Crush said:
We know a couple who give into their child's tantrums by giving them sweets. Unsurprisingly their four year old looks like a dough ball with legs. They have now ended up in a vicious circle that they're terrified to break in case their child has a flounce.
A good old flounce can be great exercise.

numtumfutunch

5,185 posts

169 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all

Our 10y old came home from school earlier this year saying that the PE teacher had asked her class to run 100m and the vast majority couldnt without stopping to catch their breath and then walk


R8VXF

6,794 posts

146 months

Monday 11th May 2015
quotequote all
Blame it on BMI. Useful as a population study not at an individual level. BF% is a far better judge of a persons health level. Just a lot harder to measure than just measuring height and weight.

Hoofy

80,186 posts

313 months

Monday 11th May 2015
quotequote all
I work with children... and most of them are normal sized. And I say this as someone who is obsessed with having a decent physique. So this article is st. Or all the obese kids are hidden away from visitors. Nothing wrong with having a bit of puppy fat but that doesn't make them obese - maybe 1 in 15 I'd be thinking their parents need to do something.

northwest monkey

6,370 posts

220 months

Monday 11th May 2015
quotequote all
You could probably say the general area where I live is a fairly "poor" area in the North - a mix of people & housing and at my sons primary school there are certainly some really fat kids. The thing is though, out of 220 - 230 kids in the entire school I'd say there are less than 10 that are really fat - certainly nowhere near as high as the article suggests.

There are some right fat fkers as parents though - I'm quite "powerfully built" but some of the ones I see are awful.

ukbabz

1,649 posts

157 months

Monday 11th May 2015
quotequote all
Take a walk down the highstreet or the nearest supermarket on a weekend. Full of fat parents with waddling fat kids. The bigger cities and up north seems to be worse for this.

S10GTA

13,817 posts

198 months

Monday 11th May 2015
quotequote all
R8VXF said:
Blame it on BMI. Useful as a population study not at an individual level. BF% is a far better judge of a persons health level. Just a lot harder to measure than just measuring height and weight.
This. BMI is massively flawed.

LordGrover

34,189 posts

243 months

Monday 11th May 2015
quotequote all
Hoofy said:
I work with children... and most of them are normal sized. And I say this as someone who is obsessed with having a decent physique. So this article is st. Or all the obese kids are hidden away from visitors. Nothing wrong with having a bit of puppy fat but that doesn't make them obese - maybe 1 in 15 I'd be thinking their parents need to do something.
What's 'normal size' though?
Today's 'norm' for adults is larger/fatter than it used to be.

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Monday 11th May 2015
quotequote all
yes In the UK "normal", as in median, body fat percentage is unhealthily high so anyone who looks "normal" is almost certainly unhealthily fat.

Yes, BMI isn't perfect but it serves its purpose in that it's a reasonable (albeit not infallible) metric for people who get an average amount of exercise (ie almost none); those who do exercise a lot are likely to understand enough about its flaws not to use it. If you plotted body fat percentage against BMI for the UK populous, you'd get a pretty strong correlation with the outliers generally knowing that they are outliers and hence why BMI isn't a valid metric for measuring their health.

Edited by kambites on Monday 11th May 09:19